Northern California Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

How would you feel?

My BIL is studying psychology. He is a super nice guy and I know he is very excited about what he is learning and he forwards articles that he thinks are "helpful" to us. I asked him to stop sending me parenting stuff, it just feels like he is saying "hey, you need this because you are doing something wrong". Then he sent some depression thing and my DH actually got a little up in arms. He then said it must have triggered something. It's like you can't win, if you get defensive, you must be the person that needs it the most. 

So would you just take it in stride and figure it was coming from a place of good intention, or would it bug you? I can't quite explain it. It's like my brother used to say jokingly his favorite expression was "that's part of your problem..". Gee, I didn't know i had such problems.  

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: How would you feel?

  • I would tell your BIL that if you need help with anything or need to talk that you'll be the one to ask for it. "Please stop offering me unsolicited advice, I know your intentions are good but it bothers me that you think I can't make up my own mind."
    Me (33)& DX: DOR, FSH-20.3; DH(28):SA=normal 8/11 HSG= clear!
    IUI #1 10/12/11 (Bravelle + HCG + Prometrium & acupuncture) = 10/26 BFP! Beta #1=250, Beta #2= 615. 1st u/s 11/8. image Visit The Nest! Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • So have you asked him to stop already? If you haven't I would, politely. If he continues after that, just delete them. My MIL sent me an email recently that ignorantly and inaccurately bashed my profession. Annoying, but she's dingy. Unfortunately sounds like your BIL is more aware so he doesn't have that excuse.
    My favorite place on earth: The Amargosa Valley.
    image
  • Yeah, that's annoying.  Ask him to stop and if he doesn't, start searching the Internet for random chain mail that you can forward him every time he e-mails you something "helpful." Devil
    I'd rather be rock climbing or playing volleyball
    imageimage
  • imageRock-n-Voll:
    Yeah, that's annoying.  Ask him to stop and if he doesn't, start searching the Internet for random chain mail that you can forward him every time he e-mails you something "helpful." Devil

    Ha! Particularly ones from Snopes.com that are totally wrong but people believe. Awesome sauce.

    My favorite place on earth: The Amargosa Valley.
    image
  • imagePassanie:
    So have you asked him to stop already? If you haven't I would, politely. If he continues after that, just delete them. My MIL sent me an email recently that ignorantly and inaccurately bashed my profession. Annoying, but she's dingy. Unfortunately sounds like your BIL is more aware so he doesn't have that excuse.

    Well, Passanie, yours doesn't really count. You ARE part of the Liberal Media And Its Agenda. Smile

    ETA that yes, that is annoying, and I'd try to find some articles about the dangers of offering unsolicited advice that I'd send right back to him.

  • Yeah, that would annoy me.  Maybe be stern when you tell him thanks but no thanks.  Then hopefully he'll get the hint.
    My wedding Bio My baking Blog View from Le'ahi Diamond Head image
  • I would be VERY unhappy...especially after you've already asked.

  • I asked him to stop sending me the parenting stuff but now he sent this depression thing. I hate when people act all high and mighty, like "Oh I just thought it might be helpful" like when someone tells you you're too skinny/too fat/too this too that, etc. It's judgmental. Anyway, it's touchy because he lives with us. Sigh. Thanks for at least validating my annoyance. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Like pp mentioned, tell him politely to stop sending them. Don't read them or mark/block all emails from him as spam. Devil
  • I would send really obnoxious articles back to him for every one that he sends you.  They would consist mostly of erectile dysfunction etc. Devil

  • imageCheekyGirl22:

    I would send really obnoxious articles back to him for every one that he sends you.  They would consist mostly of erectile dysfunction etc. Devil

     

    bwahahahha!! I LOVE this idea!

    ****missing my little angel since 11/28/12 (m/c 8.4 weeks)**** Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • Yes, it would bother me. A lot. That's totally inappropriate. Part of studying psychology, I would hope, would be to teach students when and how it's suitable to offer their expertise. You're a doctor; you don't go around inspecting and pushing treatment on your family members. You guys aren't his patients, and you've already asked him to stop. He needs to listen, and his belief that you being "defensive" proves him right is not at all relevant. He needs to understand that his behavior, despite what his intentions are, has a detrimental impact on your relationship with him.

    You've asked nicely. Maybe now it's time to get more firm. I would not get sucked into debates on whether his "diagnosis" is right or wrong; I would focus on the fact that you're not interested in these articles, you've asked him to stop, and his refusal to listen is disrespectful and irritating. If he still doesn't listen, I suggest sending him periodic emails about topics that offend/don't interest him, perhaps a newsletter from this museum?

    Good luck!

  • Unfortunately I have known a few psych students like this. For awhile one of my bros was studying psych and thought he could cure everyone. How old is he? If you've asked already once, I would mention it again more firmly. If he doesn't change then I would just ignore/delete them. Eventually he'll grow out of it/stop.
  • Yes, I'm noticing it is sort of a global, irritating tendency to psychoanalyze everything I say. "what's the question behind the question?" and "Why did your experience cause you to feel that way?" etc etc. It's sort of driving me crazy, thanks for all the support. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards