September 2010 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Registry for 3rd Baby

At work, they're throwing a surprise baby shower for a woman who is having her third baby.  That doesn't bother me, because people like to celebrate and she doesn't even know about it.  I was surprised, though, that she has two registries (both were mentioned in the e-mail invite) and that there are quite a lot of very expensive items on them (and only two inexpensive items).

The organizer of the shower mentioned that this woman gave away a lot of her baby stuff after her second child, so she needs everything for her third child.  Which makes sense, but it still feels a little weird to me, especially since a lot of the items aren't 'necessities' or are duplicates, like 2 bottle warmers, 2 different $150 swings, 2 playards (which is like a playpen/crib thing, I found out). I guess I see it both ways: it sucks not to have all this stuff, but if I were in this position I wouldn't register for these items.

I know that I can choose to decline or get her diapers and onesies and ignore the registry, but I'm wondering if she might have registered differently if she knew there was going to be a work shower with a ton of people invited.  Or am I being a complete fuddy-duddy for thinking this registry is kind of gift-grabby?  It doesn't change my opinion of her or anything, I still think she's a really sweet person and I want to go to the shower, but I think the registry is in bad taste and maybe I'm crazy for feeling that way.

Image and video hosting by TinyPic
Lilypie First Birthday tickers

Re: Registry for 3rd Baby

  • mushEmushE member
    Fourth Anniversary

    Um, whut?  I vote in bad taste.  It could be that they're outfitting their house and a relatives who will watch the kid, or something like that.  We'll be doing some of that, since my mom wants to watch the kid 2 days/week, which may be at her house, depending on where I'm working.  But sheesh, I wouldn't register.

    I honestly don't even want ONE baby shower, and this is my first kid. 

    image
  • I think baby showers are appropriate when kids are far apart. Otherwise a more casual celebratory lunch should suffice for the following kids.

    I am always in favor of registering and on those registries in have three price points: low, medium and high. I think it's a no no not to have the lower two price points no matter what the occasion. Knock yourself out and put all of your expensive wishes on there, but for people who'd like to get you a gift but not that huge of one, give them some options too.

    image
  • I didn't think about the possibility of one for her house, one for someone who will be watching the baby.  That does make sense...but it still seems weird to register for both.  And like I said, she may have done it differently if she knew there would be a shower - who knows, maybe she set this up for a completion discount, or because close friends/family had expressed an interest in buying her some big-ticket items.

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • mushEmushE member
    Fourth Anniversary

    Interesting.  I'd assume that since this is a surprise shower, that she's registered for stuff to get the discount, but I like to assume the best in people. 

    You're probably right, that if she knew she was getting the work shower, she'd have registered differently. 

    Also, since she's already a mom, she's got a better idea of how much of the cheaper stuff they'd need, like clothes and burp cloths, and stuff like that.

    image
  • For me that's tacky. One baby shower for your first, maybe another if your kids are really far apart? If you just want a fun lunch with the women in your family and they would like to bring something then you call it a sprinkle and the only thing that is allowed is diapers and bottles. If she was just making a registry for family and herself why did they include it in the invite? I would not buy a coworker a 150 swing. Heck my SIL got some clothes from me and that was it!
  • Her first two kids are sort of far apart (5 or 6 years?) but her second daughter is 3 so I don't really consider that a big gap between her and the new baby.  I don't really know what constitutes 'far apart' though.

    The e-mail mentioned that people are going in together for a big gift, but I didn't ask for more details because I'm doing something with two co-workers.  So it's not ridiculous to have big items on there, I just wish there were small things too.  I know that I can pick out small things on my own, but I like knowing I got something the person likes (which is why I like registries).  Plus I spend way less on baby showers than, say, wedding gifts, so I feel like there need to be more things in the low and mid-range price points.

    I don't know how the organizer got the registry info...to give the woman the benefit of the doubt, maybe the organizer looked it up on her own?

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • 3 is not far apart! My mom had Kane 5 years after Sean and never had one even though she had given all of her stuff away. I think it's meant for like more than 10 years gap, like Toby's cousins baby, his wifes first kid is 12 and then theirs was just born in Feb. That is acceptable to me.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards