Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

I'm thinking of legal seperation.....

How would you handle this?

 Well DH and I have been married for almost 3 years, and we have been having issues with his parents interfering in our marriage.  However, I have reason to believe that DH maybe behind all of this, because he tells me one thing and I feel that he tells his parents the total opposite.  I catch him saying certain things that leads me to believe that he tells his parents personal things that he his not happy within our relationship, and on the other hand he tells me he is fine and that he loves our life together. 

 I truly feel that my MIL is still a noisy lady and crosses the line sometimes, but I also feel that DH maybe influencing her to feel the way that she does, and maybe she feels that she is looking out for her son.

I really don't know what to do, because when confronted about it he trys to reverse it and make it seem like I'm blaming him for everything, he will not accept responsibility for this behavior.  I feel that it is very immature for him to act this way.

I also feel betrayed because I feel he is the reason why his mother always comes to me with issues, because he runs to them as if everything is my fault.  I know this because he doesn't vouch for me when his mother goes on the deep end.  I don't feel protected, and it has gotten to the point that I don't know what he has told his parents and maybe they have a reason for treating me certain ways because of the things he may have said to them.  I can 't trust him anymore.  I have always been loyal to him, because I keep our personal disputes between us, and I don't involve my family; however I just recently confided with my sister because I needed someone to talk to about some things that I have been going through, and she is really upset about all of this.

 What should I do?  I'm really contemplating on moving out.  I'm not sure that things will ever get better.

Re: I'm thinking of legal seperation.....

  • doglovedoglove member
    5000 Comments Fifth Anniversary 5 Love Its Combo Breaker

    I think you have some pretty valid feelings here and I too would be upset in your situation. Have you tried speaking to him about this? Although it's probably a long shot that he could changed if this is how he has always been.

    I had a fiance that sounds just like your husband. He told his mother everything personal about me and us and I felt like she was a part of our relationship. I tried to express to him how I felt, but pleasing her was more important to him than having a relationship with me. In the end I left and am glad I did. I wanted a man who could be my partner and who could talk to me about his feelings and not share personal information with anyone else outside of our relationship.

    Have you thought about counseling for yourself? This might help you make a decision and also figure out why you were attracted to a man like this in the first place.

  • It sounds like you're ready to leave him, so maybe you should.  When it gets to this point, when resentment has built and trust has eroded to the point that you'd rather leave than keep fighting for something better together, then it's probably not fixable.
    image
  • imagedoglove:

    I think you have some pretty valid feelings here and I too would be upset in your situation. Have you tried speaking to him about this? Although it's probably a long shot that he could changed if this is how he has always been.

    I had a fiance that sounds just like your husband. He told his mother everything personal about me and us and I felt like she was a part of our relationship. I tried to express to him how I felt, but pleasing her was more important to him than having a relationship with me. In the end I left and am glad I did. I wanted a man who could be my partner and who could talk to me about his feelings and not share personal information with anyone else outside of our relationship.

    Have you thought about counseling for yourself? This might help you make a decision and also figure out why you were attracted to a man like this in the first place.

    I didn't realize he was like this until I started to pay attention to little things that he would do...The way that I feel right now is that doesn't care how I feel and that the issues that I'm having is my problem...because he made a comment asking me quote "Do you want me to talk with my mother? I'm just trying to help "you" out""

    I took that as if he feels that he is not affected by none of whats going on, and that everything is my problem alone!!!!!

  • Well, how do you answer that?  Do you say "No, I don't want you to talk to your f*cking mother, the problem is that you tell TOO MUCH to your f*cking mother already!" and maybe bang your shoe on the table, or what?
    image
  • doglovedoglove member
    5000 Comments Fifth Anniversary 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    It sounds like everything is your problem alone because he refuses to admit that there is a problem?
  • imagedoglove:
    It sounds like everything is your problem alone because he refuses to admit that there is a problem?

    He is just 2 faced simple as that....

  • I get the impression that he's going to be completely shocked when you walk out. You are completely blaming him for the demise of your relationship, lack of trust and feelings of betrayl. He may very well deserve it. But does he know how you feel? At all? Its all well and good for him to play the victim and take no responsibility for his actions/role - but does he realize you are about to walk out on him for it? Because you posted "he tells me he is fine and that he loves our life together." YOU don't love your life together. You're at rock bottom and I don't think he has a clue.

    So, I would recommend two things:

    1- Secure an attorney to protect your finacial assests. Get your ducks in a row so you know what papers you have to collect, what to expect from a separation/divorce and what it will cost you.

    2- Tell your DH that you are miserable and are seriously planning to walk out unless things change. Then tell him what needs to change. Then start doing what YOU can to make those changes.

    Then see how it goes and if you still want a separation.

    My darling daughter just turned 4 years old.
  • imagelivinitup:

    I get the impression that he's going to be completely shocked when you walk out. You are completely blaming him for the demise of your relationship, lack of trust and feelings of betrayl. He may very well deserve it. But does he know how you feel? At all? Its all well and good for him to play the victim and take no responsibility for his actions/role - but does he realize you are about to walk out on him for it? Because you posted "he tells me he is fine and that he loves our life together." YOU don't love your life together. You're at rock bottom and I don't think he has a clue.

    So, I would recommend two things:

    1- Secure an attorney to protect your finacial assests. Get your ducks in a row so you know what papers you have to collect, what to expect from a separation/divorce and what it will cost you.

    2- Tell your DH that you are miserable and are seriously planning to walk out unless things change. Then tell him what needs to change. Then start doing what YOU can to make those changes.

    Then see how it goes and if you still want a separation.

    Oh he does have a clue.  I express to him all the time that about how I feel...the fact is that he expresses to me how he feels and then tells his family something totally different when we have our marital disputes...He knows how I feel, but he doesn't think that what he is doing is wrong, because what I'm going through is not directly affecting him.  I have told him that I'm going to leave him because of this before, and I stayed thinking that things would get better....but they have not.  He is not oblivious to what is going on...he is fully aware of the manipulation he is putting me through...he is just trying to play victim on both ends....

  • imagemarceneaux:

     I have told him that I'm going to leave him because of this before, and I stayed thinking that things would get better....but they have not.  He is not oblivious to what is going on...he is fully aware of the manipulation he is putting me through...he is just trying to play victim on both ends....

     Sounds like it's time to back up your threat with action.

    Have you suggested counseling to him?

  • doglovedoglove member
    5000 Comments Fifth Anniversary 5 Love Its Combo Breaker

    imagemarceneaux:
      I have told him that I'm going to leave him because of this before, and I stayed thinking that things would get better....but they have not. 

    Sounds like he's called your bluff. Why should it get any better if there are no consequences for his actions?

  • We have gone through counseling before, and I just don't think he gets how serious this is.

  • imagemarceneaux:

    We have gone through counseling before, and I just don't think he gets how serious this is.

    Oh, then you should probably not waste any more of your life waiting around for him to figure out how to be a decent partner.  Sorry this is happening to you.

  • It sounds like your decision is made and you are looking for validation. I will give it to you. Your H sounds like a child. If you have told him how his behavior makes you feel and you have gone through counseling and he didn't take it seriously, it sounds like it's time to move on.
    I agree with everything that muddled said. You should listen to her. -ESDReturns
  • imagerenegade gaucho:
    imagemarceneaux:

    We have gone through counseling before, and I just don't think he gets how serious this is.

    Oh, then you should probably not waste any more of your life waiting around for him to figure out how to be a decent partner.  Sorry this is happening to you.

    He will when you walk out. You need a lawyer and a really good plan to separate.  Change the conversation. Say I want to separate, how do you want to do it?

    Do you think he'll fight you on it or be relieved?

    My darling daughter just turned 4 years old.
  • jbellejbelle member
    Ancient Membership Combo Breaker
    imagemarceneaux:

    We have gone through counseling before, and I just don't think he gets how serious this is.

    I kinda wonder how the counseling went with him before; did it help at all? But mainly, I think he's pushing you to the brink so you'll leave him and he can play the victim in his own mind and to his family, who's he's been prepping for this.

    TTC #1 since Oct. 2010. Tests normal.

    jbelle

  • SueBearSueBear member
    Ancient Membership 2500 Comments Combo Breaker

    One thing that comes to mind is that you can't control your ILS or your fi, you can only control yourself.  So don't bother seeing your ILS or talking to your MIL if you are angry that your fi shares all of your personal business.

    But ultimately, that means you're going to have to stop sharing information with your H, and if you can't do that, there's no point of remaining married.

  • Were there issues with his mother before you got married? And i agree with pp, you are resenting him, not trusting him with his words, and imo, it would be over for me. The one thing i would question is, do you know everything he tells your MIL? Is it just ranting about you or does he bad mouth you to MIL? 

    Once trust is over, there is no going back. Trust will always be an issue. Get counseling and do what you said...move out. Maybe then, he will see that you were truly hurt by his words.

     

  • imageSueBear:

    One thing that comes to mind is that you can't control your ILS or your fi, you can only control yourself.  So don't bother seeing your ILS or talking to your MIL if you are angry that your fi shares all of your personal business.

    But ultimately, that means you're going to have to stop sharing information with your H, and if you can't do that, there's no point of remaining married.

    I agree! I don't think that he is fully committed to his family...he cares more about what his mother thinks than what I think...obviously.  I feel that he is playing us againist each other so that he can be the victim and not have to be forced to make decisions or take responsibility...he is a coward in my opinion!

  • Once you have made the decision to go then be ready. Get your financial security and legal advice in order. Don't threaten to leave as that has been a pattern and he is no longer worried since you don't carry through on your word. It may take a while to get yourself in a good position, but start today. You know in your heart you are done. Just be smart about it.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards