Ok- I went ahead and ordered both dresses since I couldn't decide just by looking at pictures, and they've now come in. They are both incredibly comfortable and soft, and I think pretty flattering. Dress #1 is lightweight and stretchy, and surprisingly I won't have to hem it, which never happens. I already wore it all day Sunday and it wore really well for the day. Dress #2 is a great fabric that won't give up it's shape, and I'd wear it with a pink cardigan over top to sort of go with the theme of the shower. I like that it's a good shorter length, and I'm wearing it right now in the office & it feels great so far.
So what are your thoughts??? I have a friend's bridal shower/bachelorette party weekend coming up, so whichever one I don't wear to the shower I could wear to that so I can get the most bang for the buck.
Dress #1:

Dress #2
Re: Dress Advice- last time!
Only you can pull off these two dresses pregnant and look fabulous! LOL
I say wear the shorter dress to whichever shower you won't be moving around as much-- that way you don't have worry about your hemline if you wear the longer dress to whichever shower you'll be moving around more. (I just remember my friend's baby shower-- a hot, muggy summer and her dress was short and boy I'm just glad her underwear was pretty!)
So excited to meet Peanut this fall!
*Outdated* Wedding Bio
Excellent advice! They both look fantastic and were well worth the purchase. :-)
If you don't wear #1 I might steal it from your house while you are out.
I LOVE it!
I am not going to be much help here - they are both beautiful and so different...I don't think you can go wrong either way. I am loving the sailor stripe trend right now, though, and when you can look that good in it while pregnant, I say flaunt it.
Both look great! Hard decision!
I love #1, but i agree with the poster that said #2 is probably more bachelorette-ie