D.C. Area Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Wedding shower question

My husbands brother is getting married in August.  His fiancee is a bit clueless on wedding etiquette.  She's not a cad, she's actually the opposite.  She doesn't want to put out or offend anyone.  Which is good. 

Except that she didn't think that myself and their other brother's wife should be invited to her NY bridal shower because she didn't think we'd come.  (SIL is in VA.)  She didn't want us to feel obligated and put out.  I don't know if my MIL (in NY) ws invited.  I actually think not.  Also, it didn't occur to her that my husband and brother #1 would want to go to brother #2's bachelor party.  Again, b/c it will be in NY. 

The issue isn't our not being invited. (It was in upstate NY so I wouldn't have gone. But I would certainly have sent a gift.)  It's that I think as her future family we should participate in some sort of pre-wedding celebration of her.  We can't throw her anything in person.  Like I said, she's in NY (near MIL) and my SIL is down here.   I would't want to just send a shower gift b/c I know that would make her feel weird for not inviting me. 

I feel like MIL should have thrown something in NY since that's where the rest of the fam is-- lots of aunts, nieces, cousins.  It could have been a lovely shower.  But that didn't happen, oh well.  MIL isn't really a hostessy type, so I'm not surprised at all.  She did throw us an engagement party, so I feel bad for my FSIL. 

So what can I do?

Re: Wedding shower question

  • Is the wedding in NY as well?  If so, could you do something for them right before the wedding, while you're in town - maybe a nice lunch or dinner (or tea or happy hour) the Thursday before with a small group from your DH's side of the family? 

    imageImage and video hosting by TinyPic
    Baby248 - ETA 1/10/13
  • I was in a wedding where a family friend hosted a bridesmaid's tea for the bride, bridesmaids and a few female family members.  Something like that would be appropriate.

    Maybe talk to the other brother's wife and see if she wants to co-host something with you.  Does the bride have any other friends or family in VA?  Would a Virginia shower be appropriate? 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagejenn248:

    Is the wedding in NY as well?  If so, could you do something for them right before the wedding, while you're in town - maybe a nice lunch or dinner (or tea or happy hour) the Thursday before with a small group from your DH's side of the family? 

    That's a nice idea if it's possible. 

    Otherwise, get them a really nice wedding gift and call it a day. You know she didn't mean to hurt your feelings and you wouldn't have gone anyway, so I'm not sure what you're worried about, really. 

  • Wedding is in NY on a Sunday. We won't be arriving until Saturday noonish, and the RD is that night.  Then everyone is flying/driving out at varying times on Monday morning.  So unfortunately, no time for a gathering. 

    Would it be stupid to get the women in my hubz' family to write a nice note to the bride, then I collect them and send to her? 

  • I don't think that's a bad idea.  Maybe make a little book for her?  When we got married, my in-laws sent someone around with a video camera to interview all the married people and ask them for advice.  It was cute!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageMrsPhilDunphy:
    That's a nice idea if it's possible. 

    Otherwise, get them a really nice wedding gift and call it a day. You know she didn't mean to hurt your feelings and you wouldn't have gone anyway, so I'm not sure what you're worried about, really. 

    I said in the post that it wasn't that I wasn't invited. There is no issue of hurt feelings, unless perhaps her's.   It's that I would like our family to do something for her.  It's a kind and welcoming thing to do. For my brothers' wives, we've thrown a shower-- wedding and baby.  That's just what's done.  It's hard b/c it's my hubz' family and they aren't party people, or planners.  But that's a whole other issue that I post about from time to time when it comes to vacations with them!  ;-)

  • I think the note idea or something similar would be good.  For our engagment party, my mom got a wedding recipe book (from Hallmark, I think - the kind that has blank cards for your recipes) and had all of the guests send one of their favorite recipes as well as a "recipe for a happy marriage."  Kind of corny, but it was nice (and pretty funny to see some of the marriage recommendations).  I remember you also made a really nice photobook from your Galapagos trip - maybe you could do something with family photos (although I have no idea what exactly...)?   
    imageImage and video hosting by TinyPic
    Baby248 - ETA 1/10/13
  • imagejulie5220:
    imageMrsPhilDunphy:
    That's a nice idea if it's possible. 

    Otherwise, get them a really nice wedding gift and call it a day. You know she didn't mean to hurt your feelings and you wouldn't have gone anyway, so I'm not sure what you're worried about, really. 

    I said in the post that it wasn't that I wasn't invited. There is no issue of hurt feelings, unless perhaps her's.   It's that I would like our family to do something for her.  It's a kind and welcoming thing to do. For my brothers' wives, we've thrown a shower-- wedding and baby.  That's just what's done.  It's hard b/c it's my hubz' family and they aren't party people, or planners.  But that's a whole other issue that I post about from time to time when it comes to vacations with them!  ;-)

    Yes, I am aware of what is kind in this world. I guess I was just thinking that you don't really have to go out of your way to do something just because you missed the shower. I can see how you'd want to do something nice and special anyway. I like the book idea - words of wisdom for the newlyweds or family recipes would be nice.

  • imagejulie5220:

    Would it be stupid to get the women in my hubz' family to write a nice note to the bride, then I collect them and send to her? 

    I think this is a cute idea.  Maybe, "words of advice for being married to a lastname here".  Put them in a cute box or something.  I know I would love that!

  • imageMrsHabious:
    imagejulie5220:

    Would it be stupid to get the women in my hubz' family to write a nice note to the bride, then I collect them and send to her? 

    I think this is a cute idea.  Maybe, "words of advice for being married to a lastname here".  Put them in a cute box or something.  I know I would love that!

    I love this. It can be everything from a recipe XX Family recipe the new DH will love to funny insider family stories to general marriage advice and well wishes... and of course, a welcome to the family.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards