Baltimore Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

What do you guys think about this case?

I don't think it's been discussed here yet. This happened pretty close to me....I heard the sirens and can walk there in less than five minutes. There is one part of the article that made me go Indifferent. Let's see if anyone else can find it.

http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/anne-arundel/bs-md-ar-arundel-stabbings-20110620,0,5839555.story

Lilypie Third Birthday tickersLilypie First Birthday tickers

Re: What do you guys think about this case?

  • That's pretty scary, since it doesn't sound like this guy is mentally stable. I bet this is the part that made you go Indifferent  about the wife who said  she " wanted her husband to return home."
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • [The] wife, her neck swathed in a scarf as she sat in the courtroom with a relative, wanted her husband to return home.

    I'm guessing the above is the part that made you Indifferent

  • SHE WANTS HIM TO RETURN HOME?!?!
  • Hmm, maybe she meant that she wanted him out of jail so that he could go into mental health treatment instead?  If she really meant that she wants him home, that's crazy.
  • Ok, I am glad I am not the only one......

    Um, you're sitting in court after just getting out of the hospital ICU where you almost died  from having your throat cut. Let's not forget your husband cut both your daughters' throats too. But your honor, he needs to be at home. He was just having a bad morning, really. 

    Oh and my mom wants me to move after she heard this on the news. She says after the case where the 14 year old boy was beaten and died last year and now this she thinks I live in an unsafe area. Confused OK mom! Just hand over the $40K we will lose if we sell our house right now.

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickersLilypie First Birthday tickers
  • what an idiot!  And, really, who cares what she wants, clearly, she's been brainwashed.
    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • Im gathering that there is a history of domestic violence possibly, which makes her desire sad but typical and not really surprising, but not necessarily idiotic per se.
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • imagemrsbecky07:
    Im gathering that there is a history of domestic violence possibly, which makes her desire sad but typical and not really surprising, but not necessarily idiotic per se.

    what's not idiotic about it?

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • imagemrsbecky07:
    Im gathering that there is a history of domestic violence possibly, which makes her desire sad but typical and not really surprising, but not necessarily idiotic per se.

    I was going to say this.  I'm not agreeing with her, but when I read the article, I automatically thought that she was most likely scared of what would happen if she didn't request that he return home or because of a possible history of emotional abuse, she truly thinks it will never happen again.

    image *Amber & Chuck - October 25, 2008* Anniversary
  • I realize she's a battered woman and obviously this guy has control over her, but HELLO - he's in jail, take your chance now lady.  Get a restraining order, file for divorce and get OUT.  She has to take her chance now.

    That guy back in the house is a death sentence, pressing charges, getting a restraining order, moving away at least gives her and her girls a chance.  The "idiotic" part to me is not taking her chance.

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • imageKathrynMD:

    I realize she's a battered woman and obviously this guy has control over her, but HELLO - he's in jail, take your chance now lady.  Get a restraining order, file for divorce and get OUT.  She has to take her chance now.

    That guy back in the house is a death sentence, pressing charges, getting a restraining order, moving away at least gives her and her girls a chance.  The "idiotic" part to me is not taking her chance.

    I guess my issue is that it is not that simple for victims of DV. It's not that black and white and the implication that she is stupid or idiotic for ot leaving him overlooks a whole host of psychological issues that go along with being abused, emotionally, verbally or physically.
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • The first thing I thought was domestic violence too, her actions unfortunately seem common of someone who has been in that sort of relationship and is scared. I take issue with her knowingly putting her two daughters back in danger again though. I kind of want to shake her by her shoulders and say "He tried to kill all three of you!!" If someone wants to return to an abusive relationship, it sucks, when they bring kids back into an abusive relationship, it kind of makes me mad.
    Lilypie Third Birthday tickersLilypie First Birthday tickers
  • imageKathrynMD:

    I realize she's a battered woman and obviously this guy has control over her, but HELLO - he's in jail, take your chance now lady.  Get a restraining order, file for divorce and get OUT.  She has to take her chance now.

    That guy back in the house is a death sentence, pressing charges, getting a restraining order, moving away at least gives her and her girls a chance.  The "idiotic" part to me is not taking her chance.

    That's a simplistic and naive view of domestic violence.  It's really easy to say that from the outside, and I understand where you're coming from, but in reality, it's just not that easy for the victims who are embroiled in it.

  • I'll be sure to give a more nuanced and academic answers when responding to posts about extremely complicated social and personal issues in the future, lest anyone think I'm ignorant of such issues in the future. 

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • imageKathrynMD:

    I'll be sure to give a more nuanced and academic answers when responding to posts about extremely complicated social and personal issues in the future, lest anyone think I'm ignorant of such issues in the future. 

    I didn't mean to be insulting, and I apologize if I came off that way.  I do think it's naive to respond to a case that appears to be rife with long-term domestic violence (yes I'm assuming and yes I could be wrong since the history of the couple has not, as far as I've seen, but publicized) with a simple "she should leave", as though it's that easy for a victim of DV.  If that's all it boiled down to for her, wouldn't she have left a long time ago?

    I'm no expert, but I've seen it in someone close to me and I know that, to her, she feels like there's no where for her to go.  No one to help her.  That she's a failure if she gives up on her marriage.  That she deserved the treatment.  That he does it because he loves her, because he's teaching her a lesson, because she did something wrong.  When your mind is so riddled with these kinds of thoughts, it's no longer as simple as "oh, hey, I should leave this bastard! why didn't I think of that?" 

  • I agree with FIA and Becky.  Until you're in that kind of situation, it's very hard to understand, IMO.  You (collectively) wish you'd just leave and it'd be easy, but I don't truly think that is often the case. 
  • imageKathrynMD:

    I'll be sure to give a more nuanced and academic answers when responding to posts about extremely complicated social and personal issues in the future, lest anyone think I'm ignorant of such issues in the future. 

    Hmm

     

    No one said you're ignorant.  We were having a discussion and my point was that it is not black-and-white. You were making black-and-white statements. I responded to that, because this is something that I feel strongly about, not because I think you are ignorant.

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • HI LADIES!!I PROMISE I WILL ONLY BUG YOU UNTIL THE 26TH!! :-) :-).... CAN YOU PLEASE VOTE FOR NAASIR TODAY AND UNTIL THE 26TH? ALSO LIKE IT IF YOU HAVE NOT ALREADY AND WE REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT AND YOU HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY :-) 

     http://photos.parents.com/category/vote/photo/927297

  • imagekshikab:

    HI LADIES!!I PROMISE I WILL ONLY BUG YOU UNTIL THE 26TH!! :-) :-).... CAN YOU PLEASE VOTE FOR NAASIR TODAY AND UNTIL THE 26TH? ALSO LIKE IT IF YOU HAVE NOT ALREADY AND WE REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT AND YOU HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY :-) 

     http://photos.parents.com/category/vote/photo/927297

    You shouldn't be bothering us at all.  I'm gonna go vote for another kid now, just 'cause I find you annoying.  So there.

  • imageFieryIrishAngel:
    imagekshikab:

    HI LADIES!!I PROMISE I WILL ONLY BUG YOU UNTIL THE 26TH!! :-) :-).... CAN YOU PLEASE VOTE FOR NAASIR TODAY AND UNTIL THE 26TH? ALSO LIKE IT IF YOU HAVE NOT ALREADY AND WE REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR SUPPORT AND YOU HAVE A WONDERFUL DAY :-) 

     http://photos.parents.com/category/vote/photo/927297

    You shouldn't be bothering us at all.  I'm gonna go vote for another kid now, just 'cause I find you annoying.  So there.

    Yes

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards