North Florida Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Age of Consent to Marry

For some reason in the morning when I'm getting ready for work, I'm thinking of topics to post on the Nest.... not what I need to get done that day Embarrassed

I was thinking about that 50-something y/o actor marrying that 16 y/o girl & it got me thinking about the legal age of consent to marry.

So bring on your opinions: Across the board, what do you think should be the legal age of consent to marry? Do you think that if your parents have to sign for you, you're too young to get married? What about at 18? 21? 25?

Bonus points for discussion of age of consent for sex.

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Re: Age of Consent to Marry

  • I know that when I was 18 or 21 that I was not ready to be married (even though I thought I was at 21). I also think anything under 18 is too early to have sex (based on my opinion /experience ).
  • I don't think minors should be allowed to marry, period, unless they've been emancipated and are essentially 'adults' legally. There is no reason good enough to warrant underage marriage in the modern era, where adolescence by and large is encouraged into the early and mid 20s, and we know that they are fundamentally psychologically unprepared. I say if they want to go through the hassle of being declared adults, fine, but otherwise no. I would imagine in that scenario that having a baby would weight the argument, but not entirely so. Some people would probably feel that if you have a baby, you're 'adult enough' to make your own legal decisions, but at what age? If a child has a baby at 12, is that still valid? 14? 16? I don't really have an answer.
  • I thought at 19/20 when DH and I started dating that I was ready to get married. Looking back, I was nowhere near ready and I'm glad we waited. As for sex, I was 14 when I started "messing around" and 16 when I first had sex. I was so not ready and I wish I had waited. I'm not sure the legal age of consent should be any less than 18 for either sex or marriage. I don't think the majority of young people (male or female) is ready even then.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I don't think parents should be allowed to let their children marry. I think the legal age should be 18, no if's and's or but's. Of course people will have their reasons (military, health insurance, etc.) but I really don't think it's appropriate for anyone that young to be married. 

    For sex, it's such a grey area and that scares me a little. I don't think that anyone over 18 should be having sex with 16 yr olds, but I also don't think 16 yr. olds should be having sex... there's just no way to stop it.   

    Love 9.3.03 Marriage 12.1.07 Baby Carriage 8.3.11
  • If you need your parents to sign a consent form for you to get married, you are ABSOLUTELY too young to get married. That shouldn't even be an option in my opinion. Why is getting married that important that you can't wait a couple years?

    In my opinion, you shouldn't get married until you can legally drink at your own wedding, but that's not something I think should be made a law like the first part. I just think you're too young to know what you're getting into at that point. I realize there are some people that get married at 19 and live happily ever after, but I don't think that's a norm. I think most people that get married that young end up divorced. Love is great, but it's not all you need in a marriage, and at that age, most people think love is all you need.

    Obviously, I feel pretty strongly on this.

    As far as age of consent for sex, I don't know. I lost my virginity when I was 15, almost 16, and I don't think I'm any worse off because of it. But I know I wouldn't want my 15 year old having sex! haha. I mean 18 makes sense to me... I don't know. I guess I don't have a good opinion on this part.

    Honeymooning image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I think 18 should be the minimum. I don't think parents/guardians should be able to allow marriage before 18. I don't think there is a certain age that should warrant marriage. Maturity levels vary by person.
  • I agree if you have to have a parents consent to get married you are too young.

    In my experience I think getting married after the age of 25 is good. I know a lot of people get married early and it works but I personally was not ready in my early 20's. I moved in with my BF when I was 20 thinking we would be getting married and quickly realized I needed to experience life and graduate college before I settled down. I met DH when I was 24 and it was perfect timing. 

    As far as sex I hope my daughter waits until she is 18 but 16 may be more realistic. I was def too young the first time I had sex but like Tara said I don't think think I am any worse off because of it.  

    imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I agree with Sikes, if you're not old enough to drink at your wedding then you shouldn't be getting married. I had sex the first time at 18 and it totally messed me up emotionally, I think my religious background has a lot to do with that, but I feel like it's such a big thing, if you're not old enough to get married then you're not old enough to have sex. I also think you shouldn't be allowed to drive until your 18 and junior college should mandatory with a liberal arts focus before you go to university and declare your major, so take my age beliefs with a grain of salt.
    Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos
  • I think it should be 18.  You're a legal adult and you should be able to make decision for your life at that point.
  • I'm 25, got married at 23 and don't think anyone should get married until 30.

    But just because people should wait, doesn't mean it should be illegal to get married before 30.  I think 18 is an okay age for legal purposes, but I don't think there should be any exceptions even with parental consent.  

  • imageLanerbell:
    I also think you shouldn't be allowed to drive until your 18 and junior college should mandatory with a liberal arts focus before you go to university and declare your major, so take my age beliefs with a grain of salt.

    Just out of curiosity, why do you think this is a good idea?

  • imageLucille Bluth:

    imageLanerbell:
    I also think you shouldn't be allowed to drive until your 18 and junior college should mandatory with a liberal arts focus before you go to university and declare your major, so take my age beliefs with a grain of salt.

    Just out of curiosity, why do you think this is a good idea?

    Almost every person whose gone to college in my family doesn't know what they're doing until the 2nd year or so.  All of us, every single one that's gone to college, tried to go to a state college first, changed our major a couple times, got a little lost and then had to make up for lost time.  A couple of my friends have done the same thing.  I feel like its hard to know what you're going to do for the rest of your life when you're 18-19 and have gone to college level classes for a while.

    I know that's just my family, and a couple friends. Obviously not everyone is like this, but I think junior college is a great way to get your feet wet and figure out what you're going to do before you spend tons of money at a university. 

    Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos
  • imageLanerbell:
    imageLucille Bluth:

    imageLanerbell:
    I also think you shouldn't be allowed to drive until your 18 and junior college should mandatory with a liberal arts focus before you go to university and declare your major, so take my age beliefs with a grain of salt.

    Just out of curiosity, why do you think this is a good idea?

    Almost every person whose gone to college in my family doesn't know what they're doing until the 2nd year or so.  All of us, every single one that's gone to college, tried to go to a state college first, changed our major a couple times, got a little lost and then had to make up for lost time.  A couple of my friends have done the same thing.  I feel like its hard to know what you're going to do for the rest of your life when you're 18-19 and have gone to college level classes for a while.

    I know that's just my family, and a couple friends. Obviously not everyone is like this, but I think junior college is a great way to get your feet wet and figure out what you're going to do before you spend tons of money at a university. 

    That makes sense.  I don't agree that it should be mandatory at all, but I do think it should be more widely accepted as a track after high school and encouraged for students in some cases.

  • i know plenty of people that went into 4-yr colleges as undecided and took a smattering of classes that were interesting to them first but still graduated in four years.  i don't think any particular track should be mandatory.  i also know plenty of people that knew they wanted to major in the sciences rather than liberal arts from the very beginning. different strokes...
  • imageLanerbell:
    I agree with Sikes, if you're not old enough to drink at your wedding then you shouldn't be getting married. I had sex the first time at 18 and it totally messed me up emotionally, I think my religious background has a lot to do with that, but I feel like it's such a big thing, if you're not old enough to get married then you're not old enough to have sex. I also think you shouldn't be allowed to drive until your 18 and junior college should mandatory with a liberal arts focus before you go to university and declare your major, so take my age beliefs with a grain of salt.

    I disagree with the liberal art approach. I would have found a job and probably avoided school if that was required. This would be misery to me.

  • I retract my mandatory statement.  For some, if not most, people its a good idea to take a couple years of college classes until you decide what you're going to do for the rest of your life. 
    Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos
  • I also don't think everyone should go to college.  I think community colleges (with no track to a university - just for an AA) and technical schools should be encouraged for a lot of people. 

    A bachelors degree is getting to the point (or already is) where it's like having a high school diploma now.  A lot of the time it's a waste of money and time that could be better spent gaining experience in whatever field that doesn't require a degree anyway.

  • imageLucille Bluth:

    I also don't think everyone should go to college.  I think community colleges (with no track to a university - just for an AA) and technical schools should be encouraged for a lot of people. 

    A bachelors degree is getting to the point (or already is) where it's like having a high school diploma now.  A lot of the time it's a waste of money and time that could be better spent gaining experience in whatever field that doesn't require a degree anyway.

    I completely agree.   

    Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos
  • imageLanerbell:
    I retract my mandatory statement.  For some, if not most, people its a good idea to take a couple years of college classes until you decide what you're going to do for the rest of your life. 

    But couldn't those classes be taken at a four year university?  That's what freshman/sophomore year is spent doing for a lot of (most?) people.  I didn't start taking classes specific to my major (which I changed four times) except for here and there until junior/senior year.

  • imageLucille Bluth:

    imageLanerbell:
    I retract my mandatory statement.  For some, if not most, people its a good idea to take a couple years of college classes until you decide what you're going to do for the rest of your life. 

    But couldn't those classes be taken at a four year university?  That's what freshman/sophomore year is spent doing for a lot of (most?) people.  I didn't start taking classes specific to my major (which I changed four times) except for here and there until junior/senior year.

    Yes they could. I personally would just rather pay for the cheaper classes at a junior college.

    For me, when I declared music education and accepted a scholarship through the UWF music dept, they owned me.  I had to take the classes they offered when they offered them because they wouldn't be offered again for another 2-3 years.  One of my semesters was 21 hours because of all the music classes on top of a couple generals.  When I changed my major and went to PJC, I had about 9 or so transferable hours.  It really sucked.   

    If I had gone to PJC to begin with I would already have my degree.   

    Photobucket Pictures, Images and Photos
  • imageLanerbell:
    imageLucille Bluth:

    imageLanerbell:
    I retract my mandatory statement.  For some, if not most, people its a good idea to take a couple years of college classes until you decide what you're going to do for the rest of your life. 

    But couldn't those classes be taken at a four year university?  That's what freshman/sophomore year is spent doing for a lot of (most?) people.  I didn't start taking classes specific to my major (which I changed four times) except for here and there until junior/senior year.

    Yes they could. I personally would just rather pay for the cheaper classes at a junior college.

    For me, when I declared music education and accepted a scholarship through the UWF music dept, they owned me.  I had to take the classes they offered when they offered them because they wouldn't be offered again for another 2-3 years.  One of my semesters was 21 hours because of all the music classes on top of a couple generals.  When I changed my major and went to PJC, I had about 9 or so transferable hours.  It really sucked.   

    If I had gone to PJC to begin with I would already have my degree.   

    Your experience isn't exactly normal though. Specialty departments such as Music do this for a reason - they want to weed people out. My ex was a Music major at FSU & he lasted a year & a half before he dropped out of the program. Its extremely demanding for a purpose. & IMO a music degree is kind of worthless unless you're going to teach, so it's a good thing you didn't continue down that path. What were you planning on doing with your Music degree? It seems like such a waste to put in all that time & effort to get a job that someone with a cakewalk degree could've gotten just as easily.

    For most people, freshman & sophomore year in college is spent going to Baby Bio & College Algebra... regardless of whether or not he/she is at CC or a 4 year. Hell, I walked into college thinking I was going to be a Political Science major & then go to law school. Ha! Then I switched to English because I had to wait to be admitted to the Advertising program. I decided if I didn't get into Advertising, I'd switch to Sociology because I really wasn't a fan of the English department.

    Total side track, but for the most part, I don't think a lot of people walking into college don't realize that your degree doesn't matter... unless you know you want to go into a really specialized field. Hell, I have a BS in Communications - Advertising & I work in Insurance. Had I known I was going to get into Insurance, I would've gotten a degree in Risk Management. My brother has a degree in Criminology & works in Mergers & Acquisitions for a large company. I wish someone would've explained that to me when I was 18.

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards