Philadelphia Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Amy#'s, LD, Lando, Mel & other BJ (Baby Joggers) owners

So in the maze that is the stroller jungle, MrJRM and I seem to be leaning toward either the City Select or the City Mini (it's a cautious lean). Big props to Tim, the stroller pixie at BBB this weekend who is either perpetually stoned or an angel.

I think I recall you all have Baby Joggers. I'm currently liking the one-handed folding mechanism of the Mini. However, MrJRM seems to think the Select is a better choice for storage space,  future JRMs (which I am categorically not considerating at the moment...), etc. and is not that much heavier, though it lacks the 1-handed folding mechanism.

I do all my jogging on a treadmill so really this thing just has to accomodate my suburban lifestye. I want to go places and be able to navigate parks, malls, grocery stores, etc. Any comments to help me decide between these 2?

We also contemplated the Uppababy because the kid can face you but it lacks compatibility with some of the infant carseats we're thinking about.

image

Re: Amy#'s, LD, Lando, Mel & other BJ (Baby Joggers) owners

  • City select can face you. Also if you want a second sooner the city select can accommodate two easily. That being said if this is living in your car going to the mall i would say the mini is better.
  • So I have a City Select. My main reason - a little brat who was screaming in BBB when we were the that she "ONLY WANTS THE ORANGE ONE" while her parents were shopping for a double. After that, we were not leaving with something that could not become a double. The basket is awesome, and I like that it lies flat for him to sleep, and that he can face me. it folds up veery easily, and fits in my Ford Focus trunk with groceries and everything else. Sorry for no paragraphs - I am on Opera on the ipad.
    Baby Numbers 11.8.10 The Sequel on or around 10.13.12
  • Ok, I'd forgotten the select can face either way. It was a a lot to absorb all in 1 setting.

    image
  • meldotmeldot member
    Eighth Anniversary 1000 Comments Combo Breaker

    We have the mini and love it. Downside: the storage underneath is small, but it's never been a problem for us. Despite living in LA, we do walk, and there aren't curbcuts at all the intersections-the weight is handy for tipping him back to get him onto a curb. We also used it with the carseat adaptor, and loved it.

    It's so so so easy to use-I was a single mom this weekend and was able to hold Max, open it up and get him in easy peasy. 

     

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I have the City Select and absolutely love it.  I had a travel system when my son was a baby and it was horrible. I swore I'd never get a travel system again.  I lliked the city select because of the huge bottom basket. The city mini's basket was way too small for me. I also loved the option of it becoming a double in the future. I have the bassinette for it and use it all the time. I felt a bit bratty putting it on my registry since it was $500 but i figured if no one wanted to get it, I'd buy it myself because I loved it so much. We lucked out and my aunt and uncle purchased it for us.  It wheels so nicely compared to the travel system we had before. It's worth every penny.

    ETA: Ditto Amy on the folding down flat. I have a sports car and the CS fits in my tiny trunk perfectly.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I have the mini. I love it.I never used the carseat with it though bc I didn't like the bar and locking mechanism. Also, the basket is good sized bit difficult to access. That said, I like the city select so much better. It's much more versatile and expandable. I don't/didn't have the need for a stroller like that as I'm a suburban mama, but if i was in the city or did a ton of walking I would have ponied up for it. I have a separate reebok stroller for jogging.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I had a BOB and LOVED it....I then got a city mini double and don't care for it at all.  I can't wait to ditch the double and go back to my single
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I feel the same as LD.  Love, love my City Mini.  I like the City Select better, but couldn't justify the cost.  If I wanted to spend that much on a stroller, I would have gotten a City Select.

    I just don't use it enough to pay that much.  I used a snap n go with the infant seat, and I put her in the cart when I'm shopping places like Target or the market.  For walks around the neighborhood, recently Em prefers her buggy or wagon.  So I only use it about once every week or two when we're out and about.   

  • I LOVED the City Mini from the moment I saw it and ended up buying the City Classic due to a sale which appealed to my frugal senses but left me with the worst case of buyers remorse since my terribly uncomfortable birkenstocks in the late 1990s. I cant speak to the City Select specifically but my big pet peeve with the Classic is that its wheel base is huge, comparatively, so Id keep that in mind when deciding. We took it to Target/ the mall once and nearly knocked down every display because it barely fit down the store aisles. Im assured by several friends that its fabulous for actual jogging or outside trips with less obstacles but its not very useful for the day to day suburban lifestyle.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I held off on buying a stroller until I understood what I needed. The beginning months I used a hand me down snap and go with his car seat. Once he was too heavy, I relied on a hand me down BOB jogger (awesome on sidewalks, too bulky for normal use) and a hand me down Maclaren Volo (easy to travel with but not good on sidewalks and me and my husband seem to be the only people in America who can't open/close the damn thing).

     

    We're flying in Sept so I wanted something in between. I went with the City Mini. So far I love love love it. More support than the Maclaren, reclines all the back for naps on the go, flats pretty darn flat, handles sidewalks well and that one handed open/close thing is awesome. The front/back facing thing doesn't matter to me anymore since he's older.  GL.

    ETA - I snagged a 2010 City Mini for $60 less than the 2011 at BBB... Only thing missing was is the board for the seat back. TBD whether I need to buy one. It's the only difference between the '10 and '11 

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards