Sex & Romance
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

newly weds living with In laws....thoughts?

My fiance and I are getting married next July... As of now neither of us have solid jobs. We both work full time but they are not?"career moves". Obviously we are hoping that changes between now and then. But if it does not...My fiance strongly feels that we should live with his parents until we can stand on our own feet comfortably. I personally think its a bad idea. But he is thinking logically and financially. And i get where he is coming from... but we are Newlyweds! And I love his parents and I would like to keep it that way. Living with them would be to invasive.... We can afford an apartment... we would have to slim down on other costs... but isn't that part of the adventure?

?

Yay or Nay?!?

Re: newly weds living with In laws....thoughts?

  • BAD, bad, bad bad idea.....

    If you're old enough to be married, you're old enough to live on your own. Grown up, married adults don't live with parents (barring some accidental catastrophe, of course.)

    It sounds like you can afford to live on your own, but it'll be tight. That's ok, because the small negative of tight finances FAR outweighs the lack of privacy and a whole host of other issues you'll encounter living with parents. 

    Put a time frame on it, say January. Work hard to get into better paying jobs for you both, but if you're not at that point in January, discuss some options. These could include postponing until you're more financially stable. 

    I see you are new to the Nest. If you want any idea of how living with in-laws can ruin a marriage, look no further than the Family Matters and Trouble in Paradise boards. 

    image

    ~ The Nestie formally known as MrsBrittany ~
  • I'll say what a wise woman ( my mom ) said to me. "No, you need to be an adult and live on your own when you married". Sounds harsh but it was sound advice. Being on our own taught me a lot about growing up. So much so that 5 yrs later when the marrige ended I was able to afford my house on my own and have enough to pay the bills( I did not and do not have the greatest paying job in the world either). I just feel that when we are still living with our parents that " inner child" is still there but on our own we are " forced" to grow up and live in the real world.
    Our Website

    Kristi and Kerry June 21,2008
    image

    Daisypath Next Aniversary Ticker
  • If you can't afford to live on your own, then you're not mature enough to be married.

    I promise you that eating Ramen noodles in your own tiny apartment will bring you far more joy than playing house under your inlaws' roof.

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • I would rather live in a one-room tenement with laundry two blocks away than live with his parents or mine. It's nothing at all against them; they are some of my favorite people, but newlyweds need their own place. Got to "cut the umbilical cord," if you know what I mean? (or maybe it's just pregnant lady talk) There are all kinds of problems that can start with a live-in situation, no matter how wonderful the IL's are. Honestly, if you really had to, I would say make it no more than a couple months, tops, then get out of there.
  • Don't do it.

    Every couple I have seen do it ends up divorced.   

  • Nay to infinity.

    Find the cheapest habitable apartment that you can afford with no problem and move into it.

    And a plus: finding one that is not within heartburn distance of the ILS.
  • srgwsrgw member
    1000 Comments Third Anniversary 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    Don't do it! The PP all had excellent points. As newlyweds and adults you should stand on your own two feet. I love my ILs and would never live with them! My parents offered to have H and I move into their house when we married. (They were only half kidding.) I said no thank you. I like my privacy... and the walls are paper thin at their house, if you catch my drift. Wink
  • imageHiddenAgenda:

    BAD, bad, bad bad idea.....

    If you're old enough to be married, you're old enough to live on your own. Grown up, married adults don't live with parents (barring some accidental catastrophe, of course.)

    It sounds like you can afford to live on your own, but it'll be tight. That's ok, because the small negative of tight finances FAR outweighs the lack of privacy and a whole host of other issues you'll encounter living with parents. 

    Put a time frame on it, say January. Work hard to get into better paying jobs for you both, but if you're not at that point in January, discuss some options. These could include postponing until you're more financially stable. 

    I see you are new to the Nest. If you want any idea of how living with in-laws can ruin a marriage, look no further than the Family Matters and Trouble in Paradise boards. 

    this. 100% 

  • Nay. You are a saint for even humoring the idea. I would just laugh at my H if he suggested that.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers image
  • If you can afford to live on your own, DO IT! I think you will regret living with your in-laws, no matter how much you get along with them. I can see if you fell on hard times, both lost jobs at the same time, couldn't pay the bills and needed a place to stay short term instead of being on the streets. But if you CAN afford your own place, no matter how much you would save staying with them, don't do it.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

  • I've lived with my fiance and his parents for 2 years now. He's still in college and I work full time to pay for the Wedding. The twist is they are out of town M-F as they both work on the road. We take care of the garbage, the cats, the housework, grocery shopping, mail, laundry, pool, etc. Essentially, we keep up the house and live there for free. But I HAVE to say - if they were home 7 days a week, it WOULD NOT WORK! I'm well aware that we have a unique set-up and that makes it possible to save a lot of money. There is no privacy during the weekend and they come home, make a mess, and leave Monday morning. It has it's definite frustrations and our arguments often revolve around personality conflicts between my fiance and his step-father, not me and him (as they should be). Oftentimes, we talk about how much we are looking forward to being in our own space and making it our own.
  • We lived with our in-laws for 2 months right after our wedding while we got an apartment and waited for it to be ready for us to move in. 2 weeks before our wedding my husband's apartment lease was up and we didn't want to live there he hated the complex, and I had a roommate and that wasn't gonna work so we had no choice. It was fine though they have a finished basement and we had our own space we came and went through the back door that do one else used. We even had a bathroom with our own shower down there so we only had to go up to eat. It was very short and we had no problems we had our own space it was barley like we were around anyways.  I wouldn't suggest doing it for a long time of course but a month or two until you can get an apartment/house ready is not a big deal.
    Anniversary
    "A women who can kneel before the Lord can stand up to anything"
  • imageMaybride2:
    If you can't afford to live on your own, then you're not mature enough to be married.

    This.

    Even in our early 30s, I find that staying under the same roof as my parents or my in-laws can bring up petty family issues, and cause me and my husband to revert to immature behavior which is taxing on not only our relationship with our parents, but our relationship with each other. I've told my H more than once that we could never live in close proximity to his parents (who live on the opposite coast from us), due solely to the way *he* acts when he spends a lot of time with them: he is easily irritated, his frustration tolerance plummets, and he stops thinking before he speaks. And I know my H would say the same about me, when my parents visit.

    I have a close friend who lived with her in-laws for about a year, when they moved several years after marrying. Before, she had a strong relationship with her in-laws; now, it is strained, at best. I love my in-laws, but I would NOT love them in the next room, or even next door...

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageroxy00la:

    My fiance and I are getting married next July... As of now neither of us have solid jobs. We both work full time but they are not "career moves". Obviously we are hoping that changes between now and then. But if it does not...My fiance strongly feels that we should live with his parents until we can stand on our own feet comfortably. I personally think its a bad idea. But he is thinking logically and financially. And i get where he is coming from... but we are Newlyweds! And I love his parents and I would like to keep it that way. Living with them would be to invasive.... We can afford an apartment... we would have to slim down on other costs... but isn't that part of the adventure?

     

    Yay or Nay?! 

    I can offer you personal experience, we did this. We did it so I could get back in school and when DH and I got married, he had a lot of terrible debt from a long time ago that we wanted to get paid off to start working on his credit score. We were mature enough to be marrid and thought we were making a mature decision by thinking of our finances. I loved his parents and they loved me and it didn't seem like it could hurt, I could get back into school, pay off his debt, and get in a better spot financially. We didnt.

     We blew our money because we didn't have any bills, I did get back in school and we paid off one large debt before we moved out. We were there 6 months and my relationship with his parents will NEVER be the same. We still get along great, but there are things I know about them I wish I didn't, as i'm sure they feel about me. I don't reccomend it. Post a budget on here and let the ladies help you with saving, get a dirt cheap apartment and live on bare minimum for a bit. I agree, being 'broke' for a little while is part of the adventure.

  • Really appreciative to everyones advice! Thinking I have enough reasons to help him see it another way... We would have our own space... except for eating. But really in the long run it won't really feel that way.. I don't want to feel stuck in only 2 rooms! anyways Thanks to all who replied! Feel much better!?

  • Get the apartment and slash your budget.

    You absolutely don't want to invade your in-laws. Right as I read your title I knew what your question was going to be. Its hard on the IL's & the marriage.

    You're welcome. 

    image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    image
  • I feel everyone should live out on their own before they get married.  If you can not live on your own then you are not ready to get married,  Living with IL would be ackward!
  • I've been having the same problem... only it's my fiance's great aunt who already lives with him... I feel bad, b/c she's 75, yet... the closer the time gets for us to actually move, the less I feel I can do it. I said it was ok at first but I guess I didn't give enough thought to what I was actually getting into. A month or so would be fine, but he's committed to having her live there (he bought his grandparents house from her... she moved out, then back in with him) - I'm thinking that indefinite is just too much and possibly too much of a strain on our relationship and marriage. We're getting married in march. I started a similar thread under marriages
  • This is what we've been doing.  Except we've been hopping back and forth between his parents and mine.  It's exhausting, and I want to cry sometimes from the lack of privacy and space.  I make minimum wage right now and my hours fluctuate from 10 - 40 a week, so it's hard for us to plan a budget,  DH does ok at his job but it would be extremely tight, and would only take a single disaster to send us under, right now.  We're saving every penny we can so we'll be able to get a mobile home in the next few months.  If you can afford to live on your own, do it.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • We had talked about moving in with the in laws when I went back to school as the school was in the same town as they lived in and we could not afford our own place without me working. (he was my F at this point) we got into town and we stayed there the first night and it was weird, so the next day I called up a friend of mine that had a basement suite that they were not renting out yet as they were renovating the kitchen. (she had actually told me to move in with her as she thought living with the inlaws would be a bad idea). She took us in with open arms.

    She even had the place ready for us, minus kitchen, before I called her, "just in case". lol.

    After school was done, we moved back to where I was working and we have a bachlor suite as that is all we can afford and I would live in these cramped conditions way before I live with the IL's.

    The most beautiful things in the world are not seen nor touched. They are felt with the heart. -- Helen Keller Daisypath Anniversary tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards