Entertainment
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Scrap Real Housewives of Beverly Hills?

Real Housewives of Beverly Hills: Scrap the Show, Says PEOPLE TV Critic

By Tom Gliatto

Monday August 22, 2011 03:15 PM EDT

Real Housewives of Beverly Hills: Scrap the Show, Says PEOPLE TV Critic

Taylor Armstrong and Kyle Richards

Luiz Martinez/Broadimage

A reality show may present itself as a grand mansion, but it's essentially a prefab house plunked down on what the owners hope looks like solid ground: If an earthquake rumbles below and splits open a fissure, the foundation of the house goes, goes, goes down, down, down.

Bravo has set about trying to repair the tragic mess that is now season 2 of The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills. The season, which was scheduled to premiere Sept. 5, will be reedited and possibly postponed in light of the suicide of Housewife Taylor Armstrong's estranged husband, Russell. According to Variety, it's likely that Russell's presence ? that is, his life ? will be reshaped or reduced.

The fact remains that public interest in the show is now higher than ever. But, in a better world, Bravo would just go ahead and scrap not just the season but the entire series. And I say that as a fan of the show. The first season was one of the most entertaining things ever to come out of Bravo.



The death of Russell can?t be treated merely as an act of God or some incidental tragedy. His suicide by hanging weeks before the premiere was intimately connected with Taylor's public and personal life. It may very well be that his death would have happened without press scrutiny, without Taylor's overnight fame and the disturbing revelations about his abusive behavior, but the possibility can't be eliminated. This isn't a garnish of parsley that can be scraped aside and off the plate.

Russell, although unseen, figured heavily in the season premiere screening disc Bravo sent out to critics earlier this summer: At a dinner reuniting the Housewives, Taylor, 40, was openly distraught over the state of her marriage ? weeping in the powder room ? but assuring everyone she was doing all she could to save her marriage.

Lisa Vanderpump suggested that Taylor knew how to turn the tears on and off, and her husband, Ken, mocked marriage counseling. Even before Russell's suicide, they came across as stupendously cavalier. How much of this will remain?

Even if Taylor were to quit the show and move to an undisclosed island, claiming the need to shelter her daughter and her own spirit, Camille Grammer and the others would still be required, somehow, at some point, to address the issue. Awkward, one might say. And if Taylor remains, as the show spills into seasons 3 and even 4, how naturally can she be expected to mourn and recover with women who are not so much friends as costars? Or even possibly hostile costars?

These aren't things that can be properly handled in a reunion show or on Watch What Happens Live.
image

Re: Scrap Real Housewives of Beverly Hills?

  • I don't think they should cancel the show. 

    However, I think the producers should take this as a wake up call, and think about what they're doing/hurting when they choose to make one "character" the villian.

    IUI - BFP! Baby boy born still - August 2012
    IVF - BFP - miscarriage June 2013
    FET - BFN
    FET - BFN
    Switched clinics
    IVF with PGD - three embryos created, all healthy - July 2014
    FET - transferred two embryos (boy and girl) - Nov 2014 - BFP!
    Baby Boy born July 2015

  • I would love to be a fly on the wall inside Andy Cohen's office.

    The insensitive and curious part of me really wants to see the season the way it was originally edited.

    image
  • I don't know what the proper treatment would be but since there is a little girl involved, I would think the best way to handle Russell's suicide is to edit everything related to his/marital problems out of the entire season.  Or scrap the entire season.  I would think there was enough material with the other housewives to make this show, but if a major recurring theme is Russell and Taylor's marriage, then how to avoid this elephant in the room?  I will be a little bummed out if they cancel the footage between Kim Richards and Brandi Glanville.  Slut pig would have gone down in history.
  • What happened was a real tragedy but I don't think the show was the cause of what happened and should not be cancelled.
  • imagemavjen:
    I don't know what the proper treatment would be but since there is a little girl involved, I would think the best way to handle Russell's suicide is to edit everything related to his/marital problems out of the entire season.  Or scrap the entire season.  I would think there was enough material with the other housewives to make this show, but if a major recurring theme is Russell and Taylor's marriage, then how to avoid this elephant in the room?  I will be a little bummed out if they cancel the footage between Kim Richards and Brandi Glanville.  Slut pig would have gone down in history.

    I agree, cut anything having to do with Russel and Taylor's marital problems and give us more footage of "slut pig!"

    Maybe if they need to fill up more time, they can have a dinner party with Allison Dubois and her e-cig?  Just a thought. 

  • imagemysterons:

    I would love to be a fly on the wall inside Andy Cohen's office.

    The insensitive and curious part of me really wants to see the season the way it was originally edited.

    me too. i mean, it's def sad that russell killed himself but i want to see the show. i feel like these people sign up for this when they get on a reality show. i do feel sorry for them that it got to the point where he hanged himself but still- other people have been on real housewives and torn apart with the public. it happens.

     

  • I just read that Bravo is delaying the taping of RHONY due to re-editing of RHOBH.  So, the entire season of BH won't be scrapped.

  • imageaeroluv327:

    imagemavjen:
    I don't know what the proper treatment would be but since there is a little girl involved, I would think the best way to handle Russell's suicide is to edit everything related to his/marital problems out of the entire season.  Or scrap the entire season.  I would think there was enough material with the other housewives to make this show, but if a major recurring theme is Russell and Taylor's marriage, then how to avoid this elephant in the room?  I will be a little bummed out if they cancel the footage between Kim Richards and Brandi Glanville.  Slut pig would have gone down in history.

    I agree, cut anything having to do with Russel and Taylor's marital problems and give us more footage of "slut pig!"

    Maybe if they need to fill up more time, they can have a dinner party with Allison Dubois and her e-cig?  Just a thought. 

    I agree. I'd love to see some more e-cigs, lol.

  • I really like them and hope they will continue despite the terrible circumstances of Russell's suicide.
    TTC #1 since April '09
    Dec '09 Laparotomy & laparoscopy for large cyst & HSG all clear
    August '10-June '11 TTA for hip surgeries
    Cycle #23...Dx: MFI, low p4
    2 rounds of Clomid (50 mg) = BFNs...October SIS & 2nd HSG all clear
    Plan after saving: repeat s/a + Clomid + Novarel + IUI
    image
  • imagemysterons:

    I would love to be a fly on the wall inside Andy Cohen's office.

    The insensitive and curious part of me really wants to see the season the way it was originally edited.

    Me too. Does that make me horrible?

    I want to watch the show still.Embarrassed

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards