for people who read PLL books - spoilers

hannamarin · August 2011

I just finished the books and now I keep getting confused as to what happened in the books vs the TV series.

I really enjoyed the books and I think they could have the same A in the TV show. Starting with Mona and then have the truth come out. that would be a good way to hold peoples attention. Next season could bring out Mona as A and then the following season could wrap it all up.

Diamond_Doll · August 2011

They've changed so much in the show that I can't figure out what's going to happen. In the books, (from what I can tell, didn't read them, just got too curious one day and wikipediaed) Jason/Ian/Jenna/Garrett were not part of the A storyline. I don't think they were ever connected or a team. I wonder if they'll stick with the books and have Mona and then you know who (not going to post, even though you warned of spoilers) become A, or if the show will go in a different direction. I thought reading the book spoilers would suffice my curiousity, but it just left me with more questions.

hannamarin · August 2011

Diamond_Doll:
They've changed so much in the show that I can't figure out what's going to happen. In the books, (from what I can tell, didn't read them, just got too curious one day and wikipediaed) Jason/Ian/Jenna/Garrett were not part of the A storyline. I don't think they were ever connected or a team. I wonder if they'll stick with the books and have Mona and then you know who (not going to post, even though you warned of spoilers) become A, or if the show will go in a different direction. I thought reading the book spoilers would suffice my curiousity, but it just left me with more questions.

yep, definitely left me with more questions about the TV show.

BethaBoo · August 2011

Reading the books definitely left me more confused as to what would happen in the TV show. I keep wondering if they will follow through on the Mona storyline from the books in the show or if that will get left behind.

thatgirlang · August 2011

They keep saying that they are doing it totally differently than the books. (I didn't read them either but looked it up one day.) But sometimes I wonder if they just say that to throw us off. LOL

Someone tell me- in the books, is A really everywhere for all of the girls like in the show? The way the show is written, it has to be more than one person for me to even consider believing it!

AKuzReve · August 2011

The show is so different from the books that I don't even bother thinking I know what the deal is.

mjbressan · August 2011

I don't feel like Mona would be A because they barely show her on the show. She has been pooping up a little more in the past few episodes, but not enough to justify her as A. I do think Courtney could be A and that would explain the other shadow in Jason's window.

hannamarin · August 2011

I think if I hadnt read the book and the TV show made Courtney as A, I would actually be annoyed. I would consider it a copout and almost as bad as "it was all a dream" but for some reason, in the book, I liked it. I thought it was a very good twist.

However, they would definitely have to send Hanna to the hospital as part of this.

mjbressan · August 2011

Hannah was already in the hospital after the car hit her and she "saw" Ali... Could have been Courtney.

hannamarin · August 2011

mjbressan:
Hannah was already in the hospital after the car hit her and she "saw" Ali... Could have been Courtney.

I meant the mental hospital, but I forgot about this part. This could be something that works.

for people who read PLL books - spoilers

Re: for people who read PLL books - spoilers

Choose Another Board

Search Boards