March 2009 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

xp - friend rejected a " gift "

warning - its long

 

I appreciate any input, because I understand everything has two sides - and I'm sure this will be long

DH and I hang out with a coworker and her husband semi regularly ( once a week or so )   I have known said coworker for 1 1/2 years and she is a very nice person.

the past few weeks when they have come over, her husband has mentioned that he needed a case for his cell phone, but with the kids going back to school and other unexpected bills, money was really really tight.  I asked him, in conversation, what kind of phone he had and he told me.  the next day on ebay, I found a case on ebay for $5 with free shipping.

today, I went into work and said to my coworker, " hey, give this to your DH, its a cell phone case.  I know how much he said he needed one " at first she took it, said thanks but was very hesitant.

10 minutes later she asks to speak with me and this is the conversation

cw - my DH can't accept this gift 

me - okay, but its not a gift per se, I just thought he would like to have one and I can't return it - I bought it on ebay

sw - you are a female, and I do not find it acceptable for my husband to accept a gift from a female who is not his wife or family member.

me - okay, it was only $5 but I am literally going to throw it away

cw - I can give you $5, but this just isn't acceptable

me - okay .. ( then I just went back to my desk )

  

so -- was I overstepping some sort of unknown " line " ? a male friend of Dh and mine bought me a dough hook for my Kitchen Aid out of nowhere, I accepted it, I offered him money and he declined saying it wasn't necessary -- I really like to try to be nice and surprise people with little things.  I realize its just a cell phone case, I'm not worried about $5 -- I guess she hurt my feelings. 

Re: xp - friend rejected a " gift "

  • Well, I'm baffled!! That was very nice and thoughtful of you and I don't think you were overstepping any bounds. I'm just sitting here trying to figure out what her real issue with it is.... Do you think she maybe felt like it was a gift out of pity and that it embarrassed her because they can't afford one themselves? I just can't see how you being a girl is the real reason. (Edited to add more thoughts)
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • And I would have had hurt feelings too!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I also am wondering if it was more of an embarrassment issue for her and that's just what she told you to save face, ya know?  Otherwise, I don't know.  If that were me, I'd be like SWEET, one less thing I have to buy him!  lol
    image

    PCOS and Endo

    Ovarian drilling and endo removed 1/3/12
    BFP - 3/27/12
    Beta's 11, 14, 57, 637, 2800
    Sono showed no baby and teeny tiny sac. Waiting to M/C naturally.

  • imageKSMILEY 77:
    Well, I'm baffled!! That was very nice and thoughtful of you and I don't think you were overstepping any bounds. I'm just sitting here trying to figure out what her real issue with it is.... Do you think she maybe felt like it was a gift out of pity? I just can't see how you being a girl is the real reason.

    I also posted this on D&R - and so no one has mentioned pity -- I never thought of it like that, but I don't think so ... it really just confuses me and kinda pisses me off ... Sad 

  • I find this strange.

    Do you think she actually told her DH that you got it?  Maybe she is just flat out not accepting it on his behalf?

    I'm very puzzled.  You went out of your way to be nice.  IMO a lot of people don't know some of the cheap things you can get on ebay, so I would take it as you went out of your way to be nice.  If her husband mentioned he needed new underwear and you bought some on ebay, yes that would be strange, but a cell phone case?

    Some people have very, very strange marriages.  Maybe there are lots of insecurities that you know nothing about.  Can you think of any other strange comments of things in the past that may help prove this theory true?

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Some of our obsessively conservative friends are like this. Well, actually not so much him as her. After they got married, he was no longer "allowed" to talk to his female friends independent of his wife. I don't see what that's supposed to accomplish besides being ridiculous. 

    I would try not to take it personally. It's silly, and you can never really predict which couples are going to have these kind of "rules."

    imageimageimage
    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • Okay, so I'm sure you didn't mean it this way, but I can see where the wife is coming from.  It's a little weird to be giving a random gift to someone else's husband, especially since you haven't known them that long.  I mean, I'm not overly conservative, but I don't think I would ever do that, even with the husbands of my best friends.

    I mean, it was a really nice gesture, I just think her "line" is in a different place than yours.

  • even if she didn't want to accept the gift, she could've at least said, " oh thank you " and then throw it out at home ...

    I am the person when I am out shopping and I see something I think someone needs or would like ( like under $5 ) I would gladly pick it up - its not hurting me and I enjoy it -- the whole situation makes me not want to do that for anyone anymore, male or female. 

  • Where I come from, your friend is kind of a freak.  But then, you have to understand my perspective, where the majority of my friends are male and one of those is my best friend.  And E has a lot of female friends.  Heck, on our honeymoon he bought a gift for one of his female friends.

    I have male friends who'd get me inexpensive thoughtful stuff even though I'm married, and I'd do the same for my single and/or married male friends.  I just don't read a lot into things.

    Some people do, though.  It really sounds like she's just got these ideas of what's appropriate and even though she's weird about it, there's not much you can do except forget it and not take it personally.  And sneer a little internally.

  • imagethe domesticated newlywed:

    even if she didn't want to accept the gift, she could've at least said, " oh thank you " and then throw it out at home .... 

    I totally agree! I was raised to accept the gift and politely thank them. I had a student give me a cheapo fake hair piece to wear during my wedding.... It wasn't even the same color as my hair!! But I accepted it, acted so excited about it, said thank you, and chucked it as fast as I could (as bad as I felt doing it).
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageLarissaAnn:

    I have male friends who'd get me inexpensive thoughtful stuff even though I'm married, and I'd do the same for my single and/or married male friends.  I just don't read a lot into things.

    exactly !  I have historically always had more male friends than females ( nothing but catty b!tches ! haha jk ) 

    I asked DH what he thought and said, " not everyone is like us honey - I wouldn't have minded at all.  she could've at least been appreciative "

    oh well, tomorrow is another day.

     

    thanks ladies ! 

  • imageKSMILEY 77:
    imagethe domesticated newlywed:

    even if she didn't want to accept the gift, she could've at least said, " oh thank you " and then throw it out at home .... 

    I totally agree! I was raised to accept the gift and politely thank them. I had a student give me a cheapo fake hair piece to wear during my wedding.... It wasn't even the same color as my hair!! But I accepted it, acted so excited about it, said thank you, and chucked it as fast as I could (as bad as I felt doing it).
    OMG. I wish you would have posted a pic.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageKSMILEY 77:
    imagethe domesticated newlywed:

    even if she didn't want to accept the gift, she could've at least said, " oh thank you " and then throw it out at home .... 

    I totally agree! I was raised to accept the gift and politely thank them. I had a student give me a cheapo fake hair piece to wear during my wedding.... It wasn't even the same color as my hair!! But I accepted it, acted so excited about it, said thank you, and chucked it as fast as I could (as bad as I felt doing it).

    I'm in this boat also. Just say thank you, take it, and do what you want with it.

    I think she was possibly part embarrassed, part WTF are you hitting on my man...which I think is actually ridiculous since you're married and you guys have hung out regularly...so I am leaning toward embarrassed and pity... 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I agree that she was probably more embarrassed than anything. She still could've accepted the gift and just chucked it later or whatever, but instead, she did that and made things awkward. It's not like you gave him some super expensive new machine or something...it was a phone case. I guess people just handle situations differently...
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • That's odd, and I think I would have some hurt feelings as well.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards