Baltimore Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

A WWYD-real estate related

This is just a lame attempt by me to get the board moving a bit, but I was talking to a friend the other day and wanted to see what others would do in their situation.

About 4 years ago he bought a house in a pretty sketchy area that was supposed to be "up-and-coming". There were a lot of new retail shops and restaurants planned for nearby and people had been flipping houses in the neighborhood trying to fix them up. Historically the neighborhood has been very bad-think drug deals in broad daylight, shootings, etc. However there was a core group of people committed to cleaning up the neighborhood and turning it around, lots of homeowner meetings, etc, so it sounded promising.

Fast forward about 4 years and he's throwing in the towel and selling ASAP. Crime is still a big problem and a large percentage of the residents there are apathetic and have no desire to change anything. He's also looking to start a family soon and I think that is playing into it as well. I think a lot of people had hopes for revitalizing this place but nothing is really changing. He doesn't even want to rent the place out-just wants to wash his hands of it.

So my question is, would you be willing to take a gamble like that? How long do you think you could stick it out and at what point would you say its time to go? I know there has been great success in turning around some neighborhoods but obviously sometimes plans backfire.

Lilypie Third Birthday tickersLilypie First Birthday tickers

Re: A WWYD-real estate related

  • Well I know that the market is crappy right now. MIL is a REA. Do you know how much will your friend lose if he sells now?

    I know we bought our house 4 years ago and if we sold now we would not get as much as we paid for it. We did put $ down so we would still walk away with some after the mortgage is paid off. But not nearly as much as we put down.

  • I personally wouldn't take a gamble like that. Certainly not now with a growing family. But it does sound like it was promising a few years back and it's a shame nothing has happened. What happened to that core group? Did they all bail?

    Selling the house might be pretty hard. We bought our house (in a nice and increasingly popular area) 5 years ago and we'd be lucky to sell it for what we bought it for. We've done some major renos and plan a couple more upgrades before we sell and we hope it'll pay off but those inflated prices from a few years back are killing us.

    image

    BFP#1: 01/10, M/C 6w -- BFP#2: 06/10, M/C 5w -- BFP#3: 09/10, DS born June 1, 2011
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

    BFP#4: 07/12, M/C 5w3d -- BFP#5: 12/12, EDD 08/18/13
    BabyFruit Ticker

    Decorate This
  •  

    Warning - this is long - this is a topic I think about a LOT.  

    H and I have this discussion a lot.  I know several people who bought in Pigtown (excuse me, "Washington Village") and it just hasn't made the turn around like Canton and Federal Hill, and now Locust Point as well.   Ridgely's Delight was the same way in my opinion - you kept hearing "it's in transition" but for how long?  Which brings me to my next point... 

    It certainly is a gamble and some people are lucky. I would only do it if I were willing to buckle down for the long haul. Neighborhoods don't change over night, or even in a few years.  It takes a while and you have to really make a commitment to the neighborhood, and the city has to make a commitment.

    My current neighborhood is a great example of this.  We live in Otterbein now and my landlords have lived here for 30 years (they are living in their second Otterbein house, and they own a condo in the neighorbhood plus my TH and some other house I think too).  They love it here.  Now, Otterbein is a very nice neighborhood and houses are pricey here. But they weren't that way 30 years ago. My LLs are very open with talking about how when they bought their first house here, it was a HUGE gamble and they had no idea what the neighborhood would do.   Their first TH was a good size here but they sold and bought a 4600 square foot TH (yeah, it's monstrous) in 1991 and firmly implanted themselves in the neighborhood. They are both doctors and make a lot of money and could afford to live in one of the pricey suburbs, but the husband told my mom once that he believed very strongly that the city needed people like him and his wife - professionals with money basically.

     Here's a quote from the Sun about this exact thing:

     The neighborhood just west of the Inner Harbor [Otterbein] had been entirely gutted when Schaefer started the $1 homesteading program that brought the area back to life.

    [Becky's landlord], an Otterbein resident, would have been lying to say she was happy to move to Baltimore 30 years ago. But her husband had won a fellowship at Johns Hopkins Hospital. He promised her that after two years, their next city would be her choice.

    But there would be no "next city." The [landlords]? who moved from Washington ? stayed. Willingly. And largely because of Schaefer's efforts.

    They initially moved into a new house in the neighborhood, and then bought a place that had been previously sold and fixed up through the homesteading program.

    //
    "Before urban renewal, the only way to be caught in this neighborhood was if you were dead," said [Becky's landlord], who raised three children  and credits Schaefer with the turnaround. "He made it attractive and he made it alive."
     
    So that's kind of what I'm talking about (that's from an article about Schaefer's death, hence the pro-schaefer spin, but you still see what I'm saying I think.)  That's an example of a neighborhood that did turn around and make the transition and did it very successfully.  But it was with a lot of help from the city, and it was with a lot of help from the residents themselves in terms of settling in for the long haul (lots of people here have lived here since then.)   You've gotta be willing to ride out the tough times. You also have to be politically involved I think. We have no bars or businesses here which I think helps, bc its just purely residential. It makes it a nice place to raise a family. Parking is very restricted given our proximity to the stadiums (even more so here than in Ridgely's.)
     
    SO, with all that said - would I do it? I'm honestly not sure.  I love city life and H and I often try to decide where will go when we are done here, but right now we're not sure.
     
    I will also say there is a difference between "transitional" neighborhoods themselves sometimes. I would only move to a neighborhood that was "transitioning" that was next to a more successful neighborhood, bc I think it spills over.
     
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • He thinks he can get close to what he paid for it if he can list it without having to drop the price. I get the feeling he would even be willing to lose some $ on it. He bought it for so cheap that his mortgage payment is really low, allowing him to save a lot of $ in the past few years.

    I don't think anything really happened to the core group, I just think they are outnumbered and after the economy turned, they didn't have the young professionals coming in like they had been.

    Becky-that was a great example. Some neighborhoods have been totally transformed (think Canton). My mom says that way back when, Canton was "seedy and full of bikers" and now she couldn't even afford a house there. lol. It really is such a gamble and I honestly don't know if I would have the guts to do it.

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickersLilypie First Birthday tickers
  • I thought a lot about this when I was buying a house back in the early spring. I took advice from my parents, who have moved a lot, and bought a smaller, non-renovated home in an established neighborhood for 175k (the house next door to us sold at the same time for 220k). Over the next couple years, we'll put some money and sweat equity into it and bring it up to the same level as the other homes in our neighborhood, and maybe by the then, the market will have even gone up a bit and we plan to make money on it.
  • I'd be willing to take a gamble like that in the abstract. 

    But not now I think...we want to have kids soon and the idea of having to deal with not just "not so good" schools, but actually unsafe schools scares the shiit out of me.  As does having to budget for private school.  But later...when we're kicking the future kids out of the nest?  maybe.

    My mom bought a house in south philly that is definitely in a transitioning neighborhood.  2 blocks away there are beautiful houses that have been fully renovated.  2 blocks the other direction - it's still pretty scary.

    her street is a mix.  There are some houses which have been renovated and are owned by DINKs, mostly it's lower-income families, and then there are two houses that have entirely too much foot traffic.  It's safe enough that I walk my dog at night without a worry (as long as I don't head the wrong direction), but my sister's car was broken into while parked one block over (they stole her body pillow.  Nothing else.  Just the pillow.  I'm guessing homeless? Or really high.  Or both.)

    It's interesting watching the pattern though.  In philly at least it goes like this - the gay people and the hipsters move in and start renovating and opening really fun bars and restaurants.  Then the yuppies come (in the true sense of the word.  Young urban professionals.  DINKs w/ good jobs).  Then the yuppies start breeding.  And then the neighborhood has officially "transitioned."  If it can't hold out till the yuppies start having kids, then it won't make it.  Mom's neighborhood is still in the gay people and hipsters stage.  Which she loves because she's one of them...but she's hoping that it makes the next step and doesn't fall back into crap.  It seems likely walking around...new fun shops and resturants open within walking distance of her house every time I visit.  The vibe is good.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards