Houston Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

opinions needed: RE WDW resort experience vs offsite

We're planning to visit WDW during Thanksgiving break. DD is 9yo and has never been. We've been several times for conferences and stayed at Swan and Dolphin. I really liked it and it was convenient to get to and from the parks, etc.

That said, we're also traveling with my in-laws and could rent a condo and split the cost. I'd want to visit every park possible so we'd probably stay the whole week.

My personal experience without kids at the resort has me leaning toward going the condo route and saving $$ (I assume?), but wonder if there's maybe something I'm missing that would be different with our daughter. Honestly when I'm at the resort for conference, I don't pay much attention to what the families vacationing are doing, so I have no reference to decide.

Any insight is appreciated!   

Re: opinions needed: RE WDW resort experience vs offsite

  • staying on resort you don't have to worry about transportation and you get the extra magic hours
    image
  • Thank you for reminding me about extra magic hours! We didn't use them the last time I visited because the parks/hours were limited (it was Dec) and I couldn't make it work with my conference schedule. I'm also looking at BookIt.com and they're offering about $35 off a 7-day ticket when you book with certain Orlando hotels which is not bad. Then again, if we went with a condo we could go to the grocery store and save a lot on food costs. I'm conflicted. 
  • I'd factor car rental, gas, parking, etc. and compare that to the onsite.  As for buying groceries, will you be eating many meals in the condo?  I can easily see having lunch and dinner at the parks.

     

  • i will always, always stay on-property when we go.  it's not something, in my eyes, that's negotiable.  the transportation and magic hours make it worth it, but it's just so much nicer of an experience.
  • I would def check out on site prices. Are you going for the actual day of thanksgiving? the time (I think starting the week after thanksgiving.) right after is super cheap, plus you can get the meal plan free around that time. You can even do the value hotels for less then a regular hotel ($89 night). And even if you do have a car it's free parking at the parks (I prefer driving vs taking the shuttle, faster and less motion sickness). We priced a deal for about $1k for 6 nights, family of 3 on site including deluxe meal plan, for the week after thanskgiving. 
    -Clare
    imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker imageLilypie Premature Baby tickers
  • Honestly, the savings for us was worth it to stay offsite (we had a 2 year old and a 4 year old) and I don't feel like we missed out on much at all. I've been three times before and stayed onsite once with DH pre-kid.

    We were all too exhausted to go back at the end of the day (except one day my sister and her family with the 4 year old went back to see the light up parade at Magic Kingdom). We took our lunch in every day and made dinner at the condo 6 out of 7 nights (used a crockpot for meals on the longer scheduled days at the parks).

    My answer might be different if we weren't completely exhausted by the end of the day and dealing with a 2 year old who desperately needed to go to bed at a decent hour :). When I went with DH, we DID use the extra magic hours to go back to the park after a nap (I was 15 weeks pregnant at the time).

    Transportation wasn't bad at all but we got to the parks early and didn't have to park very far away. My sister had a great schedule for us (she bought the $20 planner thing from Disney) and we saw everything we wanted to had never waited more than about 30 minutes so we were DONE by about 3 pm. This was in June and it was super crowded.

     ETA: My 2 year old had a great time but doesn't watch/know many Disney characters. That said, my niece LOVED meeting all the Disney princesses and staying offsite did not make a big difference in her Disney experience. I think either way you'll have a great time! :)

    It really depends on what you want out of the vacation. Making dinner every night and cleaning the kitchen afterwards isn't everyones definition of "vacation"! :) There are pros and cons to both. Staying onsite is definitely more convenient.

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • image04JaxBride:
    i will always, always stay on-property when we go.  it's not something, in my eyes, that's negotiable.  the transportation and magic hours make it worth it, but it's just so much nicer of an experience.

    This is me.  And add on "Will also always stay at one of the monorail resorts".  Being able to get back to my room in less than 10 minutes (if at Epcot or MK) was totally worth it, IMO.  AND not having to take kid out of stroller, wait in line for bus, hold, while standing, the kid and the stroller, and unfold and set it all up when we got off.  Not having a stroller aged kiddo might make staying at the other resorts okay, but I will never not stay onsite.  

  • imagebrideonjuly8:

    image04JaxBride:
    i will always, always stay on-property when we go.  it's not something, in my eyes, that's negotiable.  the transportation and magic hours make it worth it, but it's just so much nicer of an experience.

    This is me.  And add on "Will also always stay at one of the monorail resorts".  Being able to get back to my room in less than 10 minutes (if at Epcot or MK) was totally worth it, IMO.  AND not having to take kid out of stroller, wait in line for bus, hold, while standing, the kid and the stroller, and unfold and set it all up when we got off.  Not having a stroller aged kiddo might make staying at the other resorts okay, but I will never not stay onsite.  

    This.  After staying at the Wilderness Lodge, I won't stay off monorail ever again.  It was a total pain.  I cannot imagine staying offsite.  That being said, there are fridges in the room.  You can buy milk at the little shops inside the hotel and have cereal in the room for breakfast to save some money.  I would not be interested in cooking dinner after a day at Disney.

    Finley Anne ~ 11.9.2008
    image
    So Tasty, So Yummy
  • We stayed onsite the first time we went about 4 years ago at the Contemporary.  It was nice to be on the monorail but after going to San Diego and staying in a 2 bedroom suite, it's hard to go back to a typical hotel room.

    So we're planning on staying at the Homewood Suite in Lake Buena Vista when we go in January.  A one bedroom is only $113 a night and a 2 bedroom is $209 a night.  It has a separate living room and full kitchen.  LOVE IT from our San Diego trip.  Also, breakfast is complimentary and it's the hot stuff.  Minivan rental is only $500 a week but we want a car because we're planning on going to Universal Studio, Legoland and may also go to the beach if it's on the warm side.  They also serve complimentary dinner during the weekdays which for some reason, the girls enjoyed a lot because they were simple food (spagetti, baked chicken, mac and cheese...)  DH and I would order take out.  We don't need the magic hours because the girls are normally knocked out by 8pm and so it's not a big deal that we're not getting that extra perk. 

     

    Lisa. mommy to Emmy and Ally image
  • Thank you everyone for the responses! We definitely have a lot to think about. We will be going the exact week of Thanksgiving since we'd have to work with DD's school schedule; I would love to go the week after when there's better deals. 

    I do have a promotion email from Disney Destinations but I think it's good for every week except TG. 

    We are choosing to drive at the moment although that might change. If we stay offsite, I'd find an option that offered continental breakfast so we'd only worry about lunch and dinner. I'd try to bring in lunch as much as possible and figure out dinner.

    I hadn't heard about the convenience of monorail, so that's definitely new to me, although with a 9yo I don't think it'd be that difficult to travel between parks via other methods. 

    I'm really excited for this trip, and I just want to make sure we have the best experience for DD. :)

  • my kids weren't little when we went.  it's still annoying to have to wait for a bus, no matter the age!

    we slept in every day, went to a park for a bit, came back to the hotel, played in the pool, took a snooze, had dinner, then took advantage of the magic hours in the evening time!  mid-day and morning seemed to be the most crowded times, it seemed like the crowds thinned out late afternoon/dinner time.

    the later evening magic hours were truly magical.  we walked on rides over and over gain. 

    we also missed the hot-afternoon part of the day at the parks, and were in the pool instead.  that worked out really well for us... we had to get up "early" the day we did character breakfast but that was the only day we didn't sleep in. 

    having the park-hopper passes also served us well.   

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards