Grand Rapids Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Halloween and gender poll and discussion

Re: Halloween and gender poll and discussion

  • This is one of Henry's 5 reoccuring ideas.  I think he'd be a darn cute witch.  Jim would probably insist on calling him a warlock. ;)

    We're still planning on going the robot route, but part of me wants to let him be a witch just to rattle some brains.

    Willa 4.6.06 and Henry 10.18.08 Camp Sinki
  • This hits a little close to home... my son *loves* to "be" Ariel, Rapunzel, etc. :) My parents let me dress up as masculine characters (including a beret-topped French artist complete with a mustache) most of my Halloween-costuming years. I think I was only something overtly feminine once. Other years were gender-neutral (a crayon, salt + pepper...) or masculine.

  • I would absolutely get the pointy hat ready.  I don't see how this is a big deal at all.  :)
  • I probably wouldn't make any plans until 2 weeks before, since there are so many ideas floating around. Which would be very hard for me as I am already working on Henry's costume. 

    I was thinking a long the lines of a warlock. Tell him boys are called warlocks girls are called witches, generally, but that he can be either.  If he wants to be the witch, then do it up! I would fully expect neighbors to say something and my response would be, "You do realize Halloween is about make believe, right?"

  • I guess if it were me, I would offer different suggestions and alternatives to redirect him.  If he insists on the witch though, then I'd go with it.

    (Disclaimer: It's hard for me to visualize this situation without having a kid.  But the above is my inclination, for what it's worth.)

  • I saw let him be what he wants to be.  Big Smile 

    Did you hear that story last year about the little boy (5 maybe?) who wanted to be Daphne from Scooby Doo? The mom did a big blog post about it, and it spread around FB. 

    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • Id get the pointy hat ready ;)
    IMG_0888edit Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I have to answer honestly and say I'd try to convince him to be something else because I am doing the same thing with Maria.  She wants to be a witch and I just can't think of her as a witch.  Furthermore, I have a hard time sometimes with letting her wear black.    I know it's only one day and I'm not going to put up a fight if it comes down to it but I have made other suggestions and am hoping she'll take them.  For the boy in a girl costume question, I'd creatively call him a warlock...  Or what about this thing from Star Wars:

    image

  • Let him be what he wants to be.  This is one day where it's OK to dress up as anything you wish.  I don't think it's a big deal at all.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I voted "other" because I would remind him how awesome it would be to dress up as Bill Steffen, case closed.
    image
  • imageChymes:
    I voted "other" because I would remind him how awesome it would be to dress up as Bill Steffen, case closed.
    Bwahahahahahahahahahahahaha!! Oh yes! I want to change my vote to Bill Steffen!
    Ben & Shana - August 27, 2005
  • Henry's only 3, so I'm sure the desire to dress up as a witch has nothing to do with gender identity if that's the concerning piece here. This next bit is totally not targeted at you, GRSP, just a general statement. I think parents do a bigger disservice to their kids by freaking out about these things than if they just kind of let it go. I think there is some evidence that making a huge deal about what behavior/dress, etc is appropriate for each gender is more likely to lead to a child growing up with gender related issues than if parents are just relatively low key about things.
  • Tigers, I'd have nightmares if he went as that! 

    You guys are too easy.  I love the vibe we've got going on, but part of me misses the era of somewhat respectful debates.

    My holdup on the witch isn't that I have any gender issues.  It's just that he's got 4 other strong suggestions, and we've starting collecting things for the robot costume.  And the Bill Steffen thing, of course. ;)

    Willa 4.6.06 and Henry 10.18.08 Camp Sinki
  • imageGRsweetpea:

    Tigers, I'd have nightmares if he went as that! 

    You guys are too easy.  I love the vibe we've got going on, but part of me misses the era of somewhat respectful debates.

    My holdup on the witch isn't that I have any gender issues.  It's just that he's got 4 other strong suggestions, and we've starting collecting things for the robot costume.  And the Bill Steffen thing, of course. ;)

    Practicality always wins.

    My mom would never let us dress up as witches, ghosts, zombies, etc because we "didn't believe in those things".  Halloween was a marginally acceptable holiday in our house.  

  • imageDiana Prince:
    My My mom would never let us dress up as witches, ghosts, zombies, etc because we "didn't believe in those things".  Halloween was a marginally acceptable holiday in our house.  

    I was going to ask you about that.

    Willa 4.6.06 and Henry 10.18.08 Camp Sinki
  • imageDiana Prince:

    My mom would never let us dress up as witches, ghosts, zombies, etc because we "didn't believe in those things".  Halloween was a marginally acceptable holiday in our house.  

    Ditto. I feel somewhat strongly about that today, too. It's no secret that I'm not a fan of Halloween. I can see the appeal for kids wanting to dress like a character or animal, though.

    image
  • Yeah, I feel really "meh" about Halloween as an adult.  Choosing and implementing a costume just seems like way too much work to me.  I think the lack of energy around the holiday during my childhood has contributed to this since everyone else says "coming up with an idea is the fun part." 

    School is hosting a costume party at the end of this month and I'm pretty sure that is one event I'll opt out of.

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards