Entertaining Ideas
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Suggestions for my Christmas eve menu?

I just tried these out on DH last week and he loved them (I didnt spread the may on the bread, I used the "sauce" and spread it on instead for less mess- and no poppy seeds). 

They were pretty good...are they good enough for a appetizer buffet for the entire ILs for Christmas eve?  And, do I need to have the poppy seeds?

What else would you serve (heavy apps) to go with this?  There will be 2 children, 1 teen, and 6 adults.  Some of the adults are "big" eaters.

Re: Suggestions for my Christmas eve menu?

  • What's the usual tone of yall's Christmas Eve? Bc no matter what name you give it, that's a ham and Swiss sandwich. Could you see doing a variety of sandwiches? Would something fancier be more appropriate with this crowd?
  • Those don't say Christmas to me at all. Maybe a holiday brunch, but nothing special before a holiday dinner.

    I don't mean to discourage you, because I am a big fan of serving whatever strikes your fancy and fully expecting people to love it. But if you ask, a Christmas Eve appetizer would be better served as a platter of assorted cheeses and meats (ham, pepperoni, cheddar, jarlsberg) with a side of crackers or bread. Maybe some anti-pasta like olives, hummus, roasted peppers.

    In my family, shrimp cocktail is a big hit among adults and children. So, while not that original, it's a huge crowd pleaser. HUGE crowd pleaser.

    My darling daughter just turned 4 years old.
  • Yeah, these don't impress me, but probs 'cause my mom has been making a, better, version my entire life. 

    I think of Christmas Eve as a fancier affair. 

  • I plan making brie bites  http://fortheloveofcooking-recipes.blogspot.com/2009/11/brie-bites.html

    crostini http://fortheloveofcooking-recipes.blogspot.com/2008/10/crostini-with-gorgonzola-or-brie.html

    mac and cheese cups http://www.chow.com/recipes/30113-prosciutto-wrapped-macaroni-and-cheese-cups

    We will also have a cheese platter with crackers and smoked salmon/cream cheese crackers(I mix cream cheese with some herbs, pipe it onto thin crackers and top with smoked salmon)   We also do a honey glazed ham and a ham cheese casserole(similar to a quiche) that my mom always made for Christmas.  

    Christmas Eve is not a fancy dinner.   The only people we have over are my dad and brother and DH's parents.  It's time for the grandparents to spend time with the kids on Christmas without all of us feeling rushed.   Wejust  nibble all night.    It's not a formal sit down meal.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageakayf:

    I plan making brie bites  http://fortheloveofcooking-recipes.blogspot.com/2009/11/brie-bites.html

    crostini http://fortheloveofcooking-recipes.blogspot.com/2008/10/crostini-with-gorgonzola-or-brie.html

    mac and cheese cups http://www.chow.com/recipes/30113-prosciutto-wrapped-macaroni-and-cheese-cups

    We will also have a cheese platter with crackers and smoked salmon/cream cheese crackers(I mix cream cheese with some herbs, pipe it onto thin crackers and top with smoked salmon)   We also do a honey glazed ham and a ham cheese casserole(similar to a quiche) that my mom always made for Christmas.  

    Christmas Eve is not a fancy dinner.   The only people we have over are my dad and brother and DH's parents.  It's time for the grandparents to spend time with the kids on Christmas without all of us feeling rushed.   Wejust  nibble all night.    It's not a formal sit down meal.

    Fancy doesn't have to mean sit down. What' you've outlined here, to me, is fancy heavy apps. The op's ham sandwiches, while delicious to some, just didn't ring as "Christmas Eve fare" to many.  

  • imageTarHeels&Rebels:
    What's the usual tone of yall's Christmas Eve? Bc no matter what name you give it, that's a ham and Swiss sandwich. Could you see doing a variety of sandwiches? Would something fancier be more appropriate with this crowd?

    It's definitely not a fancy crowd.  When the ILs come around we definitely have to get super casual.

  • imageJim&Jaime:

    Yeah, these don't impress me, but probs 'cause my mom has been making a, better, version my entire life. 

    I think of Christmas Eve as a fancier affair. 

    Do you have a recipe for them you could share?

    Like I said in my pp, the ILs aren't fancy.  I have tried to go the fancy route on them with a full on apps and dinner and making nice and special, but they didn't like it.  They want all apps and finger foods.  The ILs are borderline white trash.  So, nothing fancy, super casual is what Im going for.

  • I would suggest some wingettes of some sort (don't have to be spicy), stuffed mushrooms & potato skins w/cheddar + scallions (with sour cream dip on the side)...
  • imageWA1215:
    imageJim&Jaime:

    Yeah, these don't impress me, but probs 'cause my mom has been making a, better, version my entire life. 

    I think of Christmas Eve as a fancier affair. 

    Do you have a recipe for them you could share?

    Like I said in my pp, the ILs aren't fancy.  I have tried to go the fancy route on them with a full on apps and dinner and making nice and special, but they didn't like it.  They want all apps and finger foods.  The ILs are borderline white trash.  So, nothing fancy, super casual is what Im going for.

    The ingredients are almost identical, but the prep is what brings it over the top, as baking them gets a crust on the outside, while the inside is melty goodness:

     

    Baked Ham & Swiss Sandwiches
  • imageJim&Jaime:
    imageWA1215:
    imageJim&Jaime:

    Yeah, these don't impress me, but probs 'cause my mom has been making a, better, version my entire life. 

    I think of Christmas Eve as a fancier affair. 

    Do you have a recipe for them you could share?

    Like I said in my pp, the ILs aren't fancy.  I have tried to go the fancy route on them with a full on apps and dinner and making nice and special, but they didn't like it.  They want all apps and finger foods.  The ILs are borderline white trash.  So, nothing fancy, super casual is what Im going for.

    The ingredients are almost identical, but the prep is what brings it over the top, as baking them gets a crust on the outside, while the inside is melty goodness:

     

    Baked Ham & Swiss Sandwiches

    Interesting, thanks for sharing!

  • imagevvwalker:
    I would suggest some wingettes of some sort (don't have to be spicy), stuffed mushrooms & potato skins w/cheddar + scallions (with sour cream dip on the side)...

    Potato skins might work!  Wingettes may be too messy, and they hate mushrooms :(  Thank you for your help!

  • From what you've said about them, maybe try something like this:

    Sausage, cheese, and crackers

    Veggies and dip

    Ham & swiss sandwiches

    Roast beef & cheddar sandwiches

    Chicken tenders

    Oven fries/potato wedges/potato skins

    Green bean casserole (so there's something hot on the line)

    Some sort of spinach puff pastry/crostini/quiche for another green thing ;)

    Sugared nuts

    Box brownies with these melted on after you take them out of the oven

  • imageTarHeels&Rebels:

    From what you've said about them, maybe try something like this:

    Sausage, cheese, and crackers

    Veggies and dip

    Ham & swiss sandwiches

    Roast beef & cheddar sandwiches

    Chicken tenders

    Oven fries/potato wedges/potato skins

    Green bean casserole (so there's something hot on the line)

    Some sort of spinach puff pastry/crostini/quiche for another green thing ;)

    Sugared nuts

    Box brownies with these melted on after you take them out of the oven

    All of this I love, and I think they will too! 

    I love that you added another sandwich choice, and I will have to find some sort of green veggie thing like you mentioned. Love the sugared nuts and brownies as well!  Thanks for all of the suggestions, now I can get to work finding recipes!

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards