Entertaining Ideas
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Thoughts on *optional* diaper raffles?

Just curious as to what the consensus is if it's mentioned as optional on an invite.

Thanks.  Looking forward to your comments.

Re: Thoughts on *optional* diaper raffles?

  • Tacky.

     

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Tacky.  Although it says optional I would still feel compelled to buy the diapers and get a smaller gift.
  • image6fsn:
    Tacky.  Although it says optional I would still feel compelled to buy the diapers and get a smaller gift.

    Nice to get a different persepective.  I recently went to a shower where it was optional and I just thought to myself "ok, I'll stick to the nice gift and skip the diapers." It didn't cross my mind to get a smaller gift and the diapers.  I would say about less than half of the guests brought diapers.   It was a small-ish sprinkle, so maybe that had something to do with it.

  • I loved it! I gave out $50 gift cards as the prize. Well worth it! My sister still has 3 boxes and her baby is 8 months now. It was frustrating that many people put diapers in the gift wrapping with their other gifts instead of participating. My best friend wants to do the same because her studio condo is too small for the extra baby stuff. Parents love practical gifts!
  • imagemch1987:
    I loved it! I gave out $50 gift cards as the prize. Well worth it! My sister still has 3 boxes and her baby is 8 months now. It was frustrating that many people put diapers in the gift wrapping with their other gifts instead of participating. My best friend wants to do the same because her studio condo is too small for the extra baby stuff. Parents love practical gifts!

    I wouldn't know not to wrap it.  I guarantee my mom wouldn't know.  Also, an 8 month supply of diapers takes up some room. 

    I also think sprinkles are tacky so...

  • imagemch1987:
    I loved it! I gave out $50 gift cards as the prize. Well worth it! My sister still has 3 boxes and her baby is 8 months now. It was frustrating that many people put diapers in the gift wrapping with their other gifts instead of participating. My best friend wants to do the same because her studio condo is too small for the extra baby stuff. Parents love practical gifts!

    Well worth the fact that it only cost $50 for 8+ months of diapers for your sister? Of course it seems that way, everyone loves free stuff. IMO, the whole diaper raffle thing is a lamely packaged way to get people to buy you even more things for your baby. To me, it would be like putting paper towels and TP on your wedding registry. 

  • I'm gonna disagree with the majority.

    If I actually go to a shower (bridal or baby), it's gonna be for someone I really love and don't mind spending money on. If I don't adore the person, I just don't go - I might send a gift, depending on the level of closeness. I don't send gifts just because I'm invited.

    So, assuming I'm going, I would either (1) bring a nice gift or (2) bring a nice gift + diapers if I wanted to win a prize.

    My Blog:
    Caffeinated Conversations: My Blog
  • imageJim&Jaime:

    imagemch1987:
    I loved it! I gave out $50 gift cards as the prize. Well worth it! My sister still has 3 boxes and her baby is 8 months now. It was frustrating that many people put diapers in the gift wrapping with their other gifts instead of participating. My best friend wants to do the same because her studio condo is too small for the extra baby stuff. Parents love practical gifts!

    Well worth the fact that it only cost $50 for 8+ months of diapers for your sister? Of course it seems that way, everyone loves free stuff. IMO, the whole diaper raffle thing is a lamely packaged way to get people to buy you even more things for your baby. To me, it would be like putting paper towels and TP on your wedding registry. 

    This made me laugh.  Wouldn't it be funny to go over to a board on the knot and find folks planning paper towel raffles?  lol

  • imageLittleLionC:

    So, assuming I'm going, I would either (1) bring a nice gift or (2) bring a nice gift + diapers if I wanted to win a prize.

    Sure if I had an unlimited budget I'd do this.  I don't though.  I know how much I can spend and even though it says optional I would feel like I should do it- not for the prize, but because the mom really wants diapers.  So the diapers become party of the total gift budget.

  • Also, as a mom who has purchased a lot of diapers, I know I get buy in bulk from BRU for XX rather than you paying a higher per diaper amount from Target or wherever, so, if you want to do the math, I would rather you spend $50 on a gift rather than $30 on a gift and $20 on diapers.

    I don't know if that makes sense in writing like it does in my head. 

  • image6fsn:
    imageLittleLionC:

    So, assuming I'm going, I would either (1) bring a nice gift or (2) bring a nice gift + diapers if I wanted to win a prize.

    Sure if I had an unlimited budget I'd do this.  I don't though.  I know how much I can spend and even though it says optional I would feel like I should do it- not for the prize, but because the mom really wants diapers.  So the diapers become party of the total gift budget.

    I don't have an unlimited budget either, which is why if I'm not willing/able to spend the money, I just decline the invitation to the shower.

    I should amend and say that my original post was unclear. I would include the diapers in the total gift price. If, say, I was going to spend $40 on a gift and I bought $15 worth of diapers, I'd buy a $25 instead. But I wouldn't, like, buy diapers and then just stick a $3 pack of bibs on top as the gift and call it a day (which is how I was reading previous posts that said if they had to buy diapers, they'd buy a cheap gift). If my budget was only $15 and I couldn't afford diapers and a gift, I just wouldn't buy the diapers.

    I've never thought of a diaper raffle as something that you "should" participate in, whether it says optional or not. But, I also never think of diaper raffles as something the mom requests, but as something the party planner invents as a game. Then again, I don't have kids, so I don't know.

    My Blog:
    Caffeinated Conversations: My Blog
  • I also don't have a problem with them. I actually have more of a problem if the parents register for only really expensive luxury items- like 3 swings and two high tech video monitors. But a diaper raffle I feel is the same as a bridal shower where you bring things just for the kitchen. It's like a registry at all. It's stuff the parents actually needs. Yes, the parents are ultimately responsible for meeting the needs of their children and you could give them just 57 cutsie newborn outfits, but why not give something (bottles, diaper geenie refills, socks, snot sucker ball (whatever that's called)- all not glamorous, but super useful) that the parents need?
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards