D.C. Area Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Help, my Cranberry Sauce didn't thicken!

I made my cranberry sauce last night. Since I've never made it before, I wanted to taste it this morning and make sure it tastes good.

It didn't thicken up at all - the recipe said it would get thicker as it cools. 

This is the recipe I used:

http://tastykitchen.com/recipes/holidays/cranberry-pomegranate-sauce/

Can I cook it some more tonight? Or should I buy new ingredients on the way home & start over?

Re: Help, my Cranberry Sauce didn't thicken!

  • Option 1:  Cook it more to see if it reduces/thickens

    Option 2:  Add shredded apple (apple has a natural thickener)

    Option 3:  Add cornstarch or tapioca or gelatin or allowroot (these are all flavorless)

  • cranberries are ridiculously high in pectin so i'm surprised it didn't thicken! 

    I'd cook more & then, if still not thickened, add a bit of gelatin to it.


  • The recipe calls for 12-16 oz of berries-- that's a big variation.  Since the bags in stores are 12 oz, I'm guessing that's what you used.  It just means you have more liquid than needed.

    Put it back on the stove to simmer for a while.  Let it reduce.  To test, put a bit in spoon and hold an ice cube against the bottom of the spoon.   See if it gels to where you like.  If no, keep cooking.  Then chill for several hours (overnight).  If still runny, just serve with a spoon like a sauce. If the taste is fine, no sense in starting over. 


  • imagejulie5220:
      If still runny, just serve with a spoon like a sauce. If the taste is fine, no sense in starting over. 


    this is actually a good point.  i was watching food network's thanksgiving marathon this weekend & in one episode alton brown said he served his cranberry sauce like a dipping sauce...everyone got their own little ramakin of it.  if it doesn't set up, you could consider doing something like that to make it intention!  I mean, if alton does it, it has to be OK!!!

  • imageSecretServiceWife:

    Option 1:  Cook it more to see if it reduces/thickens

    Option 2:  Add shredded apple (apple has a natural thickener)

    Option 3:  Add cornstarch or tapioca or gelatin or allowroot (these are all flavorless)

    Do both of these.  Add cornstarch 1 t. at a time, whisking it in, then replacing pan on heat.  Wait 5 min.  If you need to do more, add more.  Cranberry sauce is one of those very watch and see kind of things.

    White Knot
    Stand up for something you believe in. White Knot
  • I would have done a reduction. I have no clue about the cornstarch in cranberry sauces, but if it is like adding it to gravy then I guess that won't hurt!
  • imagekastle:
    imagejulie5220:
      If still runny, just serve with a spoon like a sauce. If the taste is fine, no sense in starting over. 


    this is actually a good point.  i was watching food network's thanksgiving marathon this weekend & in one episode alton brown said he served his cranberry sauce like a dipping sauce...everyone got their own little ramakin of it.  if it doesn't set up, you could consider doing something like that to make it intention!  I mean, if alton does it, it has to be OK!!!

    First of all, darn it I forgot to watch the Thanksgiving marathon - I really wanted to see the live show. Second, you're right - if Alton does it, it's okay! If I can't get it to thicken up (and good point whoever mentioned the 12 oz vs 16 oz of berries) I will just say it's a dipping sauce!
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards