Entertainment
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Michelle Duggar Miscarries 20th child

Michelle Duggar Miscarries 20th Child

http://www.people.com/people/article/0,,20552173,00.html

 A day of joyful anticipation has turned to anguish for Jim Bob and Michelle Duggar.

At a routine check-up Thursday to find out the gender of their 20th child, their doctor was unable to find a heartbeat and told the couple they had miscarried in the second trimester.

"After the appointment, we came back home and told the children," says Michelle, 45. "We had just been talking about baby names last night and they were getting excited about naming a boy or a girl. It has been a real sad disappointment."

She says the family will select a name after they know if the baby was a boy or girl, and then plan to have funeral service.

"I feel like my heart broke telling my children," says Michelle. "They have all been so excited about this baby and looking forward to April coming around and having a new little one in our arms. That was the most difficult. The Lord is the giver of life and he can choose when that life is ready to go on and be with Him."

The stars of TLC's 19 Kids and Counting previously weathered a medical ordeal with their youngest daughter, Josie, who was born in December 2009.

This was their second miscarriage; Michelle lost her baby during her second pregnancy. She was taking oral birth control at the time and cites this as one reason they couple together decided to leave the number of children they have "up to God."

 http://www.people.com/people/article/0,,20552173,00.html

Re: Michelle Duggar Miscarries 20th child

  • imagecrazyincidents:

    I don't wish ill on anyone - especially the loss of a child, but honestly, I think this is her body's way of saying, ENOUGH ALREADY!  With the health issues her last child gave her and now this, one would think that Michelle and Jim Bob would be smart already and call this baby making machine a shut down!

    Yes

     

  • imagecrazyincidents:

    I don't wish ill on anyone - especially the loss of a child, but honestly, I think this is her body's way of saying, ENOUGH ALREADY!  With the health issues her last child gave her and now this, one would think that Michelle and Jim Bob would be smart already and call this baby making machine a shut down!

     

    ITA. 

  • I still want to know how she could miscarry while taking birth control pills...
  • imagecrazyincidents:

    I don't wish ill on anyone - especially the loss of a child, but honestly, I think this is her body's way of saying, ENOUGH ALREADY!  With the health issues her last child gave her and now this, one would think that Michelle and Jim Bob would be smart already and call this baby making machine a shut down!

     

     Completely agree. 

  • imagecrazyincidents:

    I don't wish ill on anyone - especially the loss of a child, but honestly, I think this is her body's way of saying, ENOUGH ALREADY!  With the health issues her last child gave her and now this, one would think that Michelle and Jim Bob would be smart already and call this baby making machine a shut down!

     

    I agree with you.  Her last one was very sick and early and now this. My heart breaks for her as miscarriage is never easy. 

    Brenda & Phillip 10/10/2009

    After 6 years of failed cycles, we were blessed with our little man through adoption. 
    B born 1/3/2012, adoption finalized 12/27/12


    IVF - Sept 2013, beta #1 54.5, Beta #2 209
    S/PAIF welcome

  • imagecrazyincidents:

    I don't wish ill on anyone - especially the loss of a child, but honestly, I think this is her body's way of saying, ENOUGH ALREADY!  With the health issues her last child gave her and now this, one would think that Michelle and Jim Bob would be smart already and call this baby making machine a shut down!

    People say this every time someone mentions the Duggars, and while I agree, it's probably not gonna happen.  They've been clear from the get-go that they don't believe that it's up to them.  

    image
    Quincy and Dexter, new BFFs

    I used to be kris216.
  • I think they should not have any more kids. I do feel sorry for her and her husband but like everyone else said enough is enough. Their daughter was sick and was born early...I think she should have her tubes tied or have her husband get a vasectomy!!
  • imageDaringMiss:
    I still want to know how she could miscarry while taking birth control pills...

    that's not super uncommon. But I think she said in previous stories that she got pregnant on birth control, stopped the pill and miscarried. She felt like she caused it.

    -Clare
    imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker imageLilypie Premature Baby tickers
  • imagedexteroni:
    imagecrazyincidents:

    I don't wish ill on anyone - especially the loss of a child, but honestly, I think this is her body's way of saying, ENOUGH ALREADY!  With the health issues her last child gave her and now this, one would think that Michelle and Jim Bob would be smart already and call this baby making machine a shut down!

    People say this every time someone mentions the Duggars, and while I agree, it's probably not gonna happen.  They've been clear from the get-go that they don't believe that it's up to them.  

    I agree.  I'm hopeful that the end is in sight, at least within the next three years or so.

    TTC since 07/11 Me: 32 AO PCOS/DH: 32 Lowish count/motility IUI#1-3 = BFN (Clomid, Clomid-->Femara, Injects) IVF#1 ER on 9/24 19 ER/19 M/9 F w/ICSI Transferred a 5AA and a 5BB on 9/29 Beta 10/9 = 139 Beta 10/11 = 287
    imageimageAlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers

    My Blog

  • imageDaringMiss:
    I still want to know how she could miscarry while taking birth control pills...

    because birth control pills don't just keep you from ovulating, they also make your uterine lining thinner, so even if something happens and your egg gets fertilized, it makes your uterus an inhospitable environment.

  • They are not going to stop (or prevent) having children as it goes against their beliefs. I imagine that that do not see this miscarriage as her body saying "enough" but as God deciding they should not have this particular child.

    A second trimester miscarriage has to be hugely devastating. Especially since the whole world is watching (and waiting to say "I told you so"). I agree that their baby-making days should have been over long ago, but this is so sad to hear.

  • imageDaringMiss:
    I still want to know how she could miscarry while taking birth control pills...

    I don't believe they use birth control pills because of their religion. I read that somewhere. I think she should have her tubes tied though or her husband should get a vasectomy. They have enough kids now!!

  • imagesummergal1229:

    imageDaringMiss:
    I still want to know how she could miscarry while taking birth control pills...

    I don't believe they use birth control pills because of their religion. I read that somewhere. I think she should have her tubes tied though or her husband should get a vasectomy. They have enough kids now!!

    Quote from the article posted in this thread: "This was their second miscarriage; Michelle lost her baby during her second pregnancy. She was taking oral birth control at the time and cites this as one reason they couple together decided to leave the number of children they have "up to God.""


    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagesummergal1229:

    imageDaringMiss:
    I still want to know how she could miscarry while taking birth control pills...

    I don't believe they use birth control pills because of their religion. I read that somewhere. I think she should have her tubes tied though or her husband should get a vasectomy. They have enough kids now!!

    Part of the religion is to let God do as it sees fit. Having a vasectomy/tubal ligation is blocking what COULD be in Gods plans. They will never do that.

     

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • How is this even news? Her uterus is her business. And TLC's.

    I want a show when I have kids. Isn't that how it works? Get pregnant and get a semi-popular show on TLC?

  • This new broke my heart yesterday. How many weeks was she? 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagexokell2:
    This new broke my heart yesterday. How many weeks was she? 

    my guess is between 16 and 20, if they found out during their anatomy scan/gender check.

  • I agree with everyone that "enough is enough" but know they won't because of their beliefs.  

    Honestly, if you want that many kids PLEASE, oh PLEASE, just adopt. You obviously can handle your own sports team of children and there are so many children out there waiting for good homes.  

    DH and I would love to have a big home of children, but only plan to have (hopefully) 2 naturally and the rest we'll (hopefully) adopt.  

    image
  • imageMilsey32:

    I agree with everyone that "enough is enough" but know they won't because of their beliefs.  

    Honestly, if you want that many kids PLEASE, oh PLEASE, just adopt. You obviously can handle your own sports team of children and there are so many children out there waiting for good homes.  

    DH and I would love to have a big home of children, but only plan to have (hopefully) 2 naturally and the rest we'll (hopefully) adopt.  

    I agree with your sentiment, but it not that simple to "just adopt." And most waiting children need a thousand times more attention than either parent in the Duggar household is able to provide.

    Regardless, this is their belief system. To each his own.

  • I'm new here (hello!) but wanted to add something-Why they don't try natural family planning/rhythm method as a way to avoid getting pregnant?  Especially with how much difficulty they had with the last baby's birth, it seems like it'd be a good solution.
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • imageKatie829:
    imagesummergal1229:

    imageDaringMiss:
    I still want to know how she could miscarry while taking birth control pills...

    I don't believe they use birth control pills because of their religion. I read that somewhere. I think she should have her tubes tied though or her husband should get a vasectomy. They have enough kids now!!

    Part of the religion is to let God do as it sees fit. Having a vasectomy/tubal ligation is blocking what COULD be in Gods plans. They will never do that.


     

    Maybe a vasectomy is in God's plan? Wink

  • imageSEMelius5073:
    imagecrazyincidents:

    I don't wish ill on anyone - especially the loss of a child, but honestly, I think this is her body's way of saying, ENOUGH ALREADY!  With the health issues her last child gave her and now this, one would think that Michelle and Jim Bob would be smart already and call this baby making machine a shut down!

     

     Completely agree. 

    I also agree. All those kids could easily lose their mother to a pg complication. It's kind of sad.

  • I do agree that this is incredibly sad and that they probably won't stop. I just wish they would.

     

  • imageAngelSmitty:
    I'm new here (hello!) but wanted to add something-Why they don't try natural family planning/rhythm method as a way to avoid getting pregnant?  Especially with how much difficulty they had with the last baby's birth, it seems like it'd be a good solution.

    Cause then that TLC paycheck would go away.  And I truly don't believe this will be her last pregnancy.  They'll be doing this until she goes through menopause.

    The whole 'let God decide how many kids we have' sentiment is so ridiculous.  I roll my eyes every time I hear someone say it about the Duggars or anyone. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I think the Duggars are idiots. God (um sorry Nature) starts making pregnancy harder and harder the more children you have as well as the older you get. There are signs all around them. The body's ability to GET pregnant isn't the only "sign" around saying it's the right or wrong thing to do.

    Of course in general it's sad to lose a baby but I don't feel particularly bad for them. 

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards