Buying A Home
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Messy potential neighbors - WWYD?

I'm looking at a house that is pretty perfect, with the exception of the fact that the direct next-door neighbors (to the left) haven't exactly maintained their house to the highest of standards.  In fact, it looks pretty run-down and generally a bit messy.  The rest of the houses on the street are well-maintained and look fairly nice.  What would you do in this case?  Would you buy the house anyway?

Re: Messy potential neighbors - WWYD?

  • Run!!  We luckily sold our house and were in a similar position.  Our neighbor to the left never mowed (and would get mad if we mowed the portion of her yard that touched ours or if I called the city).  She did not maintain her pool.  It was a mosquito haven.  Partially full of rainwater, leaves, algae, the liner was falling in, etc. DUCKS lived in there during the summer!! I called the city about the Mosquitos.  It's was so bad we couldn't be outside (especially in the evenings) or we'd b covere in mosquito bites.  Her house was run down as well.  She is in her 60's and single (her kids and grand kids would rarely come help her do yardwork) so we offered on several occasions to help her out by mowing or picking up leaves and she did not want that to happen!  Ugh, I'm honestly so glad we moved!  I love my new neighbors! 
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagelil_jen051708:
    Run!!  We luckily sold our house and were in a similar position.  Our neighbor to the left never mowed (and would get mad if we mowed the portion of her yard that touched ours or if I called the city).  She did not maintain her pool.  It was a mosquito haven.  Partially full of rainwater, leaves, algae, the liner was falling in, etc. DUCKS lived in there during the summer!! I called the city about the Mosquitos.  It's was so bad we couldn't be outside (especially in the evenings) or we'd b covere in mosquito bites.  Her house was run down as well.  She is in her 60's and single (her kids and grand kids would rarely come help her do yardwork) so we offered on several occasions to help her out by mowing or picking up leaves and she did not want that to happen!  Ugh, I'm honestly so glad we moved!  I love my new neighbors! 

     

    Wow that sounds really awful!  The house next-door isn't THAT bad.  I mean, it's not a filthy pit or anything like that, it just isn't up to the standard of the rest of the street. I guess it's unlikely it will improve unless they move.  I just need to decide if I can deal with it, I guess.  My driveway would border their property, so maybe the installation of a fence would help improve things?  Hmm...

  • I would not buy a house next to one that is very rundown, but what condition are you talking about here? 
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Personally, I'd walk away.

    My IL's street is full of older (think 70's split levels and 60's ranches), but very well maintained homes. Then there is my ILs house.

    Their house isn't anywhere near the mosquito inhabited duck pond that the PP described, but it is run-down. The shrubbery is overgrown, the siding and windows need to be replaced, most of the trees on the property are covered in poison and are dying, the driveway is cracked, a few un-used bags of mulch have been sitting at the end of the walk for 3 years, the flower beds are covered in weeds, the chimney is pulling away from the house and that side is covered in mold, the septic is in disrepair, blah, blah, blah.

    They built the house 34 years ago and then never touched a thing (aside from mowing the grass each week). They don't have the money, inclination or know-how to do even the most basic of repairs or maintenance.

    Every other house on the street is nice but every other house on the street is worth a little bit less because of the existence of their house. And the ones on either side... forget about it.

    I guess if you intend to stay in this house for a long time, then you can take a gamble. But I'd find out if the people who are living there are older (which means hopefully in 10, 20 years family will take over the house and make it nicer) or if they're just young, lazy people who you'll be stuck with for the next 30 years.

  • imagekenandlaura06:
    I would not buy a house next to one that is very rundown, but what condition are you talking about here? 

     It is not incredibly rundown.  It just isn't up to the same standards as the rest of the neighborhood.  It isn't falling down by any means, just a lot messier than the rest of the street.  Lawn isn't as well kept, they keep some junky things outside on the driveway/lawn, etc.  The main issue is that their driveway and my driveway would be right next to each other, with no fence in between.

  • imagesrs5624:
    I guess if you intend to stay in this house for a long time, then you can take a gamble. But I'd find out if the people who are living there are older (which means hopefully in 10, 20 years family will take over the house and make it nicer) or if they're just young, lazy people who you'll be stuck with for the next 30 years.

    That is a good call, thanks for the thought.  This isn't a house that I'm expecting to stay in for a long time...maybe 5 years or so.  It isn't exceptionally large, so I'll need to find a larger one when it comes time to having children, etc.

  • imageredfoxtrot2:

    imagesrs5624:
    I guess if you intend to stay in this house for a long time, then you can take a gamble. But I'd find out if the people who are living there are older (which means hopefully in 10, 20 years family will take over the house and make it nicer) or if they're just young, lazy people who you'll be stuck with for the next 30 years.

    That is a good call, thanks for the thought.  This isn't a house that I'm expecting to stay in for a long time...maybe 5 years or so.  It isn't exceptionally large, so I'll need to find a larger one when it comes time to having children, etc.

    If it's just a 5-7 year house, then walk away.

    You might get a good deal on it now, but remember why you're getting a good price when it comes time for resale. Buying beside a turd means that you have to sell beside the turd.

  • When DH first bought our old home it wasn't as bad as I described in my first post.  She did maintain the pool and the house was rundown and DH had no idea if she mowed or not.  But over the years the pool thing just got out of control.  The first few years she would have chlorinated water in it and the grand kids would swim.  Then the next year it started out ok then by July the water was green.  Then the next year she didn't do anything.  Then the next year the liner fell and the rainwater started.  

    Wht I'm getting at is that these people aren't suddenly going to start maintaining.  If anything it's just going to get worse and for a maybe 5 yr house it's not worth it.

     Separate question:  most experts are saying you need to stay in a house for 7-10 years to "break even".  Why are you only looking for a house you'll be in for maybe 5 years?  I know the buying (and selling and moving) process is really stressful and expensive and I can't imagine doing it again in 5 yrs. 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Neighbors and your neighborhood are everything! I would not buy next to a run down house. Ever.
  • Well, as long as they live there, it is probably not going to get better and will likely get worse. 

    Personally, I would walk away.

    Crafts for Lily
    My Valentine Bookends (2~13~13, 2~15~09)
    image
  • And I would reiterate a pp that you should really consider not buying if you only plan to stay 5 years...you would likely be better off renting & saving more to buy more house in a few years.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I would walk. Because every.single.time I looked next door it would make me angrier and angrier for the next however long I lived there.
  • After having homes where we've had awesome neighbors on both sides, and seeing family members struggle with having crappy neighbors, I will strongly consider the neighbors before buying another house.

    We looked at one neighborhood that had a lot of what we wanted (large lots, ranches or split levels, good location) but the neighborhood is a mix of people that have maintained their homes and people that have crammed every car part they've purchased since 1974 into their carports.  The 'hood was a no go.

    We have ended up buying the problem houses in neighborhoods and turning them around.  This may be why we've had good neighbor experiences - they were happy to see the house look nice again.

  • image5thOfJuly:
    I would walk. Because every.single.time I looked next door it would make me angrier and angrier for the next however long I lived there.
    This. The house down the street from us is like you describe - junk sitting on the porch all the time, yard is not maintained, and these guys have a huge junky motorhome that sits in the driveway year round. You can't help but see it, and it makes that whole stretch of street look bad. We'd get angry everytime we drove by it.

    I'm sure that it isn't the reason we couldn't sell our house, but it's still an eyesore that we and all the neighbors hate.

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • imagekenandlaura06:
    And I would reiterate a pp that you should really consider not buying if you only plan to stay 5 years...you would likely be better off renting & saving more to buy more house in a few years.
    Not the OP, but we bought planning on less than 5 yrs because we have large dogs and there are no rentals available in this area for that. We found one apartment and it was a miserable 3 months of no yard and stairs. Plus relocation paid our closing costs so the last sale/this buy were a break even. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards