X-Factor 12/15 *spoilers*

Re: X-Factor 12/15 *spoilers*

• MrsD2006 member

  

  December 2011

  I was kinda surprised I thought Josh would go.

  Report0 Reply
• kjvogelsang

  December 2011

  I figured he would go. It's a shame because I feel like he was the most entertaining! I loved his smile! I still don't think Chris Rene is the "X Factor". I hope it comes down to Melanie and Josh.

  Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

  Report0 Reply
• rebecca2929 member

  December 2011

  I'm not a fan of Chris Rene at all.  I think it's time for him to go.  He just doesn't have the talent that the others had/have.  Marcus was more of an entertainer and had a great voice, IMO.  I hope it comes down to Melanie and Josh.

  

  Report0 Reply
• iLikeSloths

  December 2011

  I don't like Chris at all, and I think he should have gone home several weeks ago. 

  But, as long as Josh and Melanie stick around then I'm happy.  Both of their voices are amazing.  I'm interested to see who wins. 

  

  Report0 Reply
• Haribo1

  December 2011

  I also am not a fan of Chris Rene and wish he had gone home instead of Marcus Canty.  However, Marcus has been in the bottom two for three weeks in a row.  I think he stuck around this long because of the judges' saves.  I hope it will be between Josh and Melanie too.

  Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

  Report0 Reply
• thatgirlang

  December 2011

  I actually like Chris. I've only really liked him when he did his two original songs but in general I just like his vibe.  All of the comments are right- he's not the best singer but he has heart. I liked Marcus as well and thought he was a good entertainer.

  So.... this show is called the X Factor and this week it occurred to me that Melanie actually doesn't have the x factor! She is the best singer and I've assumed she would win all along but she is not really that entertaining IMO.  Her personality is not to die for either. But again, she is GREAT singer and I've rooted for her but she's really not a great performer.
  

  
  
  Baking Blog

  Report0 Reply
• SWOG31 member

  

  December 2011

  thatgirlang:

  I actually like Chris. I've only really liked him when he did his two original songs but in general I just like his vibe.  All of the comments are right- he's not the best singer but he has heart. I liked Marcus as well and thought he was a good entertainer.

  So.... this show is called the X Factor and this week it occurred to me that Melanie actually doesn't have the x factor! She is the best singer and I've assumed she would win all along but she is not really that entertaining IMO.  Her personality is not to die for either. But again, she is GREAT singer and I've rooted for her but she's really not a great performer.
  

  I completely agree with you.  

  Melanie has an excellent voice, the best in the competition, but I'm not really pulling for her to win.  There is nothing unique about her.  She is just another Kelly Clarkson, Jennifer Hudson, Jordan Sparks, Pia, Tamyra Gray(I could go on and on and on) that you see repeatedly on this type of show.

  I really appreciated what Astro and Chris Rene brought to competition.  Chris may not be the most talented singer, but he is talented(sings, raps, writes, plays an instrument).  I think I appreciate his uniqueness more than Melanie.

  I think Josh is the middle ground between Chris and Melanie, so I hope he wins. 

  ?/25 my chart

  Report0 Reply