DS2 has asked repeatedly for a pet. When DS1 turned 9, he got a green anole (lizard) and did great with it until it died. The problem is, the big boys are gone 1/2 time now and any pet responsibility would fall to me. DH is also not thrilled with adopting a dog, though we almost ended up with one a year ago.
Their dad has had multiple dogs and gets rid of them after a while when it's no longer convenient. (Grrr.) DS gets upset about it, but I don't think he understands long-term views, and fully understands that an animal will be alive until after he goes to college. He also wants a hamster or gerbil in his (basement) room, but I've been told they can smell a lot, and it's already too stinky down there for me. So far, I've said no to his pet requests.
I thought about surprising him with a fish tank for Christmas, and letting him pick out a fish or two. I don't know much about fish though, other than I've heard freshwater tanks are easier & cheaper than salt water.
WDYT - good, low maintenance pet or is it a bad idea?
Re: How easy are fish tanks?
From what I have dealt with and what I hear from my other half, Fish = total PITA.
We have a 30 gallon freshwater tank that really isn't all that high maintenance (right now). However, the start up & getting the little "ecosystem" balanced in the tank initially can be REALLY difficult. Honestly, the larger the tank, the less difficult it is to maintain once a tank is up & running, but starting one can be really time and money intensive.
oh & to address your question re: fresh vs. salt water...Freshwater is DEFINITELY cheaper! The salt water tanks cost more to get up & running & can get really costly when fish die & you have to spend $$ on the fancy salt water fish!
I agree with previous posts...and I as much as your DS might want it, I think I'd skip it (esp. since he won't be around 100% of the time to maintain the tank...you don't want that job!)
lol