Inspired by a MM poll - your e-ring.

lneuner09 · December 2011

Let's say your e-ring gets lost or stolen. Completely gone forever. Insurance is paying for a brand spankin new ring.

Do you get an exact replica of your ring? Bigger? Smaller? Better quality? A little different? A lot different?

Yes, I'm being a PW. Humor me, I'm bored and it's going to be a long day.

amelianguy · December 2011

I'd probably let Guy pick it out again. that's the special part about it to me. he put so much thought into it.

maryandkirk0909 · December 2011

I'd get a little bigger diamond that is round and not marquis- and keep the wedding ring with the sapphire trilliants.

steeser03 · December 2011

amelianguy:
I'd probably let Guy pick it out again. that's the special part about it to me. he put so much thought into it.

This. Except I'd let Andy pick, not Guy. :P

lneuner09 · December 2011

I'd probably keep things the same, honestly. I love my ring, I can't think of anything I would change, seriously. I would probably get a little better quality diamond. My center stone is an heirloom, almost 150 years old, so it's got a few dings and scratches in it. I'd be devastated that it would be gone. But naturally any new diamond would be a little better quality.

aStorie2009 · December 2011

I think I would stay with the same gold color, I have rose gold, but I might go with a different setting. Right now it's 3 bigger round diamonds but I like the one bigger stone.

law67 · December 2011

I'd probably keep things the same. Jay put a lot of effort into designing a ring he thought I would love and I do. I wouldn't sneer at upping the carat size of my center stone though Smile

kmo630 · December 2011

I would get the same one. I'm a very sentimental person, and it wouldn't feel right having a different one.

kelklump · December 2011

I am on my second ring- due to damage on the first so it doesnt bother me. I would opt for a bigger stone in the center now that the band is a little bigger with my new set but other than that I would keep it- I wouldnt mind a second band.

lilswimmer · December 2011

The same. It's big enough for my finger, but the only thing I want is a matching second diamond band.

michelle142 · December 2011

I really love my ring. It's already a good size and H picked great quality stones, so I would probably just get something the same.

sarges05girl · December 2011

Same size, same white gold. I would get a better setting though. The one in my ring now is really high and only 4 prongs. I'd probably go with a lower setting and at least 5 prongs (possibly six).

dbucks · December 2011

If insurance had covered it, I would have chosen the same ring, because it was my dream ring. That's why D picked it.

MBMcC421 · December 2011

I absolutely love my ring -- I would do everything I could to get an exact replacement.

pennstated912 · December 2011

I absolutely love my ring. It's so unique and beautiful. However, I know that the setting has been discontinued (it was being discontinued when Dave purchased it).

I would choose a similar setting, but I wouldn't be opposed to a larger sized center stone Same cut though.

ETA: Corrected misspelling and missed a couple of words. I apparently need more coffee.

Inspired by a MM poll - your e-ring.

Re: Inspired by a MM poll - your e-ring.

Choose Another Board

Search Boards