Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

BIL Girlfriend, le sigh.

Okay so FI and I don't have the best relationship with FI's Brother, but we're working on it. (In March there was a huge falling out between the three of us when he started dating his current live-in GF).

 So we're getting together and the IL's house tomorrow for CE and we got the brother something, and I want to get something for the GF from us seeing is how we got everyone else something, I'd like to be able to give her something.

I asked him what type of things she liked, he said "oh if you just want to get her something superficial I'd say anything thats purple or has stars, she likes that kind of stuff"

What a ballsy answer that really doesn't help me at all. Anyone have any ideas of what I can pick up last minute for this woman?

 

Wedding Countdown Ticker

Re: BIL Girlfriend, le sigh.

  • GC to some restaurant or store she likes.
  • Maybe a scarf or a piece of jewelry? Candles? I don't know anyone who doesn't like candles.

    image
  • imagesrgw:
    GC to some restaurant or store she likes.

    Sounds reasonable, but I don't even know what she likes XD all I got was purple and stars, and if that was what I was using for criteria I'd probably end up giving her a GC to Chuck-E-Cheese.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • Christmas ornament.

    A CD of Christmas music is another suggestion.
  • You say it's a ballsy answer, but yet.... why exactly do you want to get her a gift?  Look at it from his perspective - it's the day before CE.  To be asking him NOW what to get her.... eh, it's probably coming across as a last minute thought and that you're doing it because you feel you "have" to, not because you want to. Which really is the situation - you just don't want to look bad that you gave everyone else something and not her.  You're not doing it because you want to extend an olive branch, or what have you. 

    We're right now - just yesterday and today - dealing w/ a gift giving issue w/ MY BIL's totally insane GF, but it's something she is giving to DS.  It's a long story that I'm not going to go into - but quite honestly, her giving DS a gift is REALLY annoying and we'd really prefer that she didn't.  (Keep in mind, he's 3 and she's never met him but has had PLENTY of opportunities to do so).

    So - it kind of affects my view, but I really am wondering what it your real purpose in getting her  a gift? 

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I think his answer was fine considering you're asking the day before the CE. I'd go out and see if you can find her a wallet or headband with purple and/or stars on it. If you can't then you could opt for a GC to a common place like Target, Chili's, etc. Or you could do a candle or something edible.
  • I agree with a cute scarf or maybe a pair of earrings. I would not do a giftcard.
    Making the decision to have a child is momentous. It is to decide forever to have your heart go walking around outside your body. ~ Elizabeth Stone
    "Don't marry a man unless you would be PROUD to have a son exactly like him." ~ Unknown
  • imageEastCoastBride:

    You say it's a ballsy answer, but yet.... why exactly do you want to get her a gift?  Look at it from his perspective - it's the day before CE.  To be asking him NOW what to get her.... eh, it's probably coming across as a last minute thought and that you're doing it because you feel you "have" to, not because you want to. Which really is the situation - you just don't want to look bad that you gave everyone else something and not her.  You're not doing it because you want to extend an olive branch, or what have you. 

    We're right now - just yesterday and today - dealing w/ a gift giving issue w/ MY BIL's totally insane GF, but it's something she is giving to DS.  It's a long story that I'm not going to go into - but quite honestly, her giving DS a gift is REALLY annoying and we'd really prefer that she didn't.  (Keep in mind, he's 3 and she's never met him but has had PLENTY of opportunities to do so).

    So - it kind of affects my view, but I really am wondering what it your real purpose in getting her  a gift? 

     

    Well actually I talked to him about it 2 weeks ago, I'm just now buying it. I want to get her a gift so that she doesn't think that we don't want to include her and acknowledge her.

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • imageblissfullyignorant:
    I think his answer was fine considering you're asking the day before the CE. I'd go out and see if you can find her a wallet or headband with purple and/or stars on it. If you can't then you could opt for a GC to a common place like Target, Chili's, etc. Or you could do a candle or something edible.

     

    yeah I should have mentioned that I didn't just ask because I'd been thinking about this before I just figured I had time to decide and now its CE and I don't know what to get her.  

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • You're a woman right?

     

    Candles, bath and body works or similar body shop type items, manicure/pedicure certificate, coach/kate spade (or other high end women's  brand) key chain (they can be as low as 25 bucks), the make-up/perfume counter at stores always have lots of various gift sets, GC to Sephora or similar stores. 


    Not all men are in tune with gift giving for women - perhaps he himself has trouble coming up with things to give her. If you got her a nice coach candle maybe they have one in a pretty purple shade. 

  • Earmuffs, slippers, a nice scarf, purse (there are really great sales around - - I purchased a bag for $25 at Banana Republic), a gift card to Starbuck's or Barnes and Noble, some kind of "home spa" set (lotion, gloves, eye mask., etc.), a nice candleholder, if there is something that she likes (like tea, coffee), get her a mug and a high end assortment of (tea. coffee), picture frame.......

    Bottle of wine, her favorite fragrance, ditto the pp - a gift set from a dept. store makeup counter.

  • As a person who is allergic to Bath and Body works products and has candles spilling out of a rubber maid tote because my coworkers keep giving me them and I can't use them fast enough - I'd go with something simple like the scarf/mittens route.  Even a travel mug with some really nice cocoas would be fine or a Gift Card to their local "everything" store like Target, Walmart, etc. 
  • iTunes card?

     

    ermm I dunno. I wouldn't have bought either of them anything. We had a falling out with my BIL and he still isn't getting jack sh!t from any of us.

  • I'm know I'm really late to this, but a one size fits all gift card really should have sufficed if you don't want to feel like you're wasting your money on someone you really don't know.  I don't know about you, but if someone got me a candle, bath &body works, earrings, gloves/scarves, etc. I would wonder why they even bothered.  None of those things are something I need and to assume so many people would be fine with it.  Eh...I don't think so.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageBrandySun:
    I'm know I'm really late to this, but a one size fits all gift card really should have sufficed if you don't want to feel like you're wasting your money on someone you really don't know.  I don't know about you, but if someone got me a candle, bath &body works, earrings, gloves/scarves, etc. I would wonder why they even bothered.  None of those things are something I need and to assume so many people would be fine with it.  Eh...I don't think so.

     

    heh, not late, I still haven't gotten a gift for her yet, I'm about to get up and i'll probably just end up setting her a GC.  

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • imageILoveToRobot:

    Maybe a scarf or a piece of jewelry? Candles? I don't know anyone who doesn't like candles.

    I hate candles and get rid of them ASAP. My family has lots of allergies to all the artificial fragrances.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards