Buying A Home
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Granite countertops .. are these necessary?

In watching HGTV I am noticing how many buyers have granite countertops on their wish list and many people turn away if the house doesn't have them. Are granite countertops really that important?

We are going to do a small kitchen remodel in the next month to add more cabinets, counter space and add a tile backsplash around the entire kitchen. In 06 we painted the cabinets white (nice cabinets with raised panel doors), added new hardware, crown molding to top of cabinets, new ceramic tile floor, new Wilsonart HD laminate countertops. It looks so much better than before.  

We would like to sell our house within the next year so I'm wondering if the updates we have done so far and plan to do will be appealing to buyers? WDYT?

Re: Granite countertops .. are these necessary?

  • I always groan at that... there are plenty of homes being sold without granite counters and stainless steel appliances.

    I would take a look at your neighbors' homes, and see what they have done. You don't want to have the "best" house on the block. On the other hand, you should do what you like--just realize that you probably won't recoup the expense of putting granite in. Almost no renovation will yield a 100% ROI.

    Your renovation and plans for remodeling sound lovely, btw. Counter and cabinet space almost always trump materials. But definitely get a look at your neighbors' homes (or even a new home community in your area) and see what they are doing for an idea of what is usual in your area.

  • Ditto pp.  It all depends on your neighborhood/area.  In my neighborhood granite countertops are definitely expected but that might not be the case where you are.
  • Also, keep in mind that those TV house hunting shows are staged. They have to pick a few they don't like, so they can have one they do like.

     I'm an agent and if one of my buyers told me they were turning down an otherwise fantastic home because it didn't have granite countertops, I'd tell them how easy it is to get them put in! Real-life people don't walk away because there's no granite.

  • We were just out house hunting.  We didn't rule out any house based on counter material.  Counter and cabinet space were premium.  The look of the counter and cabinets played into the decision, but not the material. We actually liked the non-granite counters.  It was prettier than the granite countertop.
  • I'm with audra, the look was a factor but not the material. Our kitchen is beautiful, with stainless steel appliances and nice countertops but they are not granite. I feel like the amount of counter and cabinet space and the fact that we liked the look of it was way more important than the material.

    At the time I thought that I would have preferred granite, but now I'm thinking that when we redo the kitchen in the future I'll stick with the type we have. 

  • I would prefer granite, but I'm not going to rule out a house just because it doesn't have it. I do, however, factor into the price if I really feel we are going to have remodel the kitchen or bath entirely because it is really THAT dated. But I feel like putting in granite is something we can easily do ourselves down the road if we decide we want it.
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic *This is not legal advice*
  • We weren't going to rule out any house based on countertops. Those are not that difficult to change, especially for us since my brother works at a company that does countertops so we could have replaced anything we didn't like at a pretty good discount.

    We definitely preferred granite or quartz to laminate, but it wasn't going to be a deal breaker for us. Nor would appliances ... appliances are not that expensive (unless you get the super high end ones) in the scheme of things. I would rather have a house with the right amount of space, a good layout and a good location and put a few thousand dollars into kitchen upgrades than get a house with the kitchen upgrades already done but is lacking in size, layout or location.

    I'm not sure if buyers in real life are as picky as those on House Hunters, and I know those shows are staged anyway, so perhaps those buyers don't care about granite counters as much as the editing of the show leads you to believe.

    image
    Mr. Sammy Dog
  • It's all about the price. As a current house hunter, granite does not make or break my decision to put in an offer. What does, (and I see this a lot around our area) is when sellers take an old, outdated kitchen and slaps in some granite counter tops. I HATE when they do this. Then these sellers think it's okay to put an over inflated price on their homes, and it's labeled as an "updated kitchen." I don't think so. These type of homes are sitting on the market for six plus months. 

    I would much rather an outdated kitchen I can gut out and make my own, that is priced right, rather than an old kitchen with granite. 

    BUT if I do a complete remodel, I will put in granite countertops. 

  • I agree with everyone. Granite countertops and stainless steel appliances have become the house hunting catch phrase of the decade, which stinks because there are sooo many other great options out there for countertops http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/home-garden/home-improvement/countertops/countertop-buying-advice/countertop-types/countertop-types.htm Laminate would not be a deal breaker for me personally, but because this kind of thing is important to some people, you'll want to look at what other homes in your area have to offer. Good Luck!
  • I'm not a huge fan of granite counter tops, especially the thought that they are a 'must have'. But, that being said, they have become much more affordable. The cost has actually dipped below many other options. And, they are a quick and easy selling feature: 'updated kitchen with granite counters'.

    Just my two cents worth :)

    Life is a roller coaster, enjoy it!

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    Lighthouse State Beach, Santa Cruz.

  • This truly depends on the pricepoint. I'm looking in the $500k range, so laminate is a deal breaker since almost ever house we've seen has it. When shopping for my current house, laminate was fine. I always think those people are crazy onHGTV when they want to spend $150k and expect granite.
  • imageCCinLove:
    This truly depends on the pricepoint. I'm looking in the $500k range, so laminate is a deal breaker since almost ever house we've seen has it. When shopping for my current house, laminate was fine. I always think those people are crazy onHGTV when they want to spend $150k and expect granite.

    With all due respect, most people can't afford to pay $500k for a house. I don't think these people are that crazy. 150K is still a huge amount of money. I understand if you're in a HCOL area. BUT, there are a lot of small towns across the country, that if you're paying $150K for a house, you better be getting granite counter tops and an updated kitchen.

  • imageAbeFroman:

    imageCCinLove:
    This truly depends on the pricepoint. I'm looking in the $500k range, so laminate is a deal breaker since almost ever house we've seen has it. When shopping for my current house, laminate was fine. I always think those people are crazy onHGTV when they want to spend $150k and expect granite.

    With all due respect, most people can't afford to pay $500k for a house. I don't think these people are that crazy. 150K is still a huge amount of money. I understand if you're in a HCOL area. BUT, there are a lot of small towns across the country, that if you're paying $150K for a house, you better be getting granite counter tops and an updated kitchen.

     

    I agree with this. We are in a pretty low cost of living area, and the economy is still burning the housing market. If you are paying 200K or more, you would expect updates, especially kitchen and bath.

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers Image and video hosting by TinyPicImage and video hosting by TinyPic *This is not legal advice*
  • imageAbeFroman:

    imageCCinLove:
    This truly depends on the pricepoint. I'm looking in the $500k range, so laminate is a deal breaker since almost ever house we've seen has it. When shopping for my current house, laminate was fine. I always think those people are crazy on HGTV when they want to spend $150k and expect granite.

    With all due respect, most people can't afford to pay $500k for a house. I don't think these people are that crazy. 150K is still a huge amount of money. I understand if you're in a HCOL area. BUT, there are a lot of small towns across the country, that if you're paying $150K for a house, you better be getting granite counter tops and an updated kitchen.

    if you're in HCOL, you can't expect granite nor an updated kitchen will automatically be in a house going for 500k. quite a few houses i've seen just under that in my area have the original, 1950s kitchen cabinets (usually painted and in decent repair) and sometimes really old laminate, tile done 20-40 years ago, or something else that isn't granite. you also cannot buy a SFH for 150k around here. they don't exist.

    so it depends on not only the price but your market.

  • We just looked at 20 houses in 2 weeks and while I preferred an updated kitchen, we ended up buying a home that we will do the kitchen upgrades ourselves. I am kind of excited to choose the granite myself!

    So I would say you will definitely make your money back on your upgrades because not everyone wants to deal with putting in new counters and tile and new cabinets. 

    I love tile backsplash, fyi! 

     

  • We used HD laminate in our kitchen when we remodeled it. It looks fantastic, and a lot of people walk in and say "Oh, I love the granite!" lol

    FWIW, we had no mentions of it during the selling process. 

  • We are getting ready to buy our 4th home and after having granite I would prefer granite- however a HD laminate is better than some alternatives.  If a house was perfect except granite I would not say no... and if a house had granite but was totally outdated I would say no.  I looked this week and neither had good countertops! 
  • Much more concerned about the size of the kitchen than the counter material.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards