Starting Over
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Opinions Please

Ok I finally took my counselor and fellow nesties advice that I need to be single especially with getting ready to move back out on my own. I need this time to work on those issues from my marriage that I never truly dealt with given the amount of people living with me.

Here is the problem. I finally broke it off with Z for good. Once again he brought up the ring. I asked for a right-hand ring for Christmas and asked for it as just that. Not a promise ring, not an engagement ring but a right hand ring. He said he feels buying a ring of any sort means to him a life long commitment with intentions of marriage. I explained that a right hand ring was no different than the watch or cuff links I bought him for Christmas. What do you think? Should I give it back? Keep it since it was asked for as just a gift?

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: Opinions Please

  • I think it's sort of lame of him to ask for a Christmas gift back, especially since it was a piece of jewelry not intended to mean any kind of commitment. If it were me, I guess I would just give it back if I thought it was going to create bad blood, even though I think you are in the right to keep it. But I would also think less of him for taking it back, so either way I guess we wouldn't really stay friends!
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic You gotta get spanked by a lot of frogs...
  • Technically, it's yours to keep since it was a gift. I even think you're in the clear ethically/morally if you decide to keep it. With that said, I'd just give it back to him to get rid of him. You don't need a reminder of him, and you certainly don't need to give him any excuse to keep contacting you.  

    someecards.com - North Carolina: Where you can marry your cousin. Just not your gay cousin.
  • Honestly? I'd probably give it back. I don't know how expensive it was, but since it was a gift given only a short time ago, I'd probably just give it back. I wouldn't want to wear it anyway.
  • imageHoolyGo:

    Technically, it's yours to keep since it was a gift. I even think you're in the clear ethically/morally if you decide to keep it. With that said, I'd just give it back to him to get rid of him. You don't need a reminder of him, and you certainly don't need to give him any excuse to keep contacting you.  

    *nods*  I'm with Hooly.

  • imageCarrotsMakeMeFat:
    Honestly? I'd probably give it back. I don't know how expensive it was, but since it was a gift given only a short time ago, I'd probably just give it back. I wouldn't want to wear it anyway.

    We're talking $400 tops. To give it back would probably mean having to face him in person. I couldn't bring myself to do it in person because he'll make me feel guilty and I'm not strong enough to stand my ground with something like that which led me to try to work things out before.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • can you leave it on his doorstep or something? in an envelope maybe? and then text him and say ITS ON THE DOORSTEP as you run away? lol. I would nooot want to face him. I was very glad, when I broke up with my ex he just left my stuff from his house in my garage.
  • That's probably one of the most immature moves I've ever seen in my life.  If you really want it, it's yours to keep, but I'd probably just give it back to him.  I wouldn't be able to enjoy the gift anymore because of his ridiculous reaction.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageachase123:
    That's probably one of the most immature moves I've ever seen in my life.  If you really want it, it's yours to keep, but I'd probably just give it back to him.  I wouldn't be able to enjoy the gift anymore because of his ridiculous reaction.

    Not as bad as the other comment he made. I explained that I need to be single so I can truly work through my issues. He knows I'm in counseling and that I have dealt with depression. He through in a low blow saying "If you ever get your mind right, you are welcome to find me. I doubt you ever will".

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageachase123:
    That's probably one of the most immature moves I've ever seen in my life.  If you really want it, it's yours to keep, but I'd probably just give it back to him.  I wouldn't be able to enjoy the gift anymore because of his ridiculous reaction.

     

    Achase and I are agreeing a lot these days!

    And, OP, I'm glad that you decided that breaking things off with Z was the best thing for you.  I know you've struggled with this decision, and I'm so proud of you that you're doing what's best in the long-run, instead of doing what's easiest in the moment.  

    So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.

  • imagejaksmom8808:

    imageCarrotsMakeMeFat:
    Honestly? I'd probably give it back. I don't know how expensive it was, but since it was a gift given only a short time ago, I'd probably just give it back. I wouldn't want to wear it anyway.

    We're talking $400 tops. To give it back would probably mean having to face him in person. I couldn't bring myself to do it in person because he'll make me feel guilty and I'm not strong enough to stand my ground with something like that which led me to try to work things out before.

    I agree. And BTW, I am so proud of you for standing your ground! Call him, break it off and send it back via mail if he so much as mutters a word about it.

  • imageachase123:
    That's probably one of the most immature moves I've ever seen in my life.  If you really want it, it's yours to keep, but I'd probably just give it back to him.  I wouldn't be able to enjoy the gift anymore because of his ridiculous reaction.

    I agree with achase.  Maybe mail it back.  You can pay $10 for insurance when you mail it.  Might be worth it not to see him again.  He sounds like an idiot.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Oh good lord. I'm so glad you are done with this kid. He proves ridiculously immature at every move. I'd go ahead and mail it back to him. I agree with no face-to-face. Technically you have every right to keep it, but I wouldn't want the reminder or to deal with him any more.
  • imageMintChocoChip:

    imageachase123:
    That's probably one of the most immature moves I've ever seen in my life.  If you really want it, it's yours to keep, but I'd probably just give it back to him.  I wouldn't be able to enjoy the gift anymore because of his ridiculous reaction.

    I agree with achase.  Maybe mail it back.  You can pay $10 for insurance when you mail it.  Might be worth it not to see him again.  He sounds like an idiot.

     

    Send it back with return receipt. Make him sign for it. You have prove he got it. 

  • I give him the side-eye for thinking that any ring (even a right hand ring) meant that the two of you had a life-time commitment to each other. Maybe if that was his idea of what a ring meant, asking for one gave him false impressions of your relationship? Not saying that's your fault, because you obviously didn't know he felt that way about what any ring symbolizes.

    Glad to hear you're going to work on yourself first and foremost.
    image
    Pregnancy Ticker
  • imagemarigoldgirl44:
    imageMintChocoChip:

    imageachase123:
    That's probably one of the most immature moves I've ever seen in my life.  If you really want it, it's yours to keep, but I'd probably just give it back to him.  I wouldn't be able to enjoy the gift anymore because of his ridiculous reaction.

    I agree with achase.  Maybe mail it back.  You can pay $10 for insurance when you mail it.  Might be worth it not to see him again.  He sounds like an idiot.

     

    Send it back with return receipt. Make him sign for it. You have prove he got it. 

    *nods*

    image
  • imageGhostofZeldaFitzgerald:

     

    Achase and I are agreeing a lot these days!

    Does this make me "holier than thou"?

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I agree - give it back. Why would you want to keep it anyways?
  • imagejaksmom8808:

    imageachase123:
    That's probably one of the most immature moves I've ever seen in my life.  If you really want it, it's yours to keep, but I'd probably just give it back to him.  I wouldn't be able to enjoy the gift anymore because of his ridiculous reaction.

    Not as bad as the other comment he made. I explained that I need to be single so I can truly work through my issues. He knows I'm in counseling and that I have dealt with depression. He through in a low blow saying "If you ever get your mind right, you are welcome to find me. I doubt you ever will".

     

    What a ***!!!! OMG well at least now you don't have to worry about missing him or wanting to get back together.

  • imageachase123:
    imageGhostofZeldaFitzgerald:

     

    Achase and I are agreeing a lot these days!

    Does this make me "holier than thou"?

    Haha!  It's nice up here on these horses, isn't it?

    So we beat on, boats against the current, borne back ceaselessly into the past.

  • Seeing his response, I think you made the right decision. You need to have someone more mature than he obviously is.
  • imagestarburst604:
    I think it's sort of lame of him to ask for a Christmas gift back, especially since it was a piece of jewelry not intended to mean any kind of commitment. If it were me, I guess I would just give it back if I thought it was going to create bad blood, even though I think you are in the right to keep it. But I would also think less of him for taking it back, so either way I guess we wouldn't really stay friends!

     

    Starburst speaks the truth, esp all that bolded stuff.

     

    I also like what another poster suggested about mailing it, insured, so you don't have to see him and he has to sign for it. But I think it would be "good for you" to face him and not let him manipulate you. You want to break up with him. That's not his decision to make.

    image

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards