Trouble in Paradise
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Did Beyonce fake her pg? Hmmm

Did Beyonce use a surrogate and wear a fake bump?

(opens in new tab or window)

I came across this today and even though it doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of the universe-- it got me thinking. All these conversion disorders and crazy medical things (seems to be the theme today). Why would someone lie about using a surrogate? Does that mean she thinks it is shameful to have trouble conceiving and using a surrogate? Why would someone lie about that?

Also, with these kids in NY (kind of relates to Bval too)-- I understand that some of them might be making it up for attention. I am wondering if they originally were faking and then got got up. Sorta like Cartman in the tourrette's episode of South Park (lol)?

 ETA: fixed link

image
Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
image

Re: Did Beyonce fake her pg? Hmmm

  • I was looking at her first post-preg pics today and thinking the same thing!

    I wouldn't be surprised...

  • What I found outrageous and unacceptable was the patent and complete lack of patient regard.You come in and "take over" an entire patient floor? And you cover the security cameras? How is that acceptable?

    Want privacy?

    Have a home birth. Nuff said.

    I am not a fan of him or of her. She's overstayed her welcome and so has he.
  • imageTarponMonoxide:
    What I found outrageous and unacceptable was the patent and complete lack of patient regard.You come in and "take over" an entire patient floor? And you cover the security cameras? How is that acceptable?

    Want privacy?

    Have a home birth. Nuff said.

    I am not a fan of him or of her. She's overstayed her welcome and so has he.

    I didn't know this happened. Gah I used to like Beyonce and think she was relatively down to earth. Then she has to go and behave like a twit. Booooooo.

    image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    image
  • If Beyonce faked the PG, she did so for vanity reasons, not because of fertility issues.  Supposedly Kelly Preston faked her recent PG as well - I'm assuming because Scientology is against surrogacy and they didn't want to be seen as hypocrites. 

    Beyonce's a vain diva, but she goes to great lengths to portray herself otherwise.

    This is my siggy.
  • imageBowiesInSpace:

    If Beyonce faked the PG, she did so for vanity reasons, not because of fertility issues.  Supposedly Kelly Preston faked her recent PG as well - I'm assuming because Scientology is against surrogacy and they didn't want to be seen as hypocrites. 

    Beyonce's a vain diva, but she goes to great lengths to portray herself otherwise.

    My first thought was if she did it would be because she didn't want to mess-up her figure.

    PitaPata Dog tickers
  • imageMortomo:
    imageBowiesInSpace:

    If Beyonce faked the PG, she did so for vanity reasons, not because of fertility issues.  Supposedly Kelly Preston faked her recent PG as well - I'm assuming because Scientology is against surrogacy and they didn't want to be seen as hypocrites. 

    Beyonce's a vain diva, but she goes to great lengths to portray herself otherwise.

    My first thought was if she did it would be because she didn't want to mess-up her figure.

     

    This. If that were the reason, I could see using a surrogate and covering it up. But if it were infertility - I can think of a few actresses who have used surrogates openly because of infertility and I can't remember any backlash. I just saw a story about Elizabeth Banks using a surrogate.

    I also can't see Beyonce as "down to earth." She's always seemed pretty high maintenance to me. 

    DD Lea, born 04/21/10
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    BFP #4 It's a BOY!
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
    CP: July 2011
    BFP #3: 11/3/2011 M/C 12/12/11
    We miss you and love you always, little firecrackers!
  • I'm watching the video at the end- Katie Couric's interivew.  Katie asks her about the collapsing bump and she does a good job of basically totally NOT answering.  "It's so crazy/ over the top".... uh huh.

     

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • imageBowiesInSpace:

    If Beyonce faked the PG, she did so for vanity reasons, not because of fertility issues.  Supposedly Kelly Preston faked her recent PG as well - I'm assuming because Scientology is against surrogacy and they didn't want to be seen as hypocrites. 

    Beyonce's a vain diva, but she goes to great lengths to portray herself otherwise.

    Thing is, if she did legit do it because of fertility issues and fessed up, this is exactly the judgement she would get, so either way I totally get why she did it. If she did it? (she did it, and will never, ever admit it at this point).
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageBettyBookworm:

    imageTarponMonoxide:
    What I found outrageous and unacceptable was the patent and complete lack of patient regard.You come in and "take over" an entire patient floor? And you cover the security cameras? How is that acceptable?

    Want privacy?

    Have a home birth. Nuff said.

    I am not a fan of him or of her. She's overstayed her welcome and so has he.

    I didn't know this happened. Gah I used to like Beyonce and think she was relatively down to earth. Then she has to go and behave like a twit. Booooooo.



    What if there was an indicent on the floor??? They won't know any details -- Anything could have happened up there, thanks to them.

    Lennox Hill Hospital was always for the well heeled and upper crust. In this case, thse 2 sure had a lot of crust.:(

    And to be fair, not every woman shows a lot -- some hardly show signs of carrying a baby and therea re still some women who don't announce a pregnancy until pretty late in their gestation. Not everybody says they're pregnant as soon as the pee hits the stick.:)
  • SO WHAT IF SHE FAKED HER PREGNANCY.  WHAT DOES IT MATTER?
  • imageTarponMonoxide:

    What if there was an indicent on the floor??? They won't know any details -- Anything could have happened up there, thanks to them.

    Lennox Hill Hospital was always for the well heeled and upper crust. In this case, thse 2 sure had a lot of crust.:(

    And to be fair, not every woman shows a lot -- some hardly show signs of carrying a baby and therea re still some women who don't announce a pregnancy until pretty late in their gestation. Not everybody says they're pregnant as soon as the pee hits the stick.:)

    I believe they rented the entire floor, so no one else was giving birth up there.

    I love Jay Z, and I love Beyonce. I'm not 100% convinced she actually carried that baby herself, but whatever.

  • I think that a lot of the "evidence" cited in the article is weak.  Most photoshoots are done far in advance, so using those pictures to show the progress of "the bump" is questionable.

    Plus, the size of a baby bump has a lot to do with a woman's physiology.  I have pictures of my mother while she was pregnant with me and you can't tell she was carrying until the last few months.  Some women just carry more internally and some "pop out" immediately. 

  • imageMotzie:
    imageTarponMonoxide:

    What if there was an indicent on the floor??? They won't know any details -- Anything could have happened up there, thanks to them.

    Lennox Hill Hospital was always for the well heeled and upper crust. In this case, thse 2 sure had a lot of crust.:(

    And to be fair, not every woman shows a lot -- some hardly show signs of carrying a baby and therea re still some women who don't announce a pregnancy until pretty late in their gestation. Not everybody says they're pregnant as soon as the pee hits the stick.:)

    I believe they rented the entire floor, so no one else was giving birth up there.

    I love Jay Z, and I love Beyonce. I'm not 100% convinced she actually carried that baby herself, but whatever.



    There was a gent who complained he wasn't permitted near the nursery...because it was security for them. Man.:(

    There are still other patients. They could have kept that infant in her room with her  --- that's the way it used to be done back in the day --- and there are many hospitals that allow rooming-in.

    All she needed was a crew of private nurses. what's the big deal here?
  • imageDaringMiss:

    I think that a lot of the "evidence" cited in the article is weak.  Most photoshoots are done far in advance, so using those pictures to show the progress of "the bump" is questionable.

    Plus, the size of a baby bump has a lot to do with a woman's physiology.  I have pictures of my mother while she was pregnant with me and you can't tell she was carrying until the last few months.  Some women just carry more internally and some "pop out" immediately. 

    And also, saying "oh she did ALL that while she was pregnant?"  Yes. That is what homegirl does. She might have taken it easy for 9 months and still did ALL that.

  • imageTarponMonoxide:


    There was a gent who complained he wasn't permitted near the nursery...because it was security for them. Man.:(
    I'm pretty sure that dude was debunked as a lying liar who wanted hush money and or residual fame.  And I'll add that there were plenty of times we weren't 'allowed' in the NICU... shift changes & rounds namely.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageMotzie:

    And also, saying "oh she did ALL that while she was pregnant?"  Yes. That is what homegirl does. She might have taken it easy for 9 months and still did ALL that.

    On this, totally with you.  That part of the "evidence" had me rolling my eyes.  MANY PG women actually continue to be VERY active during pregnancy.  Unlike what you read on The Bump, not every woman thinks she's a fragile egg who has to be pampered for 9 months... ;)

    I have a friend who at 8 months PG.... you could BARELY tell.  She looked 3 or 4 months at best.  She carried "in". 

    But the caving belly... that one is hard for me to look past.

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I have an easier time believing that she was pregnant, She certainly has pp boobs.

    But, I am open to the idea that she delivered at a different time/place than reported.  You know, so she could drop some weight 'fast' or whatever. 

    I absolutely believe Kelly Preston faked her pregnancy. 

  • I have a cousin we did not know she was pregnant until a few days before she gave birth, she was already super small and we could not tell she did not have the bump or anything. Her Mom who is a large woman was pregnant with her last son, we could not tell she was pregnant at all.

     

    The other argument she still wearing heels, Jessica Simpson still wears hers, Tia Mowry wore hers, and my God-Sister wore hers until the day she gave birth. My God-Sister argued that she was more comfortable with high heels then flats.

     

    I agree we will never know the truth and who cars. When I saw the post baby pic all I could think is I hope pray I loose my baby bump as fast. Oh yeah a lot of women work, exercise, and continue to live until the day they give birth.

  • imageEastCoastBride:
    imageMotzie:

    And also, saying "oh she did ALL that while she was pregnant?"  Yes. That is what homegirl does. She might have taken it easy for 9 months and still did ALL that.

    On this, totally with you.  That part of the "evidence" had me rolling my eyes.  MANY PG women actually continue to be VERY active during pregnancy.  Unlike what you read on The Bump, not every woman thinks she's a fragile egg who has to be pampered for 9 months... ;)

    I have a friend who at 8 months PG.... you could BARELY tell.  She looked 3 or 4 months at best.  She carried "in". 

    But the caving belly... that one is hard for me to look past.

    I'm pretty much in line with you, ECB, on the subject. The caving belly is weird. The other evidence in that article .... meh.

  • Put my vote in the "not pg" column.

    Look with your special eyes.
  • There was a photo shoot of Beyonce, in a bikini, when she was around 5  months. If she'd been a 'normal' person, you almost really wouldn't think she was pregnant, but for Beyonce, she was definitley showing. Bare tummy, mind you.
  • I thought the postpartum picture looked real.  She was looking a little thick (by Hollywood standards of course) in the side view.

    My aunt never really showed when she got pregnant and she was pretty thin.  Near the end she popped out, but not until almost 8 months along.  I had a noticeable bump by 4 months and I am not thin.

    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers
  • Lurker but look at her boobs.  There's no way to fake the milk filled boobs.  Mine were huge like that after my kids.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards