Travel
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Where did you stay in St. John?

I'm finding more vacation rentals than hotels. 

Re: Where did you stay in St. John?

  • There are only two resorts- Westin and Caneel Bay. Caneel is signficantly more expensive, but also more luxurious and intimate. There are other smaller hotels, but if you want a resort, they are your two choices. Also, not sure when you were looking to go, but Caneel closes down once a year for about a month during the fall. So that limits choices even more!

    That being said, I stayed at the Westin. I loved the idea of Caneel Bay, but at the end of the day, I'm a Starwood junkie! :)

    image
    Our wedding on Wilson Island!

  • We stayed at the Westin on our honeymoon. We got an oceanfront room and it was fabulous!
    imageLilypie Second Birthday tickers
    Our Little Piece of the Internet
    Heather & Michael ~ June 28, 2008
  • We stayed at Caneel bay and loved it!

    My friends stayed at the Westin and had great things to say about it as well.

    There are a lot of villas/condos to rent as well.

  • We did St. John on a budget after our bareboat charter in the BVI so we booked a private accomodation http://www.sailviewstjohn.com/ It was nice and for a short stay I would stay there again. Any particular reason you don't want to do a private villa? For a longer stay I much prefer villas to hotels so that would be my choice.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I have been to St. John three times (it's my favorite Caribbean island).  The first time we stayed in a villa and really enjoyed it.  One thing to think about though is that St. John is 2/3rds national park, so there are not very many villas that are on the beach.  But most villas have fantastic views.  Some are very luxurious, but you can also find more affordable ones.  We enjoyed the villa experience for the space and privacy.  And while our villa was directly on the water (a rocky beach), I missed being able to have direct sandy beach access.

    There are only two resorts on the island, Caneel Bay and the Westin.  I stayed at Caneel on my last trip there and that was my favorite.  The property is very spreadout, and there are seven different beaches to visit at the resort.  We loved having such easy access to the beaches there.  The rooms are very comfortable, but they are on the rustic side (don't expect the Four Seasons, even though it's expensive, you're paying for the amazing location.).  I have not stayed at the Westin.  It's on a manmade beach, so it would not be my first choice.

    We also stayed at a bed and breakfast, Estate Lindholm.  It's a 15 minute hike to two beautiful beaches.  The rooms were comfortable, there were nice views of the harbor, and the hosts were great.  

    One good thing about St. John is that there are many different gorgeous beaches to visit, so no matter where you stay, you should explore the island and different beaches.

  • We loved Caneel Bay because there are many options for beaches...all gorgeous.  To wake up and drink coffee on your porch, steps from the beach, while donkeys and deer come right up to you was so much fun.  The snorkeling was exceptional!  BUT...and it's a big BUT:  the rooms suck beyond belief.  You felt like you were at summer camp.  The bathroom was so small and old with one of those old louvered crank windows in the shower stall and tiles from circa 1982.  Teeny tiny room.  OH...and the closet was in the teeny tiny BATHROOM.  Worst resort room ever.  We actually thought about going back to ST. John this year, but I just couldn't deal with that room again. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards