Trouble in Paradise
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Kuus--to answer your question

I was at the doctor's office yesterday and was scrolling through posts on FB to keep me entertained.   I saw your question for your FB friends.    I have a strict policy to never discuss political or controversial issues on FB (and I also try to steer clear of potty training and religion discussion on there also).

Anyhoo, here are my opinions on pre-natal testing and abortion. 

Personally, I'm against it (aborting based on results of pre-natal testing).  Shocking right, since I'm pro-life anyway.   However, I've never been in a situation where I'd have to do the heavy lifting of actually making that decision.   I think there are very few circumstances where I'd consider it though.    I understand the lady's viewpoint in the article you referenced (her son has a fatal disease that is slowly killing him).   I'm honestly not sure how I'd feel in that situation.  Maybe I'd feel different, but from my cushy seat on the sidelines, I think I'd choose not to abort.    The reason for that is that I feel there is value in every human life.   Most of that perspective comes from a religious standpoint in that I believe there is a deeper purpose and meaning for every life, and maybe in a tragic situation like that, there are deeper powers at work, even if I can't see it and understand it. 

From a less religious perspective, I'd worry there'd be a slippery slope tendency re: prenatal results.   What would become the definition of disabled?   Would then children who have down syndrome, or some other non-fatal disorder or non-painful disorder, be terminated?    I can see someone terminating a pregnancy to avoid having a child suffer and die, but with something like DS, you'd be projecting your own views of quality of life onto another person.   If that makes sense.

So there you go.   A deep thought from someone who put her shirt on backwards this morning.

 

Re: Kuus--to answer your question

  • I saw the question too because HS replied to it. It made me want to be FB friends with Kuus, but I don't think I'm cool enough.
    image "Evolutionary game theorists...ignoring beebees on the nest since 2005"
  • Speaking of FB, now and then I think I see you (Donny) pop up on my list of people I should friend on FB.  I'm only friends with one former TIPper, so she must be friends with you.
    PitaPata Dog tickers
  • ESD, if I'm cool enough to be friends with Kuus you totally are. I'm kind of a loser.

    As far as the question goes, for our decision-making process we were firmly in the 'abort' category for incompatible with life stuff, like trisomy 18, but for spina bifida or DS, we would've kept it.

    I do think that if you feel like you can't handle caring for a DS kid, it's kinder to abort than to put it in the care of the state or take care of it yourself, which is probably super flammable.  I also kind of wonder why you'd have a kid in the first place.

    (this is the hypothetical 'you', not Donny 'you').

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageESDReturns:
    I saw the question too because HS replied to it. It made me want to be FB friends with Kuus, but I don't think I'm cool enough.

     

    I'll accept if you send me a friend request.  Just so you know.

    image
  • imageMortomo:
    Speaking of FB, now and then I think I see you (Donny) pop up on my list of people I should friend on FB.  I'm only friends with one former TIPper, so she must be friends with you.

    If you friend me, I'll accept.    I don't cross-contaminate FB and TIP.   And what I mean by that is I don't take stuff from TIP and post on FB.   (Motzie's pregnancy for example).   Although, I suppose I occasionally take stuff I see on FB over here (like updates on what others are up to). 

    I must warn  you though.  I post an excessive amount of photos of my children on FB.   It's mostly for the extended family living far away. 

  • imagedonnycornelius:
    I must warn  you though.  I post an excessive amount of photos of my children on FB.   It's mostly for the extended family living far away. 
    You so do not.  But then, maybe that's because I post way more than you for the same reason, and I don't feel like I'm super excessive with it.  So maybe it's denial, lol.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageReturnOfKuus:

    imageESDReturns:
    I saw the question too because HS replied to it. It made me want to be FB friends with Kuus, but I don't think I'm cool enough.

     

    I'll accept if you send me a friend request.  Just so you know.

    You totally have a friend request.

    image "Evolutionary game theorists...ignoring beebees on the nest since 2005"
  • imagebroccolitree:

    imagedonnycornelius:
    I must warn  you though.  I post an excessive amount of photos of my children on FB.   It's mostly for the extended family living far away. 
    You so do not.  But then, maybe that's because I post way more than you for the same reason, and I don't feel like I'm super excessive with it.  So maybe it's denial, lol.

    Ha ha ha!  It must be relative.   I do try to limit the photos (like, I won't post all 5 adorable pictures of the boys in the same pose...I'll try to pick the best of the bunch and post it).

     

  • Hmm.  It would seem that there's a pretty clear line in most people's heads as far as projecting your own quality of life ideas onto someone else, then.  I haven't seen anyone argue that things like DS are abort-worthy yet, while everyone seems to agree that no matter the final decision, short life in excruciating pain is a tough call and has more to do with mercy than playing free with someone else's life.
    image
  • imageESDReturns:
    imageReturnOfKuus:

    imageESDReturns:
    I saw the question too because HS replied to it. It made me want to be FB friends with Kuus, but I don't think I'm cool enough.

     

    I'll accept if you send me a friend request.  Just so you know.

    You totally have a friend request.

     

    Are you sure?  Because I checked, and it doesn't look like I do.

    edit:  nm, it just showed up.

    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards