Health & Fitness
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Anyone read the newest issue of Shape?

I got my issue last night and I am still pissed off at the "success story" of Holly Madison.

2 reasons: 1) At 5'5 being 111 pounds is under her ideal body weight. While I understand that some people have smaller frames than others, Shape has always used the real women for their success stories. How many average women can achieve this weight? 2) They mentioned in the article about 3 times how she lost it using NV!!! Seriously?! You are a health magazine and you promote someone losing weight with fatburners!

Ugh. So disgusted. Glad the subscription was free or I would ask for my money back.

2011 Races
3/12 5 mi -- 49:22 Pace: 9:52
5/1 Half Marathon -- 2:11:22 Pace: 10:01
5/22 10k -- 56:29 Pace: 9:00
5/24 3.6 -- 29:03 Pace: 8:18
7/10 15k -- 1:44:46 injured Pace: 11:14
10/29 5k -- 28:24 Pace: 9:04

Re: Anyone read the newest issue of Shape?

  • Yeah, women's health magazines are really disappointing lately. No
  • I got a subscription to Shape as a gift and it goes straight in the trash because they do this kind of crap every month.
    image
    two years!
    after two losses, now happily expecting baby #1 09.16.12
    Pregnancy Ticker
    Brie Fit Blog | BFP Chart
  • Omg.  I'm an inch taller than her and 24 pounds heavier.  I don't care if you're built small, that's not a good weight.  Do you think she can lift things?

    I have a free subscription to Women's Health and it's the same kind of thing.  Some of it is interesting, but all with a grain of salt.  Unfortunately, the "health" magazines are just as bad about promoting unhealthy diets and medications as the other magazines.

    Sometimes I think I'd be better off reading Men's Health.

  • God.  I'm 5'6" and look like a skeleton below 140 lbs - 150-155 lbs is realistic for me.  She is ridiculous.
    imageFollow Me on Pinterest
  • And just think of how much of that weight is in her boobs!

    I usually like Shape, but I was very disappointed at the Holly praise in this past issue.  I bet a lot of their readers are.  I know they switched editors within the last year (maybe a little longer?) and it seems like a lot more fluff now.

  • I saw that too, and I was annoyed.  For a magazine that talks about eating healthy and working out to shed pounds, they sure do look hypocritical right now.
    Always be yourself. Unless you suck.
  • imageaeroluv327:

    And just think of how much of that weight is in her boobs!

    I usually like Shape, but I was very disappointed at the Holly praise in this past issue.  I bet a lot of their readers are.  I know they switched editors within the last year (maybe a little longer?) and it seems like a lot more fluff now.

    Yeah, I don't like the change in editors. I actually wrote into the mag this morning to express my displeasure.

    2011 Races
    3/12 5 mi -- 49:22 Pace: 9:52
    5/1 Half Marathon -- 2:11:22 Pace: 10:01
    5/22 10k -- 56:29 Pace: 9:00
    5/24 3.6 -- 29:03 Pace: 8:18
    7/10 15k -- 1:44:46 injured Pace: 11:14
    10/29 5k -- 28:24 Pace: 9:04
  • imagefeinicstine:

    Sometimes I think I'd be better off reading Men's Health.

     I totally read my husband's Men's Health :)

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I am old enough to remember when Shape was a decent magazine that promoted semi-healthy lifestyles.  I picked up a copy a couple years ago and was appalled.  I distinctly remember telling a friend of mine that it had turned into an exercise version of Cosmo.
  • I stopped subscribing to Shape last year because of this.

    Health magazine is the same way. A few months ago they promoted a women who lost 50+ lbs on the cookie diet. Tongue Tied. Luckily that subscription ends in September.

    Right now I have Runner's World and I really like that.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I saw that, too, and thought "how could they print this." Esp. the part about using NV to lose the weight.  I've been really disappointed with the magazine and won't be renewing it when it comes due.
  • I read it last night and was seriously disgusted. Once my subscription runs out, I will not be renewing.
    ?"All I want is what I have coming to me. All I want is my fair share."
    Visit The Nest! image
    Anniversary
    GP buddy to blenderdance
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • I don't have a problem with her weight at all -- she's barely 10 lbs below her healthy weight range and there are PLENTY of people who look fine and are healthy at 10 lbs above their healthy weight range, so it goes both ways.

    However, the fact that they are touting a diet pill as her vehicle for success is both alarming and disappointing. How many people will read that and think it will work for them too? Sad and shameful.

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    DD #1 born 9/07 ** DD #2 born 7/11 ** Operation Take Back My Body has begun 10/11
    Upcoming Races
    Gobble Wobble 5K 11/24/11 - Abington, PA 29:40
    Superbowl 10K 02/05/12 - Allentown, PA 54:28 PR!!!!
    Broad Street 10 Mile Run 05/06/12 - Philadelphia, PA 1:30:44
    Rock and Roll Half Marathon 09/16/12 - Philadelphia, PA
    Philadelphia (Half?!?) Marathon 11/18/12 - Philadelphia, PA
  • imageGummybear:

    I don't have a problem with her weight at all -- she's barely 10 lbs below her healthy weight range and there are PLENTY of people who look fine and are healthy at 10 lbs above their healthy weight range, so it goes both ways.

    However, the fact that they are touting a diet pill as her vehicle for success is both alarming and disappointing. How many people will read that and think it will work for them too? Sad and shameful.

    The bolded is what really bothered me as well. As someone who looks/feels good just above my "normal bmi," I'm generally not bothered by being a bit under/over. And while she was never fat, I also appreciate showing someone get from a tad on the heavy side for them, to looking fabulous. But the diet pill hype was appalling. 

  • Agreed. I was truely disgusted by the diet pills. They are mostly fluff, but I have never seen them promote diet pills before. I wonder how much $$ Holly and NV are making off of this.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageGummybear:

    I don't have a problem with her weight at all -- she's barely 10 lbs below her healthy weight range and there are PLENTY of people who look fine and are healthy at 10 lbs above their healthy weight range, so it goes both ways.

    However, the fact that they are touting a diet pill as her vehicle for success is both alarming and disappointing. How many people will read that and think it will work for them too? Sad and shameful.

    I guess I would feel better about the weight if she did it in a healthy way. But that just gives the feeling of "Look, use fatburners and you can be uber skinny and a playboy model too!!!".

    I wonder how many complaints Shape is getting today.....

    2011 Races
    3/12 5 mi -- 49:22 Pace: 9:52
    5/1 Half Marathon -- 2:11:22 Pace: 10:01
    5/22 10k -- 56:29 Pace: 9:00
    5/24 3.6 -- 29:03 Pace: 8:18
    7/10 15k -- 1:44:46 injured Pace: 11:14
    10/29 5k -- 28:24 Pace: 9:04
  • imagelauren060306:
    Agreed. I was truely disgusted by the diet pills. They are mostly fluff, but I have never seen them promote diet pills before. I wonder how much $$ Holly and NV are making off of this.

    I've never seen them promote pills before either, it was really disappointing to see that piece in there.

  • While I was reading it I thought it must be one of those pages that's really an ad but is made to look like an article... KWIM? Really irritating.

  • I am getting mad about this all over again. Does anyone have a link where I can send them a message? I will give them a piece of my mind, lol. I seriously hope the editor gets fired over this.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagelauren060306:
    I am getting mad about this all over again. Does anyone have a link where I can send them a message? I will give them a piece of my mind, lol. I seriously hope the editor gets fired over this.

    This is the avenue that I used.

    http://www.shape.com/contact

    Not sure if it is the best way to contact them. If anyone has suggestions for another way, let me know because I will resend my message to them.

    2011 Races
    3/12 5 mi -- 49:22 Pace: 9:52
    5/1 Half Marathon -- 2:11:22 Pace: 10:01
    5/22 10k -- 56:29 Pace: 9:00
    5/24 3.6 -- 29:03 Pace: 8:18
    7/10 15k -- 1:44:46 injured Pace: 11:14
    10/29 5k -- 28:24 Pace: 9:04
  • imagepdxjenn:

    While I was reading it I thought it must be one of those pages that's really an ad but is made to look like an article... KWIM? Really irritating.

    That was my first thought, too. Sadly, I was wrong.

    ?"All I want is what I have coming to me. All I want is my fair share."
    Visit The Nest! image
    Anniversary
    GP buddy to blenderdance
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • Shoot.  Mine came in the mail last week and I've been saving it for a long bike ride (stationary, of course!) tonight.  Now I'm already disappointed...  :(
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers BabyFruit Ticker
  • I was really annoyed by this too. And it really is a widespread problem. I love reading Oxygen, but it's hard to ignore the fact that the millions of diet pill ads in there seriously conflicts with the clean lifestyle they advocate.
    Baby E: July 3, 2009 Baby M: February 22, 2012
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards