Starting Over
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

NSOR: Would you rather...(wedding related)

Would you rather go to a reception that was casual, come-as-you-are-go-as-you-please, with good food, drinks, music, yard games, bonfire, etc.
 
Or would you rather go to a normal wedding reception, with the big white tent, linens, white wooden chairs, centerpieces, china place settings, structured timeline, etc. Still with good food, drinks, music, etc.
 
The ceremony would be family only, and either take place earlier in the day, or even the day before. Both receptions would be adult only and the bride and groom would NOT expect gifts...just in case those might be factors in your decision.
image
Pregnancy Ticker

Re: NSOR: Would you rather...(wedding related)

  • As you aren't inviting these people to the wedding and you don't expect gifts, I'd make it as non-wedding like as possible.  I'd make it more of a party than a reception (meaning your first option).
    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I like the open house idea #1
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I like option #1.  But I'm not big into "wedding" stuff anyway

  • imageEastCoastBride:
    As you aren't inviting these people to the wedding and you don't expect gifts, I'd make it as non-wedding like as possible.  I'd make it more of a party than a reception (meaning your first option).

    This makes sense. I also think anything with a backyard, bonfire, sounds like a great time.    

  • I'd be quite happy at either, but agree with ECB that the first one seems to fit the vibe that you're going for better.
  • See, I've been to a not-first wedding that was like option 1, and while it was fun, I felt kind of awkward at the lack of structure. Maybe it was because it was my STBXH's family and I didn't know a ton of people, but in that situation, I would have preferred a more traditional set-up. 

    That said, if you're having a family-only ceremony the day before, I think it makes more sense to have an open-house style reception.  

  • I'd prefer the second option.. .but I think it is weird to invite people to a reception but not the wedding.
  • imageElleWrites:

    See, I've been to a not-first wedding that was like option 1, and while it was fun, I felt kind of awkward at the lack of structure. Maybe it was because it was my STBXH's family and I didn't know a ton of people, but in that situation, I would have preferred a more traditional set-up. 

    That said, if you're having a family-only ceremony the day before, I think it makes more sense to have an open-house style reception.  

    The lack of structure thing is exactly what I was worried about when FF said he wanted a more casual affair. However, now that we want a family-only ceremony, I think we could get away with having it completely separate from the reception. Maybe the day before and take all of our ceremony guests (aka immediate family) out to a sit-down dinner. Then we could have the causal and informal party the following day for 150 of our closest friends and family Smile
     
    *sigh* I don't know what to do. A lot of this stems from the fact my student loans will be in repayment in 6 months and will kill our budget. Hopefully my house will have sold by then, because the monthly payments are identical. I just have a hard time not feeling guilty for spending a ton of money on a formal reception when we could be putting it towards our nest egg, paying down debt, etc. We want to try to start a family within a year of getting married, so that comes into play for our budget as well. Damn guilt is getting the better of me!
     
    I'm going to talk to FF tonight but I'm pretty sure I know what he'll say. He'll vote for the fun party Smile
    image
    Pregnancy Ticker
  • imagePrettyInPearls23:
    imageElleWrites:

    See, I've been to a not-first wedding that was like option 1, and while it was fun, I felt kind of awkward at the lack of structure. Maybe it was because it was my STBXH's family and I didn't know a ton of people, but in that situation, I would have preferred a more traditional set-up. 

    That said, if you're having a family-only ceremony the day before, I think it makes more sense to have an open-house style reception.  

    The lack of structure thing is exactly what I was worried about when FF said he wanted a more casual affair. However, now that we want a family-only ceremony, I think we could get away with having it completely separate from the reception. Maybe the day before and take all of our ceremony guests (aka immediate family) out to a sit-down dinner. Then we could have the causal and informal party the following day for 150 of our closest friends and family Smile
     
    *sigh* I don't know what to do. A lot of this stems from the fact my student loans will be in repayment in 6 months and will kill our budget. Hopefully my house will have sold by then, because the monthly payments are identical. I just have a hard time not feeling guilty for spending a ton of money on a formal reception when we could be putting it towards our nest egg, paying down debt, etc. We want to try to start a family within a year of getting married, so that comes into play for our budget as well. Damn guilt is getting the better of me!
     
    I'm going to talk to FF tonight but I'm pretty sure I know what he'll say. He'll vote for the fun party Smile

    If someone I loved were to forgo the whole reception because they wanted to be responsible with money (save for a house, kids, whatever) I would totally support that.  The party doesn't make you any more (or less) married, you know?

  • If this was an "immediately following the ceremony" type reception where all of the people at the wedding would also be going to the reception, I'd pick option B, I'm a traditionalist like that. But based on the fact that it's more like a party to celebrate the marriage and not a recpeption, I'd go with option A.
    Ridley Run 3.1 - 4/9/11 - 34:24 - 1st race evah!
    Kelly Monaghan's 5K - 5/15/11 - 3rd Place in AG
    Walk the Talk 5K - 5/18/11 - 31:12 PR
    Ridley Run 3.1 - 4/14/12 - 1st race of the year, 32:45
  • imageDorisWE:
    imagePrettyInPearls23:
    imageElleWrites:

    See, I've been to a not-first wedding that was like option 1, and while it was fun, I felt kind of awkward at the lack of structure. Maybe it was because it was my STBXH's family and I didn't know a ton of people, but in that situation, I would have preferred a more traditional set-up. 

    That said, if you're having a family-only ceremony the day before, I think it makes more sense to have an open-house style reception.  

    The lack of structure thing is exactly what I was worried about when FF said he wanted a more casual affair. However, now that we want a family-only ceremony, I think we could get away with having it completely separate from the reception. Maybe the day before and take all of our ceremony guests (aka immediate family) out to a sit-down dinner. Then we could have the causal and informal party the following day for 150 of our closest friends and family Smile
     
    *sigh* I don't know what to do. A lot of this stems from the fact my student loans will be in repayment in 6 months and will kill our budget. Hopefully my house will have sold by then, because the monthly payments are identical. I just have a hard time not feeling guilty for spending a ton of money on a formal reception when we could be putting it towards our nest egg, paying down debt, etc. We want to try to start a family within a year of getting married, so that comes into play for our budget as well. Damn guilt is getting the better of me!
     
    I'm going to talk to FF tonight but I'm pretty sure I know what he'll say. He'll vote for the fun party Smile

    If someone I loved were to forgo the whole reception because they wanted to be responsible with money (save for a house, kids, whatever) I would totally support that.  The party doesn't make you any more (or less) married, you know?

    Agreed!

  • There's a lot of cost effective ways to have a reception that don't break the bank. What about having it at a local park? Having brunch? A lot of restaurants offer reduced rates for a brunch of afternoon reception or just going with a drinks/dessert type of reception?

    I hear you - spending the money is a killer, especially when debt repayment is number one priority. We are somehow making it work with a 7k budget. Somethings (food) are expensive, while we have gotten a break on other things (ceremony place, officiant).

  • I like the fancypants weddings.  Now that I think about it, the food is usually better at those.  Maybe I wouldn't mind the casual one if the food were truly good (no cold cuts!), especially if it's okay to come in sweatpants.
    image
  • imageReturnOfKuus:
    I like the fancypants weddings.  Now that I think about it, the food is usually better at those.  Maybe I wouldn't mind the casual one if the food were truly good (no cold cuts!), especially if it's okay to come in sweatpants.

    I refuse to cut corners when it comes to food! IMO, the food, drinks and company are what make (or break) the party!!

    image
    Pregnancy Ticker
  • If I were you, I'd pick option #1 simply because I have already done the big fancy wedding (don't know if you did for your first) and looking back it was all so showy and fancy and, quite frankly, wasteful. It was what our parents and families wanted and since the parents were paying for it, we did it.

    B and I have already talked about what we want for our wedding. Neither of us want a big to-do -- totally isn't his style, and I've been there done that. We live by the beach and if you have less than 100 people you don't need a permit to have a "gathering" on the sand. So we have a spot picked out where we will tell everyone to meet us. We will have a quick 15 minute vows ceremony and then walk up the street to our favorite restaurant to have dinner and drinks -- no garter, no flower toss, no formal dancing -- just music, good food and good wine. It is a nice restaurant and they do have a private dining room upstairs that we will use for our dinner. Some people may think it is weird we aren't having dancing, but we just don't want anything super formal like that. And the restaurant is where we had out first "fancy" dinner out, so it has meaning to us.

    I say it needs to reflect you and FF. Which ever option reflects you two better, that is what you should do. If people don't like it, they really don't have to go. When it comes down to it, both options sound fun in different ways, so it is a win-win!

  • I think I'd like a combination of the two. I do like certain aspects of traditional weddings, like dressing up. I sometimes think there are fewer and fewer opportunities to get all dolled up so I enjoy that part of weddings. I don't like the formal sit down with the structured timeline of a traditional reception. 

    So maybe, a little fancier casual reception? 

    someecards.com - North Carolina: Where you can marry your cousin. Just not your gay cousin.
  • Honestly if the budget is tight, a party (even done on the cheap) for 150 people is going to be pricey. I would say skip the big party. Have your family ceremony and then have something really nice, special and intimate after. Perhaps a lovely dinner at a restaurant.

  • I go with the casual route.  I like everything you've been pinning on Pinterest (the rustic look is soooo cute with so many fun ideas).  I think since it's a second wedding for both of you, casual is better.

    One of the best receptions I ever went to was an outdoor wedding at one of the bride and groom's friend's parent's wineries (which is also at their home).  It was a backyard reception, overlooking the winery and so beautiful.  They had margarita machines and a table set up for tequila shots.  They also had a dessert table instead of cake and they had sugar cookies shaped like their initials.  it was all very intimate and personal and the bride and groom had a great time.  I suggest something like that!

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I would say #2 but thats because I don't get to dress nicely and go out very often so I enjoy it when I do.
    "You cannot protect yourself from sadness without protecting yourself from happiness."
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards