Military Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

S/O HG Over-analysts - 31 differences between book and movie

http://ohnotheydidnt.livejournal.com/67650092.html#cutid1

I know you guys had mentioned some of them in the other thread, but apparently there's 31 total.

I just re-read the book this weekend since it's been over a year since I read it.  I'm supposed to go see it tomorrow and I am beyond excited! 

imageBabyFruit Ticker

Re: S/O HG Over-analysts - 31 differences between book and movie

  • I'm going to see the movie tomorrow so I'll be sure to check out that site afterwards!
    image
    Photo bomb, yeah!
  • I pretty much agree with the article. I really did like that they put in the parts (in the movie) of president snow and the gamemaker control room. Number 10 & 18 in the article.

     I also agree with 23 where they in the book district 11 sends Katniss bread after the scene with Rue and in the movie it doesn't exist. 

    All in all I can't wait until the other movies. 

    Formerly known as E&M
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
  • Sadly (or not?) I did note all those differences, but many of them didn't bother me as much because it is what it is when a book is turned into a movie. 
    imageMilitary Newlyweds FAQ Button
    I changed my name
  • imageJillyWtP:
    Sadly (or not?) I did note all those differences, but many of them didn't bother me as much because it is what it is when a book is turned into a movie. 

    This exactly. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageKiller Cupcake:

    Honestly, I don't care about 99% of those things. It didn't change the fact that the movie was good. 

    Everyone is picking the movie apart because it didn't do everything just like the book or left something out. If they kept it exactly the same and put everything in, the movie would have been 6 hours long. Not to mention, there are going to be (rumored) 3 other movies to detail a lot of this stuff.

    Also: 20 is wrong. Rue pointed out the tracker jacker nest AND suggested dropping it on those below.  

    I agree, just thought it was interesting. I haven't seen the movie yet but I don't think anything will affect it that much.  I know a lot of people were upset with The Help too but I thought that was really good anyways.

    I'm pretty sure Rue only pointed the hive out.  I just re-read the book yesterday so I was fresh going into the movie.  She points it out so that Katniss doesn't disturb it, but she never mentions dropping it on the careers.

    imageBabyFruit Ticker
  • imageKiller Cupcake:

    Honestly, I don't care about 99% of those things. It didn't change the fact that the movie was good. 

    Everyone is picking the movie apart because it didn't do everything just like the book or left something out. If they kept it exactly the same and put everything in, the movie would have been 6 hours long. Not to mention, there are going to be (rumored) 3 other movies to detail a lot of this stuff.

    Edit: read it wrong.

     I hadn't heard the rumor that there would be 3 more movies (4 total right?).  That makes me excited and I hope it is true.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Yeah I heard 4 movies too.  I'm kind of annoyed by it because we will have to wait even longer to see all of them and they are dragging it out like Harry Potter did.  But I'm also excited that there will be an extra movie to see.
    imageBabyFruit Ticker
  • imagednbeach12:

    I'm supposed to go see it tomorrow and I am beyond excited! 

    Did you find someone to see it with? 

    image

    image
    67/200
  • imageMaryboo247:
    imagednbeach12:

    I'm supposed to go see it tomorrow and I am beyond excited! 

    Did you find someone to see it with? 

    Yes!  Kara from MB who posts here sometimes too is gonna go with me.  I was fully prepared to go by myself though because I just want to see it! 

    imageBabyFruit Ticker
  • Man, this happens every time a popular book is made into a movie. I am with KC, although I haven't seen it yet, I really don't care what has changed that much. I know that the author helped write the screenplay, so I trust that the quality of the story wasn't compromised that much.  

    image
  • I really liked some of the alterations.  The pace a movie has to keep is very different than a book.  Plus, you don't have someone's thoughts as narrator, so I thought they were quite creative in showing Katniss' thoughts through things like Haymitch's notes and the gamemaker's control room.

    A few things bothered me, like the lack of strategy talk.  And I really think they missed some good Haymitch characterization opportunities (woody harrelson would have rocked the hell out of drunken stumbling on stage).  

    Overall, though, I have hope that some of the things they left out were to have more room to develop the other movies.  The 2nd and especially 3rd book got weaker, and the characters were flat and stale by then. 

    image
  • imageKiller Cupcake:

    imagednbeach12:
    Yeah I heard 4 movies too.  I'm kind of annoyed by it because we will have to wait even longer to see all of them and they are dragging it out like Harry Potter did.  But I'm also excited that there will be an extra movie to see.

    It'll take longer, but I think it will definitely benefit the story since the third book was so rushed.  

    I hope so.  I really hope they build more into their story after.  It was super intense and then just bam, she's at her house years later with the guy the chose.  That was probably my least favorite thing about the books.  After 3 books of buildup and being torn about Peeta and Gale she just end it all in like 3 pages.  I hope they elaborate in the movie. 

    imageBabyFruit Ticker
  • Someone correct me if I am wrong but didn't Peeta lose his leg in the book but not in the movie?
  • Yup. Katniss tied a tourniquet to stop some bleeding. The scene where the hover craft was taking them home- the blood kept flowing even though they were frozen in the beam, and she freaked out at the doctors trying to fix him. Plus her eardrum didn't appear to be damaged by the blast that took out cato's food supply. 
    imageMilitary Newlyweds FAQ Button
    I changed my name
  • I had read the books but well over 6 months+ ago. I'm so glad that I hadn't recently read them to compare against the movie. 

    I saw the movie a 2nd time on Sunday and I still enjoyed it as much as the first time. I can't wait to see how well they make movie #2.

     

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageblueshirt2003:

    I had read the books but well over 6 months+ ago. I'm so glad that I hadn't recently read them to compare against the movie. 


     

    I just said this on MB! I totally agree, I was far less picky. I only missed the Avox story line, but I'm sure they'll get into it later.  

    I've seen a lot of military surprise homecomings. It wouldn't work on me. I always have my back to the corner and my face to the door. Looking for terrorists, criminals, various other threats, and husbands.
  • I just saw it, and definitely wasn't bothered by most of the parts left out.  The only thing that I wish they would have kept in is District 11 sending Katniss the bread after Rue's death, since it showed that the other districts were starting to like her.  I feel like showing the rioting didn't give that effect at all.  

    Other than, I really liked how they did the movie, and really liked all the scenes of the game makers.  Even after reading the book twice it gave me a little more clarity of how and why the game makers did things, like the fire. 

    imageBabyFruit Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards