Politics & Current Events
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Hunger games/Rue/Racism/BunnyBean

Bunnybean, you brought this up in the post about Zimmerman below, but since I am like 3 years behind, I just read The Hunger Games last week (actually, I read all 3 books in less than 2 days b/c I had to know what happened).

Anyway, I read an article about Rue and the racist tweets right after I finished the first book, and I'd seen movie posters so I knew Rue in the movie was black before I picked up the book.  Actually, I take that back - I knew there was a black female character b/c I'd seen the movie posters, not her name.

So yeah, I read the book, and when I read the racist tweets article, I was like Indifferent because I thought it was BEYOND OBVIOUS in the book that Rue was black, that District 11 = South/slavery reference - like to the point that I almost thought it was bad writing and I was beaten over the head with the reference (if it hadn't been YA, I would have really been on the bad writing train).

Both the racism of those tweets and the straight up stupidity stunned me.  Did these people even read the book?  

And yeah, this post is kind of pointless, but since I read the book 3 years after everyone else, I wanted to talk about it now.  

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: Hunger games/Rue/Racism/BunnyBean

  • It could have been pretty obvious, but I skimmed through parts of the book and missed that she was black. I said in a previous post that I always pictured her as a redhead for some reason. I totally didn't catch the district 11=the south but now that people have quoted all of it I realize it was pretty obvious.

    I would never want to be tested on my knowledge of the details of HG because I was so anxious to get to the end I think I missed a lot.

  • *haven't read these books but* Maybe the kids didn't know because all the textbooks now say North Atlantic Triangle Trade.
    image "There's a very simple test to see if something is racist. Just go to a heavily populated black area, and do the thing that you think isn't racist, and see if you live through it." ~ Reeve on the Clearly Racist Re-Nig Bumper Sticker and its Creator.
  • People think Twilight is great literature. Nothing surprises me anymore.
    A big old middle finger to you, stupid Nest.
  • imagepixy_stix:
    People think Twilight is great literature.
    LOL!

    It's these kinds of stories that remind me what a bubble I live in. 

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • I agree with Toledo.

    Also, Suzanne Collins' writing style was very stream of consciousness, imo. Less than Handmaid's Tale, but still there. I felt like going from one line to the next could have changed the story line dramatically. I think that was one of my biggest gripes about things. Sometimes it seemed to happen so fast I couldn't keep up with what was going on. So, the fact that people glossed over that part doesn't surprise me.

    The fact that a person wouldn't have remorse because she's black does, and it's appalling. 



    Zuma Zoom
    image
  • imageSMorriso:

    I agree with Toledo.

    Also, Suzanne Collins' writing style was very stream of consciousness, imo. Less than Handmaid's Tale, but still there. I felt like going from one line to the next could have changed the story line dramatically. I think that was one of my biggest gripes about things. Sometimes it seemed to happen so fast I couldn't keep up with what was going on. So, the fact that people glossed over that part doesn't surprise me.

    The fact that a person wouldn't have remorse because she's black does, and it's appalling. 

    Good point.  And I can see skimming/reading fast to see what the hell happens.  I know I was tearing through the 3rd book at times to try and see what the end was going to be.  I read slower through the first book, though.  I think partially, though, that was a product of it being something that I really dislike (as far as genre - dystopian, I mean).  I was trying to make myself take it all in still.  But  by the end of the 1st book, I wanted to know what happened so I was more invested anyway.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagenitaw:
    *haven't read these books but* Maybe the kids didn't know because all the textbooks now say North Atlantic Triangle Trade.

    wait, what?! are you serious??

    image Ridin dirty
  • imageTianacheron:

    imagenitaw:
    *haven't read these books but* Maybe the kids didn't know because all the textbooks now say North Atlantic Triangle Trade.

    wait, what?! are you serious??

    Yeah, this.

    image
  • Given the state of education and literacy in this country I'm not shocked that teens wouldn't pick up on district 11 being the south though it seemed glaringly obvious to me. I'm also not surprised that reading comprehension is so poor as to miss the description of a character's appearance. 

    I am surprised that so many kids are apparently openly racist though.  

    "We tend to be patronizing about the poor in a very specific sense, which is that we tend to think,
  • FYI - I saw the movie this weekend. I sobbed when she volunteered, and I was a blubbering mess when Rue died and then when she saluted District 11.

    There was a younger kid in the theatre who I swear had a mental breakdown. The parents had to take him out. There was a bunch of whispered, "but you read the books, you knew this was going to happen!" as they walked out.

    A big old middle finger to you, stupid Nest.
  • imagepedantic_wench:
    imageTianacheron:

    imagenitaw:
    *haven't read these books but* Maybe the kids didn't know because all the textbooks now say North Atlantic Triangle Trade.

    wait, what?! are you serious??

    Yeah, this.

    Nope. Thank Texas.

     http://blog.sfgate.com/ybenjamin/2010/05/21/texas-approves-renaming-slave-trade-as-atlantic-triangular-trade/

    Edit - Slave is still in there, but yep, this is happened. 

    image "There's a very simple test to see if something is racist. Just go to a heavily populated black area, and do the thing that you think isn't racist, and see if you live through it." ~ Reeve on the Clearly Racist Re-Nig Bumper Sticker and its Creator.
  • imagenitaw:
    imagepedantic_wench:
    imageTianacheron:

    imagenitaw:
    *haven't read these books but* Maybe the kids didn't know because all the textbooks now say North Atlantic Triangle Trade.

    wait, what?! are you serious??

    Yeah, this.

    Nope. Thank Texas.

     http://blog.sfgate.com/ybenjamin/2010/05/21/texas-approves-renaming-slave-trade-as-atlantic-triangular-trade/

    Farking Texas.

    A big old middle finger to you, stupid Nest.
  • I read all three books this weekend (started Saturday and couldn't stop).

    I agree about the racist tweets, either people have very poor reading composition or they didn't read the books thoroughly. It could be a combination of both.

    ETA: Fwcking Texas. That op-ed made me want to tear my eyes our due to the typos / grammar errors. Still the message is clear. We need to give Texas back to Mexico.

    Slainte!
    my read shelf:
    Jenni (jenniloveselvis)'s book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards