Politics & Current Events
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Ruling blocks Ohio facility from liquefying bodies

CLICKY

COLUMBUS, Ohio (AP) ? An Ohio funeral home that was blocked from dissolving bodies using lye and heat has joined a funeral directors' group in pushing for the state to legalize the process.

Under a bill in the Ohio House, the state would recognize alkaline hydrolysis as a separate legal, regulated form of disposition, rather than lumping it in with traditional cremation, as some states have done. The bill was introduced in March after a judge's ruling blocked Edwards Funeral Service in Columbus from using the process, which involves the corrosive chemical lye, heat and sometimes extra pressure in a large metal cylinder. The method turn remains into a liquid that could be poured down a drain and a dry bone residue that can be given to relatives or buried.

Edwards was the first U.S. funeral business known to publicly offer alkaline hydrolysis and used the method in 19 cases before the state Board of Embalmers and Funeral Directors and the Ohio Department of Health stepped in with permit restrictions. They didn't believe the method was legal under state law.

Edwards filed a lawsuit asking the court to block enforcement of the restrictions, alleging the groups didn't have the authority to keep the funeral home from using the procedure. A Franklin County judge disagreed, saying in March that the board and the department have the authority to determine which disposition methods are allowed but that officials might want to consider whether to change existing rules to allow for the use of alkaline hydrolysis.

Funeral home owner Jeff Edwards said he doesn't plan to appeal the decision but instead will join efforts to get the new bill approved.

"I guess it's easier to work together," he said.

Proponents say alkaline hydrolysis has lower operating costs and is more environmentally friendly than traditional cremation because it doesn't cause the emissions that incineration does, such as carbon dioxide and mercury from dental fillings. But skeptics question whether it's safe for the environment and public health, along with the social implications of disposing of someone's remains down a drain.

The Ohio Department of Health hasn't taken a position on the bill and is still in the early stages of discussing alkaline hydrolysis, spokeswoman Tessie Pollock said. The head of the embalmers board did not respond to a message seeking comment.

The bill's sponsor, Republican Rep. Bob Hackett of London, said it's clear that the Ohio Funeral Directors Association wanted to make sure the method would be properly used and regulated if it's included in state law. He said the information he's reviewed indicates the method is safe but that lawmakers would welcome environmental concerns or other testimony from opponents when a committee of lawmakers considers the bill.

Jeff Edwards is also optimistic about the measure becoming law and said he's looking forward to offering alkaline hydrolysis again. While his legal case played out, more than a dozen people pre-planning arrangements with his funeral home selected the method, even though it wasn't currently available, Edwards said.

"It's kind of silly for Ohio to keep bucking a solution that is consumer-preferred and good for the environment as compared to a fire-based cremation," he said.

Half a dozen states in recent years have opened the door for the use of alkaline hydrolysis, in some cases by changing how they define cremation and removing references to flame or direct heat. The Anderson-McQueen Funeral Home in St. Petersburg, Fla., has started offering the method, and the Maine Coast Crematory in Searsport, Maine, got its alkaline hydrolysis machine last month.

The Mayo Clinic in Minnesota and the University of Florida have used the process, also known as resomation, for human cadavers. It's been used for two decades on animal carcasses.

A big old middle finger to you, stupid Nest.

Re: Ruling blocks Ohio facility from liquefying bodies

  • I want to know more about the liquid and exactly what drains it will be dumped into.  You aren't even supposed to pour medicines down the drain, so I have a hard time thinking liquid people are safe.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Fifth Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • Ima make a fortune

    Amadeus Water Jug Gold Rim 

    image
  • image+adamwife+:
    I want to know more about the liquid and exactly what drains it will be dumped into.  You aren't even supposed to pour medicines down the drain, so I have a hard time thinking liquid people are safe.

    image 

  • image+adamwife+:
    I want to know more about the liquid and exactly what drains it will be dumped into.  You aren't even supposed to pour medicines down the drain, so I have a hard time thinking liquid people are safe.

    My understanding is that it basically reduces everything down to base components, which means "liquid people" are a lot more safe than the (literal) crap that sewer systems are designed for.

    I'm actually happy to see alternatives being pursued here that are more environmentally friendly than cremation or embalming/burial.


    image
  • imagemysticporter:

    I'm actually happy to see alternatives being pursued here that are more environmentally friendly than cremation or embalming/burial.

    I am too. Although my first thought after reading the article was, "they're pouring PEOPLE down the drain?!"

    A big old middle finger to you, stupid Nest.
  • image+adamwife+:
      You aren't even supposed to pour medicines down the drain, so I have a hard time thinking liquid people are safe.

    If I could change my siggy I would put this quote there because it just made me snort. Smile

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • They talk about this process in detail in the book Stiff: The Curious Lives of Human Cadavers.  From what I remember the liquid that is created is supposed to be safe and environmentally friendly. FWIW I thought it was a really interesting book.



    I could hold you for a million years
    To make you feel my love.
  • image+adamwife+:
    I want to know more about the liquid and exactly what drains it will be dumped into.  You aren't even supposed to pour medicines down the drain, so I have a hard time thinking liquid people are safe.

    Lye is either KOH or NaOH, react it with a strong acid and you have table salt and water, which is perfectly fine to put down the drain.

  • imageKnitty:

    image+adamwife+:
    I want to know more about the liquid and exactly what drains it will be dumped into.  You aren't even supposed to pour medicines down the drain, so I have a hard time thinking liquid people are safe.

    Lye is either KOH or NaOH, react it with a strong acid and you have table salt and water, which is perfectly fine to put down the drain.

    It's just the thought of liquid people ending up in my drinking water.  I realize it's no different than flushing fecal matter or urine, but the thought still makes me Ick!

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Fifth Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards