Starting Over
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

s/o: posting outdated or misleading pics when online dating

Turtle's date post got me thinking: why do people do this?  J and I were talking about this last night and how this makes online dating so much more difficult.  He and I met on match and we both were only on there for a little longer than a month, but had similar experiences with dating.  People often post pics that look nothing like them, or are outdated. 

I just can't understand it and I think it makes things even more awkward than they already are when you actually do meet.  I remember texting for a little while with a guy who eventually texted me a current pic.  He looked NOTHING like his pics on match and had gained a considrable amount of weight.  It may have been shallow but it was one of the deciding factors that made me not want to meet him.  J said he'd had similar experiences with the few dates he'd been on. 

I'm not sure what the point of this post is but I figured I'd see what SO thought.

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: s/o: posting outdated or misleading pics when online dating

  • Some people probably do it just because they are not honest, but I bet there are a lot that still think in their head that they really look like that. 
  • Maybe because they want the ego boost that comes along with a lot of "interest" on the dating site?
    image
    Pregnancy Ticker
  • So I had a guy "review" my profile to see what changes I could make or whatever and he commented on my pictures.  Here's thing thing, my hair is naturally curly, and I have most pictures with my hair "normal" but occassionally I flat-iron it, and it looks totally different.  I think the same can be said for hair up, hair down, I look sort of different.  Anyway, he commented about how the pictures were obviously from different time periods and I looked "heavier" in certain pictures.  Thing is they are all from the last few months, so my weight is the same. 
  • I am actually super paranoid about this on my own profile! I purposely added some pictures where you can tell I've gained some weight, just so guys don't think I'm trying to make it seem like I"m skinnier than I am. A lot of my pictures are from snowboarding though so it's really hard to tell someone's size under all your gear haha. And I've got a variety of hair up/natural curl/ flat ironed/ curled with flat iron pics since I don't usually do the same thing all the time.
  • I actually posted older pics of myself at first. Last year when I posted on Match

    I went to my old "stand by"s before realizing the next day that I am about 15lbs heavier and my hair was toatlly different (length, bangs etc). I put them up out of habit, cause they were the best pics I had of myself...

    Though, like I said, the next day I took some new pics on my camera and dug up some nice ones my sister had taken at the last holiday.

    I can tell you this: 3 yrs ago I was on match for the first time and I got many more messages then I did last year. I know it some of it was because I was divorced and a single parent, but I know I lost a big chunk of interest because of my weight. I think some people are just insecure and want to be seen at their best, so they post pics of them at their best.

    Going from "athletic" to "about average" in the weight catagory eliminates a lot of people from the pool of interest.

     It is still not right to mislead people. I think a lot of the people though are just not honest with themselves.

     

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagebeccaga16:

    I actually posted older pics of myself at first. Last year when I posted on Match

    I went to my old "stand by"s before realizing the next day that I am about 15lbs heavier and my hair was toatlly different (length, bangs etc). I put them up out of habit, cause they were the best pics I had of myself...

    Though, like I said, the next day I took some new pics on my camera and dug up some nice ones my sister had taken at the last holiday.

    I can tell you this: 3 yrs ago I was on match for the first time and I got many more messages then I did last year. I know it some of it was because I was divorced and a single parent, but I know I lost a big chunk of interest because of my weight. I think some people are just insecure and want to be seen at their best, so they post pics of them at their best.

    Going from "athletic" to "about average" in the weight catagory eliminates a lot of people from the pool of interest.

     It is still not right to mislead people. I think a lot of the people though are just not honest with themselves.

     

    Can we talk about the weight categories please? I think there should be some standard guidelines for this...I see lots of guys putting "athletic" who are far from it, based on their pictures.  Or "about average" can go either way.  I always put "curvy" because I look like a woman (hips, big boobs and a butt) but wonder if that is limiting my options?

  • It took me awhile to accept myself for who I am and with the way I look.  Ironically, I was much thinner and in shape when I was more insecure.

    I think it just telling that the person has not yet free and comfortable in their own skin.  I don't necessarily think this is a red flag as I am sure all of us go on that journey at some point but definitely something to be cautious about.

    Like other posters responded to my earlier posts, I think it is important to be open minded while guarded and careful.

     

  • imageDorisWE:
    imagebeccaga16:

    I actually posted older pics of myself at first. Last year when I posted on Match

    I went to my old "stand by"s before realizing the next day that I am about 15lbs heavier and my hair was toatlly different (length, bangs etc). I put them up out of habit, cause they were the best pics I had of myself...

    Though, like I said, the next day I took some new pics on my camera and dug up some nice ones my sister had taken at the last holiday.

    I can tell you this: 3 yrs ago I was on match for the first time and I got many more messages then I did last year. I know it some of it was because I was divorced and a single parent, but I know I lost a big chunk of interest because of my weight. I think some people are just insecure and want to be seen at their best, so they post pics of them at their best.

    Going from "athletic" to "about average" in the weight catagory eliminates a lot of people from the pool of interest.

     It is still not right to mislead people. I think a lot of the people though are just not honest with themselves.

     

    Can we talk about the weight categories please? I think there should be some standard guidelines for this...I see lots of guys putting "athletic" who are far from it, based on their pictures.  Or "about average" can go either way.  I always put "curvy" because I look like a woman (hips, big boobs and a butt) but wonder if that is limiting my options?

    This made me think of this It's Not a Match Post:

    http://itsnotamatch.com/2012/02/09/what-body-types-on-dating-sites-really-mean/

     

    The Nestie formally known as....
  • imageRedRedWine2:
    imageDorisWE:
    imagebeccaga16:

    I actually posted older pics of myself at first. Last year when I posted on Match

    I went to my old "stand by"s before realizing the next day that I am about 15lbs heavier and my hair was toatlly different (length, bangs etc). I put them up out of habit, cause they were the best pics I had of myself...

    Though, like I said, the next day I took some new pics on my camera and dug up some nice ones my sister had taken at the last holiday.

    I can tell you this: 3 yrs ago I was on match for the first time and I got many more messages then I did last year. I know it some of it was because I was divorced and a single parent, but I know I lost a big chunk of interest because of my weight. I think some people are just insecure and want to be seen at their best, so they post pics of them at their best.

    Going from "athletic" to "about average" in the weight catagory eliminates a lot of people from the pool of interest.

     It is still not right to mislead people. I think a lot of the people though are just not honest with themselves.

     

    Can we talk about the weight categories please? I think there should be some standard guidelines for this...I see lots of guys putting "athletic" who are far from it, based on their pictures.  Or "about average" can go either way.  I always put "curvy" because I look like a woman (hips, big boobs and a butt) but wonder if that is limiting my options?

    This made me think of this It's Not a Match Post:

    http://itsnotamatch.com/2012/02/09/what-body-types-on-dating-sites-really-mean/

     

    LMFAO! Awesome...I love it!

  • I am a pretty average size, size 6/8, 127 pounds (and losing - woot!), but I've got an "Oakland booty" and have had 2 kids, so I have some extra tummy weight. I always feel weird meeting someone because their idea of "average" might be different than mine.

    Curvy annoys me, and here's why: I think when a man sees "curvy" he thinks Christina Hendricks or Kim Kardashian, but I know women who look more like Melissa McCarthy who consider themselves curvy rather than "a few extra pounds." Most of the categories are so subjective to how a person sees herself. A guy I went out with a few weeks ago said he hates those categories because they're misleading. I agree, but I'm certainly not going to post my measurements! LOL

    She's crafty - and she's just my type.
  • I have no idea why people do it.  You're only fooling someone until you meet, and then it's obvious.  I think it's like PP's have said, either (1) people are not being honest with themselves, or (2) people are trying to put their best image out there even though it's not accurate.

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageDorisWE:
    imagebeccaga16:

    I actually posted older pics of myself at first. Last year when I posted on Match

    I went to my old "stand by"s before realizing the next day that I am about 15lbs heavier and my hair was toatlly different (length, bangs etc). I put them up out of habit, cause they were the best pics I had of myself...

    Though, like I said, the next day I took some new pics on my camera and dug up some nice ones my sister had taken at the last holiday.

    I can tell you this: 3 yrs ago I was on match for the first time and I got many more messages then I did last year. I know it some of it was because I was divorced and a single parent, but I know I lost a big chunk of interest because of my weight. I think some people are just insecure and want to be seen at their best, so they post pics of them at their best.

    Going from "athletic" to "about average" in the weight catagory eliminates a lot of people from the pool of interest.

     It is still not right to mislead people. I think a lot of the people though are just not honest with themselves.

     

    Can we talk about the weight categories please? I think there should be some standard guidelines for this...I see lots of guys putting "athletic" who are far from it, based on their pictures.  Or "about average" can go either way.  I always put "curvy" because I look like a woman (hips, big boobs and a butt) but wonder if that is limiting my options?

    It is wierd I dated 2 guys last year and both said that I was not "about average" meaning I was not heavy enough to put that... but I didn't see myself as athletic at the time either!

    I felt better saying "about average" because I felt it was more accurate.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I always put that I am "average" size, but one of my guy friends who was on match told me that I might as well just put slender because a ton of girls who are twice my size will put average. It really doesn't mean much of anything.
  • I HATE when men post misleading pics!

    My all-time worst date from online (he NO JOKE asked me for a handjob, then asked if we could make out in my car, then asked if we could just have phone sex -- to make a long story short) showed up about 15 years older and 20 lbs heavier than his pics. WTF dude?

    I get confused too when there are a lot of pics where they look really different. WHICH one looks like you??

    Can we talk about the weight categories please? I think there should be some standard guidelines for this...I see lots of guys putting "athletic" who are far from it, based on their pictures.  Or "about average" can go either way.  I always put "curvy" because I look like a woman (hips, big boobs and a butt) but wonder if that is limiting my options?

    I'm so completely confused by the choices for women.

    I don't think I would be considered thin or skinny, though I'm petite and at a good weight, comfortable enough in a bikini.

    I've got boobs but I'm petite and have a slim/straightish build, so I'm definitely not curvy.

    I usually choose athletic, because I have muscular legs and I really don't know what else to choose, but I think of athletic as more fitting for someone like RiverPestie (don't know if you post pics on here RP lol).

    image
  • One other thing is that not a lot of people recent pics of themselves.  I know most of the pics I take are of my son.  I never think to ask someone... hey will you take a picture of me?  The pics I have on my profile are mostly from my last visit with my BFF where we purposely took single pics of each other just for this reason.
  • I'm curvy (hourglass figure) but with a few extra pounds and I can run a 10k tomorrow if someone asked me to. And I'm all of 5'2" and have to shop in the petite section most of the time.

    WTH am I supposed to put? I put "about average" but I really am like 10 categories combinded. I also put a variety of pictures from just face to full body, so they know I have curves, am short, and athletic...and even a race picture with (gasp!) no makeup (it's cute though!)

    No complaints so far... Stick out tongue

    The Nestie formally known as....
  • I think some people are trying to be misleading, some don't have many pics and are just choosing from what they have, and others don't think they've changed much. I just don't take pictures very often. I'm not dating yet but when I do I imagine I'll have a couple of recent pics and maybe 1-2 from a few years ago. I haven't changed much and I'll put the year they were taken as a caption. I'm the same height / weight, my hair is still pretty much the same, my face hasn't changed at all, and my clothing style has updated but hasn't changed drastically. Those photos are good and more full body so they give a good overview of what I really look like.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards