Buying A Home
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Second loan for PMI? (80/20?)

So I was talking to my dad, and he suggested that we look into a second loan to cover PMI.  From what I understand, PMI is only necessary if you have less than 20% equity in your home.  We technically have 20% to put down, but that would leave us with no e-fund, so we're going with an FHA loan.  According to my dad, PMI is necessary, but also a waste of money since it only benefits the lender.  This smacks of those risky no down payment loans, but my dad is in real estate (albeit commercial) so I tend to think he knows what he's talking about.  Has anyone done something similar?  Thoughts?  
image
Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.

Re: Second loan for PMI? (80/20?)

  • Just to clarify, per my dad, the only money we'd be "wasting" with this idea would be the interest on the second loan.  In theory (at least) the payment on our second would be only slightly more than the amount we'd pay in PMI anyway.
    image
    Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.
  • If you're comfortable putting 10% down, you may be able to do an 80/10 with the 10 at a higher rate if you have good credit but the days of 80/20 (which is no money down) is long gone.
  • I havent but we did go with a conventional loan with less than 20% down.  It has PMI for a minimum of 12 months but we can have the house reappraised after 12 months to drop PMI which is something like $80/month.  PMI on conventional loans are less than the FHA pmi. 

    I'm not sure they do 80/20 loan anymore which would mean take an 80% loan and then a 2nd loan for 20%.  Maybe you meant spmething like 80/10/10- 80% loan, 10% 2nd and 10% down?

     

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagelil_jen051708:

    I'm not sure they do 80/20 loan anymore which would mean take an 80% loan and then a 2nd loan for 20%.  Maybe you meant spmething like 80/10/10- 80% loan, 10% 2nd and 10% down?

     

    right. An 80/20 would mean we're putting nothing down at all.  We ran the numbers and 20% down would lower our projected payment about $250/mo, but it would wipe out our efund (5% for a conventional loan is like $40/mo, so not worth it at all.)  We'd rather have that cash cushion than the extra $ per month, KWIM?  Frankly, we're likely to fritter than $250 away on nothing rather than fold it back into our savings.  IDK, something to consider, I guess.  We'll talk to out realtor about it. 
    image
    Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.
  • You can always look into a conventional loan with no PMI.  We got a 5% down no pmi for the house we close on may 9.  Our mortgage broker found it for us and said multiple banks were offering it.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageangiem33:
    You can always look into a conventional loan with no PMI.  We got a 5% down no pmi for the house we close on may 9.  Our mortgage broker found it for us and said multiple banks were offering it.
    Really?  Did you buy a house that already had equity (below market value?). Am I wrong that PMI is only required when you have less than 20% equity?
    image
    Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.
  • No money down loans were part of why we got into this housing mess.

    I doubt you will find anyone giving 80/20 loans today.

     

  • imageSisugal:

    No money down loans were part of why we got into this housing mess.

    I doubt you will find anyone giving 80/20 loans today.

     

    Very helpful.  We have $ to put down.  
    image
    Anything you can achieve through hard work, you could also just buy.
  • We had an 80/20 loan in 2005, but I don't think they offer them anymore. 

    We had the 20% to put down on our current house (closed on a month ago), but like you we didn't want to use up all of our funds. We were able to get a conventional loan with 11% down with no pmi. 

     

  • I think you're talking about an 80/10? You put down 10% and take out a second mortgage for the other 10% so that you don't pay PMI.I don't think many people are doing those anymore.

    You really don't want to go with FHA if you don't have to the fees are much higher and you have to pay PMI for several years. With a conventional you can get out of the PMI once you have 22% equity, even if it's not too long after buying.

    You could get a no PMI loan, but your interest rate will be higher so it only makes sense if you're not planning on staying in the home long enough to get to 22%

  • imagelil_jen051708:

    I havent but we did go with a conventional loan with less than 20% down. It has PMI for a minimum of 12 months but we can have the house reappraised after 12 months to drop PMI which is something like $80/month. PMI on conventional loans are less than the FHA pmi.

    We did something similar.  We did a 30 year conventional loan with 15% down, no points, and the only difference is that the interest is just slightly higher than it would have been if we put 20% down.  The PMI can be dropped after so long (forget the time frame, dont have paperwork here). We're taking the rest of the cash back from our house sale and putting it into savings.

    imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageMrsAxilla:
    So I was talking to my dad, and he suggested that we look into a second loan to cover PMI.  From what I understand, PMI is only necessary if you have less than 20% equity in your home.  We technically have 20% to put down, but that would leave us with no e-fund, so we're going with an FHA loan.  According to my dad, PMI is necessary, but also a waste of money since it only benefits the lender.  This smacks of those risky no down payment loans, but my dad is in real estate (albeit commercial) so I tend to think he knows what he's talking about.  Has anyone done something similar?  Thoughts?  

    A second loan "to cover PMI"?  Are you sure you understand what all the terms mean?  You don't borrow money "to cover PMI."  PMI is insurance for the lender in case you default. 

    I also don't understand why you're "going with an FHA loan" and talking about 80/20's (or 80/10/10's).  

    FHA loans only require 3.5% down.  Obviously you can put down more than 3.5%, but most FHA loans I've come across require you to pay MIP (the FHA version of PMI) for a certain period of time regardless of equity.  Ours is 5 years.  So even if you only borrowed 80% of the value of the house with the FHA loan, you wouldn't avoid MIP (PMI).

    If you're going to take out a 2nd mortgage for, e.g., 10% of the value in an attempt to avoid PMI, you would need to have a conventional mortgage, not FHA, for the first mortgage.

    All this effort is not necessarily going to save you money in the end, though.  The interest rates are likely to be higher, particularly on the 2nd mortgage.  How much does it matter if you spend the money on interest or PMI?   

    Alternatively, you could save up a little longer to allow you to put 20% down without blowing your e-fund.

  • imageMrsAxilla:
    imageSisugal:

    No money down loans were part of why we got into this housing mess.

    I doubt you will find anyone giving 80/20 loans today.

     

    Very helpful.  We have $ to put down.  

    The title of your posts is asking about 80/20 loans.   An 80/.20 loan IS a no money down loan. All you would pay for is closing costs.

  • imageMrsAxilla:
    imageangiem33:
    You can always look into a conventional loan with no PMI.  We got a 5% down no pmi for the house we close on may 9.  Our mortgage broker found it for us and said multiple banks were offering it.
    Really?  Did you buy a house that already had equity (below market value?). Am I wrong that PMI is only required when you have less than 20% equity?

    Sorry for the delay in getting back to you! Yes really, 5% down no PMI, and no the house wasn't sold below market.  And you are right PMI is typically is on anything with less than 20% equity, but there are banks that will lend to very well qualified buyers without requiring a PMI policy.  

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageangiem33:

    imageMrsAxilla:
    imageangiem33:
    You can always look into a conventional loan with no PMI.  We got a 5% down no pmi for the house we close on may 9.  Our mortgage broker found it for us and said multiple banks were offering it.
    Really?  Did you buy a house that already had equity (below market value?). Am I wrong that PMI is only required when you have less than 20% equity?

    Sorry for the delay in getting back to you! Yes really, 5% down no PMI, and no the house wasn't sold below market.  And you are right PMI is typically is on anything with less than 20% equity, but there are banks that will lend to very well qualified buyers without requiring a PMI policy.  

    Typically this is lender paid PMI and results in a higher APR. In many cases, it's better to just pay the PMI as it's a short-term cost vs. committing to a higher rate over the life of the loan.

     

    image Lucy, 12/27/2009
    Pregnancy Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards