Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Moving in with MIL?!

My husband and I own a home in our hometown. He works a steady full time job, while I am finishing up school and preparing to build a business as a salon owner. His mother lives a few streets over from us, and lives alone bc her husband died when my husband was just a boy.

 Recently we have been discussing selling our home and living with his mother for a few years to save some money and pay off some of our outstanding debt with the money we get left over from selling our home. (student loans/credit cards)

 It sounds like a good idea, but I dont know if I could stand living with his mom and him. Since his dad did die young, he is a COMPLETE Mommas boy...which is great, except when she 'competes' with me to get his attention.

 I DONT KNOW WHAT TO DO!

I feel like we should go ahead and do it NOW, so that we can get it out of the way and be living in our own home again when we are ready for kids...

 

suggestions?

Re: Moving in with MIL?!

  • This is stupid.
    image
  • stupid is taking the time to reply to a post that you think is stupid.
  • You're stupid for even considering this.

     

    image
  • imageOurhouse124:
    stupid is taking the time to reply to a post that you think is stupid.

    But it is stupid.  

    Do you want opinions or just validation?

    image
    "That chick wins at Penises, for sure." -- Fenton
  • This is exactly the kind of plan I would expect from someone who would come up with a "so is your face" argument as an adult.

    I don't know what in any of this sounds like a good idea to you.  You don't want to live with her, he's a momma's boy, and you already have a place to live that isn't hers.  Mooching off of her and being miserable in order to pay off debt is just asinine.

    image
  • imageReturnOfKuus:
    This is stupid.

    Agreed.  You are adults.  Don't move back in with mommy.  I would rather have my sanity and some debt than live with my MIL.  You can find a better way to pay this off.  Also, there is A) no guarantee your house would sell and B) if it does sell, no guarantee that it would sell for more than your mortgage.

  • imageReturnOfKuus:

    This is exactly the kind of plan I would expect from someone who would come up with a "so is your face" argument as an adult.

    I don't know what in any of this sounds like a good idea to you.  You don't want to live with her, he's a momma's boy, and you already have a place to live that isn't hers.  Mooching off of her and being miserable in order to pay off debt is just asinine.

    My thoughts exactly.  If the two of you are so stressed about paying down/off debt, and you do not have children, do one or both of the following:

    1) Downsize on the house

    2) Get 2nd job(s)

    Anniversary
  • NBreeNBree member
    Sixth Anniversary 100 Comments 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    If he's already a mama's boy and she already competes with you for his attention it will just get worse x1000 if you move in with her.  This whole thing sounds like a recipe for disaster and misery.  You would be better off adjusting your budget and cutting costs to save more.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I don't think moving in with your husband's mom is a very good idea in your circumstance.

    Have you considered just getting a cheaper place, like an apartment to save money? 

  • Extremely stupid idea.  Do not do it. 
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • +SMACE++SMACE+ member

    This sounds like the worst idea, ever, in the history of bad ideas. 

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickersLilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • +SMACE++SMACE+ member

    imageOurhouse124:
    stupid is taking the time to reply to a post that you think is stupid.

    image

     

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickersLilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • NBreeNBree member
    Sixth Anniversary 100 Comments 5 Love Its Combo Breaker

    Actually, I take back what I said.  He should move in with his mother, you should look into counseling and/or possibly a divorce attorney.  Especially if it was your picture he was uploading to porn sites.

     http://community.thenest.com/cs/ks/forums/thread/65776756.aspx

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • You already said you don't know if you could stand it... and that right there is enough to tell you... Don't Do It! My husband and I just this last fall moved across the state to over where his family and friends are. We lived with his mom for five months so we could take our time finding an apartment that we really liked. His mom is always really nice to me and we get along well... but living with someone is different. Luckily we were able to move out before anything dramatic happened, however, we were stressed out and wanted a space of our own! (Plus he has a 16 year old sister living there too). Maybe you can find a small, inexpensive apartment? Don't make your lives miserable and strain your relationships with these people just to save money.
  • This is a very bad idea.

    NEVER a good ideat to live with a relative or other people.

    What caught my attention is this:

    It sounds like a good idea, but I dont know if I could stand living with his mom and him. Since his dad did die young, he is a COMPLETE Mommas boy...which is great, except when she 'competes' with me to get his attention

    Between this issue and your randy little H uploading pics of his naughty bits on the interwebs, sister, have you got lots of problems.

    Show him the door.

    BOTH problems are solved: he's out of your life and no more discussion about living with his mom.

  •  It sounds like a good idea, but I dont know if I could stand living with his mom and him. Since his dad did die young, he is a COMPLETE Mommas boy...which is great, except when she 'competes' with me to get his attention.

    This entire paragraph is a bunch of contradictions.

    It's a good idea, but you don't know if you can stand to live w/ his mom.

    He's a COMPLETE momma's boy, which is great.  Huh?

    I have a feeling YOU know the answer to this, but you have your DH in your ear telling you what a great idea HE thinks it is.  Let me guess- his MOM came up w/ this idea?  And as such, he thinks it's a GREAT idea? 

    Am I right?? Huh? Huh?

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • Very bad idea. But so is being married to this guy.  As an aside, I'm happy that Gloria Steinem has shown up to give her opinion on your marital issues in TIP.  

    image Mabel the Loser.
  • imageNBree:

    Actually, I take back what I said.  He should move in with his mother, you should look into counseling and/or possibly a divorce attorney.  Especially if it was your picture he was uploading to porn sites.

     http://community.thenest.com/cs/ks/forums/thread/65776756.aspx

    Yes 

    image "...Saving just one pet won't change the world...but, surely, the world will change for that one pet..."
  • doglovedoglove member
    5000 Comments Fifth Anniversary 5 Love Its Combo Breaker
    You already know the answer here. Do you really have to ask us or do you just want us to tell you it's a bad idea?
  • I have actually done this. It was a disaster. It's not worth the savings. It becomes poison to your relationship.
  • I am a smelly loser.
    Love my million dollar family with 2U2! DS born: 12/16/10 DD born: 07/18/12
  • DH and I have a rule: NO living with relatives. Ever. Period. 

    I suggest the same.  

  • Sounds like a lot of people full heartily disagree with you moving in with her! What what you said it does sound like your apprehensive which you should listen to. Looking into a cheaper smaller place like people have said is a good idea. I currently am living with my MIL for the same reason your thinking about it. We can save lots of money. It totally depends on the size of the house, the house we are staying in is 3 stories so if I want I can pretty much keep to my side of the house and only see her if I need to go cook in the kitchen. We have our own living room, bathroom, and 2 bedrooms, plus lots of storage in the garage and basement. We do fight from time to time about his inability to say 'no' to his mom or stand his ground which often results in me looking like the ***. He is getting better and I'm getting better at letting the little things that really don't matter go. If you decide to do it, have talks about some ground rules right up front. If you can do this with him and then do it together with her, but even if its only ever with him thats better then nothing. I need dinner where it is just the two of us 2 times a week, and I prefer that to be at home where we cook together, but obviously I can't tell her to go out. So my compromise is sometimes we cook together and then she eats with us, and sometimes the two of us go out on dates. It has made us have to communicate really well. Rather than saying, "Hey want to watch a movie tonight?" when you actually want to snuggle and see where it might lead, you have to say "Hey lets get a movie, and  watch it up in the bedroom (assuming you have a tv in your room which you really should if your living with your MIL) so we can have some snuggle time?" You will learn to be explicit in what you want, because otherwise if he is anything like my good intentioned mommy's boy he will invite her to watch it with you. Good luck it is a hard decision and it totally depends on how good you can communicate, whether he gets that she competes for his attention, ect. It can work so don't totally throw the idea out, but have lots of talks about what it can and will do to the spontaneity of your relationship, your sex life, being able to have friends over and dinner parties. There are lots of things that change when your living in someone elses house so try to think of them all and decide if its worth it. For us the size of the house and our communication is the only things that make it work. Good luck!
  • My advice is don't do it.

    However, if you do move in with your MIL, make sure you have a solid Plan B: saved money for a security deposit and first month rent at an apartment.  You can save a lot of money living with a relative, but having a back-up plan will help you to be more assertive.  If you are living at your MIL's, and you put all of the money from the sale of your house into paying off debt, then you will feel trapped and possibly not speak up enough at MIL's due to fear of her threatening to kick you out at anytime.  You don't want to ever give your MIL that power.  I did once and it was the worst feeling, and it took several years to repair the damage and reset boundaries. 

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards