Fashion & Beauty
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Help me finalize my MAC shadow choices

Your comments in my previous post were very helpful!

I got rid of Seedy Pearl and replaced with Motif.

I decided that Naked Lunch was too similar to Shroom, so I ditched NL and added Brun to have another dark option for the v or crease.

This leaves me with: 

Amber Lights, Woodwinked, Expensive Pink, Swish, Sky Blue, Shimmermoss, Plumage, Beautiful Iris, Motif, Shale, Sable, Cork, Brun, All That Glitters, Shroom

However, I'm kind of thinking that Cork and Sable are too similar.  I love Cork, but may want to get rid of Sable.

Also, I think I may want to ditch Sky Blue and replace with a pretty green color.  Any recommendations for a green color to replace Sky Blue?  I already have a Dior palette with very light and springy green colors, so I'm thinking a non-pastel green. 

If I get rid of Sable, what about a nice grey color to use a as crease shade?  I'm pretty heavy on the browns right now.  I would think that a nice grey would be a pretty crease color with the pastel lid colors such as Shimmermoss and Beautiful Iris.  Any recommendations for a grey to use as a crease color (nothing too dark for daytime)?

I'm officially addicted.  This cosmetics thing is like crack.

Re: Help me finalize my MAC shadow choices

  • I really like Humid for a green. It's a darker/foresty green.
    A big old middle finger to you, stupid Nest.
  • Sable, All That Glitters, & Shroom are my faves.

     

    I'm always making excuses to buy makeup. My excuse is it always fits no matter my size. Stick out tongue


    imageimage

    9/24/2011 Plymouth Firefighters 5k: 47:13
    11/12/2011 Diva Dash 5k: 45:45
    5/5/2012 STEM school 5k TBD Coming up in 2012:
    6/10/2012 Walk to Remember SIDS foundation 5k
    (in memory of a sweet baby boy)
    11/10/2012 Diva Dash 5k
  • I have Sable, but have also used Cork.  They are not too similar, IMO.  Sable is darker and has more red to it than Cork.  Sable is a satin finish.  I can't remember what Cork is.  I want to say matte or almost matte.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Maybe Folie instead of Sable? See my FOTD today for the color. Also, Folie looks amazing with Amberlights as a smokey eye combo.

    I also vote Humid for green. If not Humid, maybe Swimming or Juxt? Both on the lighter side.

  • What about the grey color Electra?  Would that pair with some of my other colors if I wanted to do something with grey rather than brown?
  • I thought you were trying to spend less on cosmetics? Wink
  • Copperplate is a really pretty gray brown.  
  • imageGo_Dawgs:
    What about the grey color Electra?  Would that pair with some of my other colors if I wanted to do something with grey rather than brown?

    Electra is pretty silver... and usually I pair silvers with black or alone. Possibly Plumage? When are you going to order? I would have to look at my colors and compare after work for you LOL! ;)

    ETA: Nehru, Scene or Print are more gray than silver. Scene is the lighter of the 3, and more of a "natural" gray

  • imageLitasail:
    I thought you were trying to spend less on cosmetics? Wink

    Yeah, that's not going so well.  I don't NEED to cut back, but sometimes I think it's a little silly to be such a cosmetics junkie like I'm becoming.  It's also so much easier to excuse the spending when I'm having a really good month like this month (I'm self employed)  :)

  • imageMrs Acorn Blue:
    Copperplate is a really pretty gray brown.  

    Ooooo, I love Copperplate!  That might be a winner.

    CAB - I already have Plumage on the list.  It's very pretty!

    I like Humid and may replace Sky Blue with humid, but I'm going to google the other two green colors you recommended. 

  • imageCAB1217:

    ETA: Nehru, Scene or Print are more gray than silver. Scene is the lighter of the 3, and more of a "natural" gray

    Cool - I'll google these, too :)

    I may order tonight.  Or tomorrow.  IDK - it's not like I really NEED these right away :)

  • You know, Club goes with blues, greens, grays, browns... Check out that color! It's gorgeous!
  • For grey how about Print? It's my fav! Or Knight Divine, or Smut?
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • my standby all time favorite combination is Ricepaper, Expresso (I think), Shroom with Brun as the eyeliner. 
  • And to make it harder, I use Follie as a crease color and it is my favorite crease color ever. It looks like a cranberry/brownish color but is very neutral on the lid. SOOOOO pretty and I wear it with naked lunch, grain, all that glitters. Also I love to use cork in my crease and Follie in the outer v.

    Sigh...love MAC

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Okay, Humid is definitely my green. 

    Now I have to decide if I should keep Sable, or replace it with Scene or Copperlate (I love both!)

    I'll PIP my palette so far :)

    imageimageimageimageimageimageimageimageimageimageimageimageimageimage

    So, for my last color, should I pick:

    Sable

    image

    Scene

    image

    or Copperplate?

    image

  • imageCAB1217:
    You know, Club goes with blues, greens, grays, browns... Check out that color! It's gorgeous!

    That one is pretty, too!  Crap.  lol

  • Man, you girls are killing me.  MAC has so many pretty colors!  I CANNOT get more than 15!  Decisions, decisions . . .
  • imageGo_Dawgs:

    So, for my last color, should I pick:

    Sable

    image

    Scene

    image

    or Copperplate?

    image

    My vote is for Copperplate. 

  • spoken like a true MU junkie Dawgs ;)

    honestly I went through that phase too....now I feel guilty & silly focusing on it so much. Get some great stuff and be done with it minus things here and there.

    lately I'm focusing on clothes a lot..mostly bc I feel so frumpy and feel like it's more of an investment for me right now....other times I spend too much on books. Depends on my mood :) 

  • imageCarrotsMakeMeFat:

    spoken like a true MU junkie Dawgs ;)

    honestly I went through that phase too....now I feel guilty & silly focusing on it so much. Get some great stuff and be done with it minus things here and there.

    lately I'm focusing on clothes a lot..mostly bc I feel so frumpy and feel like it's more of an investment for me right now....other times I spend too much on books. Depends on my mood :) 

    Yeah, it really does eventually have to end. I mean, I only have so much space, and one can only use so many different products, lol. I've been so boring with my makeup for so long, though, that it's like I'm discovering so many new fun things.  I'm sure the novelty will eventually wear off :)

    ETA: Until about six months ago, I had never even heard of Benefit, Tarte, Nars, MUFE, and so many other brands.  If I went to Sephora, it was for something very specific that I'd been using forever.  I don't know why I was so disinterested for so long.  But now that I've started learning about different cosmetic products, it's like being a kid in a candy store!

  • Greensmoke is my go to green for MAC.
    Meine Welt... Meine Welt... Und die Liebe die wird rot Und der Hass schwarz wie der Tod Ich mach' das so wie's mir gef
  • I'd remove the yellowy-gold in the third row of your pictures. I think the yellow is much too strong, especially since you have red tones in your face.

    Cooperplate looks a lot like the last color in the 4th row, just a smudge darker. I'd suggest something different since you could add a little black to Copperplate to get that look. 

    Here some that I like:

    Knight Divine (lovely dark grey with shimmer)

    image 

    Club (a beautiful brown/gold/green)

    image 

    Fig 1 (rich purple, great crease color for blue/green eyes)

    image 

    "However, she mistook the drowsy-eye/alcohol warning for a winking-eye alcohol suggestion." image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards