9 to 5
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Need Advice from commuters: Long commute, worth taking job?

Hi ladies,

 

So I am fortunate enough to have two job offers within the same industry. My question is, would you take a job with a long commute to make 50% more money? Are you currently commuting everyday at least an hour or more and is it worth it? Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.

 My husband thinks i'm insane for considering the company where my commute is longer but the pay is higher (higher than what gas would cost, plus I drive a prius). The offer where I would be closer pays less and I would be in training twice as long (meaning low pay while in training). Thanks!

 

Re: Need Advice from commuters: Long commute, worth taking job?

  • Commuting makes the work day that much longer. Is the commute an hour with or without traffic? Try driving it during the morning and afternoon like you would if you worked there. In Austin Tx it takes 30 minutes to get across town. During rush hour it can take 2+ hours depending on where you work and live.

     I say if the commute is an hour then it's worth taking. Only you can decide. You can get audio books and make the commute productive and enjoyable too. 

  • i agree with PP, it depends where you live. How is the winter weather by you? Warm, Cold, lots of snow?  What is traffic like. An hour of steady driving isnt a big deal, i used to do that commute but laced with traffic is stressful and frustrating. 

     Also- which job would you take if you didn't have to make the commute or do you like both equally?  Do you need the extra money?

    imageimage
  • I did a 90 minute commute (3 hours) for years because the pay was better and it was just a better company.  It does take it's toll on you and the gas adds up. But I listened to CD lessons, audiobooks, etc and made the best of it.  Sometimes I was about to take the train.  Is there any public transit?

    50% more is alot.  I would suggest calculating the fuel/wear&tear (you did) on your car and any additional city/county taxes along with driving it once like you would for work.  Would this make it a 11 hour day?  What are you sacrificing? Can you live with that?

    From what you have said, I would do the commute :)

    image
  • I would think long-term, if you will have children in future, I'd rather be closer to home in case of emergency, etc.
  • Thank you everyone for all of the insight. I have to be honest with myself that it's not an easy commute. If any of you know the D.C. beltway area, then you know traffic is a nightmare. However two of the work days are weekends and the other days are non peak rush hour times 10-7pm. Not that is makes it any better. So if there were no traffic issues at all, it's close to an hour one way. Of course if there is traffic, then it could be at least 90 minutes.

    50% is alot more so I have to decide if it's worth making it a possible 12 hour day. And yes, I have two kids. 

    If there were no commuting between both jobs, I would take the one that is the long commute because they are so similar and the companies are so similar so it comes down to the pay. 

  • I drive an hour each way to my job, 5 days a week. I have now been with my company for 9 months and this job was my only job offer from my job search last year. I work at a physical therapy clinic with long hours and the two hours a day driving definitely do take their toll-making my 10 hour days, which wouldn't be too bad if I lived 10 minutes away, into 12 hour days. It has been hard to make time to see friends and family, as well as my fiance since we do not live together. I am anxious to see next year when we get married and share a home if I will mind the drive more or less. On the gas side, I have a car that gets 39 combined mpg, so that does not bother me too much. I hate putting miles on my car though. It is definitely a hard decision to make, especially with your kids in the picture! I love my job and the people I work with, so for right now I am content. As I'm sure you know, your co-workers can either make you love or hate your job! You can also see if this company would ever consider allowing you to work 4 ten hour days to save you 1 day of driving if that idea sounds appealing to you.
    Wedding Countdown Ticker

    May 2013 January Siggy

    image

  • I too have a job offer, but the job is 3 hour commute away, which really means I drive up Monday morning and come back Friday afternoon.

    I have to think about accommodation, gas and time away from my bf.

    Jobs are so scarce that I really need to take this one! 

    There is flexibility in that I can work from home some of the days.

    Good luck with your decision! 

     

     

     

    Vacation
  • I drive 1.5 hrs each way for work. I make way more than I would in the area even with my gas guzzling SUV and tolls included, in fact I'd probably have to be in a different industry entirely if I worked near home. I even have to pay taxes for where I live plus on wages for PA (where I work) and I still make out better. I have a 7 hour work day with flexible hours so luckily I am able to leave for work early morning and the office by 3. Otherwise I would hit rush hour and the 1.5 hrs would grow. Do I feel like I may have nervous breakdowns when there is traffic and I'm stuck for 3 hours? Yes but that rarely happens. With my commute my day is 6:15 and I'm home at 4:30. If I had to work until 5 and not get home until 7 there is no way I would do it. At least getting home at 4:30 I have a decent part of the day left. Good luck!
  • I think it boils down to work/life balance since I have children. Although I love the company and the people are so great, the thought of a 12 hour day if I had to commute is just not appealing and will probably cause me to want to quit later on down the road. Then I may not be so lucky with job offers. I think on Monday I will decline the offer with the long commute. Thank you for all your advice

     

  • I've commuted for about two years in the Chicago area now.  My commute has usually been a solid 2 hours each way.  I don't know what type of commute you're looking at, but I would personally only consider that if you weren't going to do it long-term.  People that I know that have done it long-term are the ones that get burnt out and I know there have been studies that show the effects this time apart can have on a relationship. 

     While I don't think you should necessarily bow down to your husband's wish, I also think the longer hours will put a lot of stress on your relationship if he didn't want you to take the job in the first place.  These are all things to consider.  

     Overwhelmingly, though, the main thing you should be thinking about is how long you are willing to commute timewise.  Will you do this if/when you have kids?  What are you going to do if you start commuting and find that you just don't have enough hours in the day to get stuff done at home or to go to the gym or whatever you currently do in your free time?   

  • I commuted from Fredericksburg to D.C. for over a year, and it was rough on both my husband and on me. I would seriously consider if the money is worth it, because it took a toll on me and it definitely strained our relationship because I was so tired by the end of the week. In the end, the money and prestigious job weren't worth running myself ragged just to work. 

    I tried taking the commuter train, driving all the way in, driving to the metro then metro-ing in, and they all had advantages and disadvantages.Yes, you can listen to books on tape, read on the train, etc, but you are still committing 3 - 4 hours of every day to travel to an 8 hour job.

    Plus, living and working in DC/Northern Virginia, there was always something to make the commute longer, whether it was serious traffic on 95 or the Metro/VRE delays caused by weather or a sick passenger, etc. Even if you still arrive at work on time, nothing puts you in a bad mood like trekking 2+ hours just to get into work so you can put in a full 8 hours, then take the trip home.

    Another thing to consider: I got a bad stomach bug and got sick at work and had to leave early, and instead of being able to quickly get home, I had to take  a metro to Union Station, then a 1.5 hour train ride just to then get in my car to drive myself home from the VRE station. None of that helped my stomach. In cases of emergency and sickness, it's sure nice to be close to home.

    You also spend more money just to get into the office, weather it's the ever-increasing price of public transportation, or gas and wear & tear on your car. The salary is 50% more, but the time you spend in work mode is also 50% more, and with the added expenses, is the additional money off-setting your time & monetary investments? 

    If you could, I would recommend taking a test commute for a few days - see how you feel after 3 or 4 days commuting to your job. 

  • I used to commute 25-35 minutes for 5 years in traffic! Boy it was a pain sometimes as all I wanted to do was get home...I applied for another job that was 13 minutes from my house and the pay was 3,000 less but I took it anyway....I ended up making what i did at my last job as the health insurance was a lot less due to it being a bigger company so I basically broke even. Plus I save on gas, wear and tear on my car and a lot of metal exhaustion.. best thing I ever did!
  • Oh gosh, D.C. traffic made me thankful for the Metro system.  Smile  I now live in northwest Colorado.  My typical daily commute is 40 minutes, but with snow or summer road construction, it's an hour or more.  I hate it.  I like my job, but I get to work grouchy and I come home exausted.  I'm seriously considering quitting.  I want to move closer, but my husband's job is down the highway in the opposite direction.

    Commute only if you think you would LOVE your new job.  If you only like it, the exaustion and extra time away from home may not be worth it.

  • I was recently in your very same shoes with two job offers one with a 20min commute the other a 50min commute the one with the longer commute ending up paying more money. I ended up taking the job with the longer commute and I am glad that I did. We really need the extra money, the hours work good for us and the drive really doesnt seem that bad gives you time to unwind after work
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards