Buying A Home
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Buying from an emotional seller

Hi everyone, my wife and I just submitted an offer on a house we love. The listing agent has told us and our agent that the seller is emotionally tied to the house and even has it listed too high- so both the seller and the listing agent agree it is listed for too much. We know the specific reasons but are not going to post them for privacy issues. Anyway our initial offer was obviously below asking price but after scrutinizing the CMA, overall condition of the house and items needing repair we do not feel it was unjustifiable. I guess our question is how soon should we respond to her counter? She did come down a little bit but one of her reasons for not coming down too much (aside from the strong emotional situation she is going through) is that she did not want to deviate too much from her original list price- which was admittedly too high. The house has been on the market for almost 11 months now and she has only reduced price 1 time. Should we come back now with another offer or wait a few days? A week? Feel free to contact me privately for more specific info.

Re: Buying from an emotional seller

  • Usually - legally - an offer requires a counteroffer.  So you would be responding to her counteroffer at this point, no?  If that's the case, you can counter whenever you'd like.  If you submitted something that she hasn't answered to yet, then you should wait for her to answer.  


  • That's correct.  We'll be responding to her counteroffer.  I am just mauling over how long we should wait to submit a counter to her counter since her emotions are running so high. 
  • I would wait several days before countering in order to give the seller time to think logically instead of acting emotionally. And when countering, I would not go up very much. Stick to what the CMAs are telling you, otherwise you'll be under contract at a higher price than the house will appraise for, and you'll be stuck re-negotiating the deal in a few weeks anyway.
  • Honestly I don't think it matters how long you wait- if she's really overpriced and everyone knows and it doesn't appear she's going to come down.  She's been on the market for almost a year and is still overpriced. 

    You don't have to respond at all to the counter.  If there is a time listed to respond an you don't respond then the counter is void.  You would be putting in a new offer at that point when her counter expires. 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • If she's been overpriced for a year, there is little chance a few days are going to change her mind.

    I'd think twice about offering too much on this property. It may not appraise for what she is asking and then you'd either have to make up the difference out of your pocket or walk away.

  • As someone who has had to walk away from two homes this year due to failed appraisals, you need to figure out fair market value using recent comps with your REA and offer accordingly.

    We have dealt with emotional sellers and it sucks.  Sadly, I think their realtor is a huge problem as well, so instead of being the voice of reason, it was a huge cluster.

    imageimage
  • I can see the sellers realtor being a problem.  She seems too sweet which in this case may not be good for the actual seller who needs to start thinking a little more rationally.  Also agree that a failed is a concern though I something tells me we'll never even get that far.  I hope I'm wrong but I'm always ready to walk.  I try to live a cluster free life:)
  • In any negotation I have been through the offer and subsequent counter-offers were submitted with time frames as part of the offer.  For example, our original offer was submitted with 24 hours for the seller to respond or else the offer became void.  When the seller countered they stipulated we had 12 hours to counter/respond or their counter was void.  I have not heard of a situation where an offer or counter offer is still on the table for as long as you would like to think about it.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards