May 2012 Weddings
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Would you be offended?

I have a friend that recently anounced she is expecting. I was at lunch with her and her mother the other day and they started talking baby shower. Now, keep in mind she is only 10 weeks along so a shower is still in the distance but grandma-to-be is very excited about grand baby #1. Anyways, my friend brought up an idea she saw on Pinterest that instead of guests to the shower bringing a card, they purchase a childrens book instead to give as the 'card'. This way they can write in the book and it is something that child can have for years to come and actually use. I think it is a cute idea but I know from my lurkings on other boards that this is considered a MAJOR no no because you are telling people how exactly to spend their money. I don't dare post this any place else because I would get burned at the stake so I wanted your ladies opinion on the matter. Would you be offended if you received a baby shower invite with this message in it? The message she found on Pinterest is a cute poem so it's not like it would say 'Buy me books instead of cards' or something like that. Thanks for the input gals :)
Hey, Hey Hockeytown!photo hockeytown_zps6a7377b0.jpg

Re: Would you be offended?

  • I might be in the minority based off of what I've seen on The Bump but I wouldn't be. We didn't do it for my baby shower but we did do it for my SIL's. Everyone thought it was a cute idea and those that didn't, just didn't bring a book.
    Lilypie Maternity tickers

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • I think the idea is cute and honestly if it's not asked in a rude way I don't see the harm. And like PP said if they don't like the idea or want to do it then they won't. 

    For my bridal shower they asked everyone to bring household items and they all loved it and thought it was such a wonderful idea. I think if the invite doesn't come from the mom to be/bride then no one will take it as being rude.  

  • I wouldn't be offended by this. For my shower the hosts asked the guests to bring a recipe in for me to have, I've gotten invitations to showers that asked for me to bring a tea cup and saucer for the bride to be etc. But it was never a requirement, just an idea for guest to choose what they'd like to do. I think for a baby shower this is actually a great idea since cards get tossed in the trash afterwards plus the books people bring will be really useful for this little one's future. Also, childrens books these days can be almost the same cost as a greeting card so I don't think guests will be spending more than they would have anyway and if they do then they can cut back on what they spend on the actual gift.

    image

    Missing Our July Sparkler
    BFP#1-11/12/12, MMC 1/16/13-baby stopped growing @ 9wks, found out at 13wks, D&E 1/25/13
    BFP#2-4/23/13 EDD-01/02/14 baby BOY born 12/31/13 Michael Cameron <3

  • I personally rolled my eyes at all the stuff people on TK used to say they'd be "offended" by.  I'd hate to be around someone IRL who got that butthurt over every little thing.

     Anyways...I've been invited to showers with that same idea.  They didn't tell you that you have to, it was worded more optional, like we will be collecting children's books so if you would like to write your message inside of a book instead of a card, we'll add it to baby ____'s bookshelf.  A lot of people brought books, but a fair amount didn't.  I think as long as you word it correctly, and it comes across as a no obligation option instead of a request, it's totally fine.

    photo trex2_zps7ab4e9b0.jpg
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I'm with everyone else here... i wouldn't be offended.. in fact I love the idea... I love buying kids books :) I think reading is important so i'd be all for it. And those that don't want to do it... won't! 
    View Full Size Image
  • I wouldn't be offended at all. I think it's a really cute idea :) Like PP have said, as long as it's worded in a way that lets people know it's not required then I think it's fine.
    imageAnniversary
  • I love this idea and I wouldn't be offended at all!  As PP's have said, I think as long as you word it so that guests know that it is optional, then people can choose to participate or not.
    image 

    Anniversary 
  • Every shower I been too and its been a lot lately have done this... I think its cute and no harm. :) 
    "Anyone can be passionate, but it takes real lovers to be silly"
  • Agree with the PPs- I wouldn't be offended at all! It is a cute idea, and children books are not expensive and readily available.
  • I probably wouldn't hang out with someone that was that easily offended.  lol

    I saw that same idea on Pinterest and thought it was super cute!  I'd probably want to do it too :)

  • I agree with all the previous posts. I think cards are a waste of money and I'd rather buy a book the kid will use/keep than a card. If someone doesn't want to buy a card they won't and I honestly can't see why anyone would be offended by this. 

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers 

    imageimage

    image

  • Looks like i might be the odd one out here. I wouldn't be offended and think the idea is cute, but I probably just wouldn't go because at this point in my life I don't have the money for a gift AND a book and wouldn't want to be the one person who showed up without bringing a book. My price range for showers and b-days and such of non-family is very low right now because of finances, so I would already risk looking cheap with a small gift, and then to be expected to spend more money on getting a book. I wouldn't want to be embarressed and not bring one.
  • I love the idea and actually have been doing this myself for years.  Mommy-to-be's around here love that I do it and have kind of gotten a reputation for always bringing the book/card.  The only problem now, is finding books someone hasn't already been given!  I say do it as long as it is written as a idea/option rather than a "can't get through the door without the book!" kind of thing....
  • No, not at all! I have heard of baby showers where the host asks the guests to bring their favorite children's book to start the baby's library. I think it's a cute idea :)

    What I think is wrong is planning a baby shower when she is 10 weeks along... maybe I am old fashioned , but I am not telling anyone until we hit 12 weeks. 

    imageDaisypath Anniversary tickers
  • Just joining in the bandwagon... I think the idea is lovely and I am a sucker for buying kids books (and you can find them just as cheap as a nice card now).

    I think it'd be great and cute. 

  • imagemandi921vh:

    What I think is wrong is planning a baby shower when she is 10 weeks along... maybe I am old fashioned , but I am not telling anyone until we hit 12 weeks. 

    Two girls I'm friends with on Facebook (one is an old friend from college and one is one of H's friend's wives) announced it on the Internet around 7 weeks.  Toooooo early! I would be so nervous!

    Lilypie Maternity tickers

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards