Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Live in Sister-In-Law

My wife and I have just celebrated our 4 years this past Decemeber. My wife is from Poland, and we met playing in a co-ed soccer league.  Our marriage is great and we are both happy, but I have only one complaint... The sister in law. I love my sister in law, and she is a great person. But since we have been married, we have not had our home just to our selves. I try to be patient about everything I am about to share, because they are twins and all of their family is back in Poland.

 I finally got the SIL to move out a year and a half ago,  but her dog got into trouble and now the dog has to stay with us.  (Her apt is in our condo neighborhood, so she is 2 mins away) The dog is destroying our house which causes my wife and I to argue, and when I bring this to my SIL attention, she replies that it's only things that I shouldn't worry so much about it....?!

My SIL doesn't get along with her room mate so she basically sleeps on our couch 4 days a week, and when she is not working she is hanging out at our house for the nights/mornings. 

 I am trying really hard to be patient, but coming home everyday where the walls and base boards are all scratched up, the couch is covered in dog hair, the house is clutter with dog toys and my SIL's stuff is all over the house. Not to mention, I would like to have a nice quite evening with my wife just the 2 of us.

I am not sure how to solve this problem, but everytime I bring it up with my wife, it starts an argument and I would hate for this to be the reason for our marriage to fall apart. Any adivce would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Live in Sister-In-Law

  • It's okay to argue.  That's how problems are resolved.  Have the argument with your wife, and don't back down out of fear of the marriage ending.  After all, is she kicking out the sister and dog because she's afraid of the marriage ending?  No, she is not.  This is how you foster a power imbalance in your marriage, and THAT is a marriage killer.
    image
  • I agree with PP. This is also a wife issue not a SIL issue. Your SIL wouldn't be able to do any of this if your wife didn't allow her. The dog would be gone if I was you, and you should tell your wife you are going to start charging her sister rent. Talk to your wife and tell her this isn't working for you and something HAS to change.

    Also, do you watch Real Housewives of Miami? You should, this same problem with the sister and the Poland angle is on this show. This maybe mud. Lol 

  • imageReturnOfKuus:
    It's okay to argue.  That's how problems are resolved.  Have the argument with your wife, and don't back down out of fear of the marriage ending.  After all, is she kicking out the sister and dog because she's afraid of the marriage ending?  No, she is not.  This is how you foster a power imbalance in your marriage, and THAT is a marriage killer.

     All of this. 

  • Be careful of ultimatums, or things that sound like ultimatums. Approaching your wife kindly with your real concerns and desires to share your newlywed (ish) time with just the 2 of you is a much more positive spin than "I'm gonna charge her rent if she doesn't get out". However, you can't let this continue while you fester resentments and get angrier. You need to speak up for yourself!
  • This was helpful, thank you. The hardest part is bringing it up to a point that I am not trying to throw a ultimatum, but just the fact that it is boiling me up inside and something has to change. Thanks for the advice :)
  • The way you said it right now is good, that you are trying not to throw out an ultimatum, but you are really seething with resentment over this, and it's not good for your marriage.  Maybe also add that whatever solution you come to, you want both of you to agree on it together, so neither of you is resentful and you both feel that you're working as a team.
    image
  • I think it's time to get down to the nitty gritty. First, get out of the apartment - take a drive, get a coffee and sit in the car and talk. There is nothing worse than knowing a family member you are trying to avoid may get back any minute and will put you both on edge and defensive - get out and have some real alone time with no distractions. You need to talk about this meaning have a conversation. Do not talk AT eachother. Focus on keeping your tone non-dominating. Find out how she feels about this situation that has obviously been going on long enough and that will hopefully lead to a calm, cool and collected discussion about how she thinks it is effecting your marriage and how it makes you feel. It sounds like if she is willing to get in multiple arguements with you about this (and willing to ignore your discomfort) then there is something she is NOT dealing with. She must not like to tell her sister "no", but your spouse becomes your immediate family when you say those vows and your old immediate family becomes your EXTENDED family. YOU come first.

    Further suggestions - get rates on doggy day care or sit the sister down about moving so she can accomodate a dog that she obviously isn't mature enough to handle. Either get her to move or y'all move plan and simple. If it complicates your life a little but yet adds physical distance between your SIL then I personally would rather deal with that.

    I have a very dramatic and high mainenance SIL as well and my fiance and I aren't even married yet! She almost ruined my engagement because she made a 360 and decided she hated me and ignored me for months on end and I had no idea why. Her behavior was even effecting all of us when we were all together - she was just down-right moody, derragotory and HORRIBLE. None of my fiance's family is pro-active and VERY nonconfrontational which only made me feel alone and unprotected and I was the one that had to fix everything on my own.

     All in all, dealing with a spouses family is a toughy and I commend you for being so patient. I would personally be going crazy if that was happening and that shows a lot on your character to be handling it so strongly. I wish you the best and you will stay in my thoughts and prayers that you both will meet a mutual solution.

  • imageMLE2010:

    I agree with PP. This is also a wife issue not a SIL issue. Your SIL wouldn't be able to do any of this if your wife didn't allow her. The dog would be gone if I was you, and you should tell your wife you are going to start charging her sister rent. Talk to your wife and tell her this isn't working for you and something HAS to change.

    Also, do you watch Real Housewives of Miami? You should, this same problem with the sister and the Poland angle is on this show. This maybe mud. Lol 

    This!  Plus, it really stinks when you work hard for a nice place and you come home to it to being a mess.  The SIL is disrespecting you and your wife, but your wife is allowing it to happen.  It's definitely a wife problem!  Honestly, I don't know how anyone can live like that.  I don't know how your wife isn't upset that the house/condo is a mess and it's from her own sister.

    Lol..I watched this episode!  Joanna and I can't remember the fiance and SIL's name, at the moment.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Anniversary
  • Your wife has no right to be angry about how you feel about your SIL.  Your SIL is way out of line by pretty much taking over your home.  It is a space for you and your wife to live and be a family and be married and her sister is disrupting this.  You need to sit both your wife and her sister down and explain to them how you feel about what is going on, and you should bring up the fact that her dog is tearing up your house and she needs to take it back or find it a home or you will.  She is also encroaching on your personal space by sleeping on your coach which prevents a healthy relationship between you two as new brother and sister.  If your wife is picking her sister over you this is a problem especially since she has her own apartment, you have to lay down boundaries and if she does not respect them she is not respecting you as an equal partner in your marriage.  It is your house too not just hers and you need to make that clear.
    Abraswell
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards