Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

need advice

My husband and i are going to be trying to get pregnant later this year (end of summer, fall time) and my only worry is the fact that it will somehow upset his older sister who just had her first baby later this year. Ever since i met her somehow different things i do (it seems like just my actions) upset her.. they were out visiting the family this past weekend and someone asked when my hubby and i would be trying, and we said, and she got up and ran out of the room in tears.. they were supposed to stay the weekend but they left later that afternoon due to the fact she was so upset...her husband assured us its nothing and she will get over it..but now i feel like im stepping on her toes or stealing her thunder of this year being "her year" or something...

i dont know if i sound immature by typing this or what to really do...my husband thinks his sister should get over it and accept the fact we want to start a family.. and i feel the same but i also don't want to have her acting like she did every time.. i love his sister and i am very proud to be an aunty to her baby...but i just dont know what to do here...its easy to say "who cares what she thinks do what you guys want" due to the fact drama is so not needed...but let me hear thoughts please.

Re: need advice

  • I don't get why she's so upset. I mean I would be happy if my child got to have a cousin so close in age! I don't think you guys should go schedule your life around what shes doing so I say continue doing what you're doing and do not let her bother you. I guess I really don't understand why she is acting like this and why you care. My only advice is try getting closer to her and you guys can try and bond over the whole baby thing, but if shes not having it just chalk it up to crazy hormones and move on. 
  • My goodness gracious...such childish behavior. How old is the sis? Sounds like she's about 7 years of age.

    This is your decision and H's --- do as you wish. you are stepping on nobody's toes. Don't feel guilty and don't try to please everybody by doing as they wish, not as you wish.

    Her H sure must have his hands full. She probably demanded they go home early and he obliged. Sad.
  • i have just determined that she has her own "way of life" and doesnt like when things dont go as she plans... also, your right, i dont know why i care...i am a caring person i guess lol i shouldnt worry about what she thinks. its just hard being family, but family SHOULD be supportive and whatnot, you dont see ME causing her problems or crying about things she chooses to do.
  • Are you close enough to her to ask her about her reaction? And for clarity - Did she have a baby late last year, or is she pregnant now?

    Regardless, you and DH should have children when it best suits YOU. There's nothing saying you can't try to understand and empathize with your SIL, but at some point you just step back and let her sort through her own issues and emotions.

    Break cycle BFP on 11/6/12 after 17 cycles and a failed IUI - TTC/BFP details in bio
    image
    Nestie Bestie with the lovely RockABye
    image imageimage
  • she just had their first baby at the start of this month, but babies for her in general since she got married she wanted one and was deeply jealous of anyone else who had one before her... she felt the world was "tormenting" her with all baby commercials and seeing babies everywhere, now they have one... i feel terribly cause we are really ready to settle down and start our family, she should be supportive and happy, but she just seems so negative about it, my hubby and i were talking over my lunch break today and she was texting him saying "i really just think you guys should be married for at least 3 years before you have a baby, it lets you get to know eachother better has husband and wife" which he did not understand and asked her what else we need to know about eachother, he basically told her that she should support our decision and not be so whiny about it because it isnt her life, its ours.. 
  • sounds like she is mentally unstable. Live your own life and let it roll off your back.
  • imageburybuck0489:
    she just had their first baby at the start of this month, but babies for her in general since she got married she wanted one and was deeply jealous of anyone else who had one before her... she felt the world was "tormenting" her with all baby commercials and seeing babies everywhere, now they have one... i feel terribly cause we are really ready to settle down and start our family, she should be supportive and happy, but she just seems so negative about it, my hubby and i were talking over my lunch break today and she was texting him saying "i really just think you guys should be married for at least 3 years before you have a baby, it lets you get to know eachother better has husband and wife" which he did not understand and asked her what else we need to know about eachother, he basically told her that she should support our decision and not be so whiny about it because it isnt her life, its ours.. 

    She sounds like she's being a brat. For goodness sake, if you start TTC in the fall, even if you're successful the first month, the birth of your child is still 18m away. She'll have all the attention in the meantime. Do what's best for you, and you might want to develop a few witty comebacks for what are sure to be snarky comments from her in the near future. And kudos to you DH for telling her to shove it. Don't expect her to be happy for you, or to have your best interests at heart - for right now all you'll be is disappointed. Hopefully motherhood helps her mature a little.

    Break cycle BFP on 11/6/12 after 17 cycles and a failed IUI - TTC/BFP details in bio
    image
    Nestie Bestie with the lovely RockABye
    image imageimage
  • Thankyou for your words of advice. we will be trying for a baby end of summer/ start of fall. we are very much looking forward to the start of our beautiful family... but i guess you are all right, she DOES have to get over this, 
  • This girl sounds too stupid to deserve a baby. 
  • i dont know if "stupid" is the right word to use towards my SIL, i think she just needs to let go of the thought that things have to happen to HER liking, 
  • Your SIL sounds immature and possibly suffering from a mental issue. It is not normal to run out crying at the mention of someone TTC. Next time stand up and applaud her and scream out Emmy performance!! J/K 

    Don't ever put your goals or dreams on hold because of her or anyone else. You can feel sorry for her but not guilty.  

  • Would you believe she has a degree in psychology? lol and yeah, its just tough cause i care, sometimes too much i guess..but i really shouldnt let our dreams be crushed because "she" doesnt approve
  • She sounds like a whackjob.  I don't understand why you would even entertain caring about this.  It's nonsense.
  • simply because i am a caring person, and i seen she was upset and i did not know really what to do, i try to be a good person and i really didnt understand what i was doing wrong, i didnt think i was but according to her i was...she will just have to get over herself.
  • So if you got pregnant and this upset her what would you do? If you got a puppy and it upset her would you give it away? If you allow her tantrums to dictate your life you will be very sorry indeed. There is a difference in being caring and being a pushover. You sound like the latter. 

    "Do the best you can, until you know better. Then when you know better, do better." 

    -Maya Angelou


    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • You and your H need to just go ahead and do your thing. Your SIL needs to grow up and realize that you and your H are on your own life schedule, while she and her H are on theirs. My BIL behaves in a similar manner - everything with him is some competition, including TTC - and basically whatever problem he has with what we do is his problem. If your SIL brings it up again or has another tantrum, you should remind her of this. I would also recommend maybe keeping your plans to yourselves just so you don't have to deal with any headaches from her. But aside from that, don't you guys want to have something as personal and private as TTC to be between you and H?


  • I think you're trying really hard to be compassionate and sympathetic to her feelings, which is admirable.  However- there's a line between compassion and treating unreasonable behavior as if it's reasonable. It's fine to be compassionate- being ready to accept her apology or explanation if she offers one, or politely chalking it up to hormones or some source of stress in her life you don't know about- but you don't have to treat it as reasonable for her to act that way.  You don't have to tiptoe around her when you do get pregnant, you don't have to postpone TTC until she gives you her okay, you don't have to offer her any apology or explanation for you living your life.  
  • I am wondering if it's a possiblility she's gotten terrible news from her doc about her future childbearing capacity and maybe your news made her feel real bad.:(

    Even so, this isn't how adults act: she should have stood down and said nothing at all. Or quietly left the room. ANything but do what she did.:(
  • Nope, i called her after i finished work cause it was eating at me why she did that, her anwser was exactly as i thought, this is "her" childs year for attention and by me getting prengnant it takes the light off of her new baby, i simply told her that me being pregnant is just simply that, no light would be taken, and that she should be excited that her baby will have a cousin so close in age to grow up with, but to no avail...she cried and said that this was her year for a baby...so i told her regardless if she likes it or not we are going to be trying for a baby in the fall and she can either stand proudly and support us, or not come around if her jealousy is going to ruin things...my husband got on the phone with her and said that as his older sister it is her job to support and help him out and she is doing neither and that it would mean a great deal to him if she just sat down and let things happen and that no one will steal anyones thunder, which was completly stupid to begin with, it shouldn't be a competition, its a blessing
  • My guess is it was a competition to her, since she had a fit when people she knew had a baby before her. I am sorry you have a SIL like this, hopefully you can deal with all the drama with the years to come, yikes. 

    I'm glad you and your husband had a convo with her and didnt let it go as being 'okay'. Sounds like she got away with a lot growing up with how she talks to you and your H. I'm a pushover, so I know this situation would bug me too, but if people are acting unreasonable like this I have a much easier time saying go jump in the lake.

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • imageburybuck0489:
    my husband got on the phone with her and said that as his older sister it is her job to support and help him out and she is doing neither
    Really?  He thinks this and said this to her?  I'm glad you both talked to her - but this is kind of stupid.  It's not her "job" to be anything simply because she happened to be born first.  Yes, in the general sense of family and support, you'd HOPE that she'd be this for him - and vice versa.  But to put this onus on her just seems silly.

    That being said, what a PP said about it's one thing to be compassionate it is right.  You keep saying "i'm a caring person".  yea - well, we all are!   But we can recognize that she's being irrational!   This is her baby's "year"?  Really? 

     You really need to learn to live your life w/o worrying about what she thinks - at least as long as she's being this crazy about it. And moving forward, I'd actually advise to NOT talk to her about it (or other stuff she freaks out over).  You made one attempt - that's good.  Now- stop explaining and defending the choices in your life that actually have nothing to do w/ her.  To do so only tells her that she actually DOES have a say.  Don't give her that much power.  

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • imageburybuck0489:
    Nope, i called her after i finished work cause it was eating at me why she did that, her anwser was exactly as i thought, this is "her" childs year for attention and by me getting prengnant it takes the light off of her new baby, i simply told her that me being pregnant is just simply that, no light would be taken, and that she should be excited that her baby will have a cousin so close in age to grow up with, but to no avail...she cried and said that this was her year for a baby...so i told her regardless if she likes it or not we are going to be trying for a baby in the fall and she can either stand proudly and support us, or not come around if her jealousy is going to ruin things...my husband got on the phone with her and said that as his older sister it is her job to support and help him out and she is doing neither and that it would mean a great deal to him if she just sat down and let things happen and that no one will steal anyones thunder, which was completly stupid to begin with, it shouldn't be a competition, its a blessing

    This whole thing made me LOL.....tell your SIL to get over herself. And I stand by what I said - from now on, you should just keep baby making plans between you and your H. In the end, it's no one's business but yours when you guys are TTC.

  • thanks everyone for all your advice! i am feeling much stronger about the situation in the terms of ignoring the way she acts and letting her get over herself.
  • imageburybuck0489:
    thanks everyone for all your advice! i am feeling much stronger about the situation in the terms of ignoring the way she acts and letting her get over herself.

    Well thank heaven you came to your senses.  I was beginning to think you just liked being involved in other people's drama. 

  • The sister is RIDICULOUS. Live your life however it makes you happy. You'd think the sister would love having a cousin for her child and sharing in some of those new mom moments!! That's bizarre behavior...maybe she has some postpartum issues...but since you said this style of behavior is ongoing, maybe she's just selfish and self-centered. Big Smile
  • i just needed time to really access the situation, and once i stepped back and seen the situation i just shook my head and laughed, ill let her be that way, but it will not stop me and my husband from having our beautiful family when WE want to have it.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards