Pittsburgh Nesties
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Again with the countertops

Does anyone wish to weigh in on this? I have such commitment issues.

We have chosen a granite for our kitchen that looks like carrara marble and plain white subway tile for the backsplash. Our cabinets and floors are dark brown.

I currently have included in the estimate a walnut colored, distressed wood for the island b/c I like the mismatched island look and our house is so cookie cutter that I find myself wanting to mix things up when I have the chance. I was also thinking that it would warm up the cooler dark/white combo going on elsewhere in the kitchen.

But, it's $350 more for the wood and it's not as durable as the granite. It was a heat and water resistant treatment, but it will have to be recoated every 3 years and you still have to use hot pads on it.

But, we already use hot pads, so that's not an adjustment for us. And the rest of the surfaces will still be granite, so we would still have a lot of room to throw a pan directly onto the counter if we were really driven to do so.

And that about summarizes the argument that's replaying on a loop in my mind. Make it stop!

Re: Again with the countertops

  • For visualization purposes, here's a kitchen with similar tones with the uniform island:

    image

    And here's with wood on the island:

  • Personally I like the granite on the island.  Bur I'm generally pretty tame and am hesitant to mix things up sometimes.
    imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Tickera>
  • I like the wood/granite combo. But I chose wood for our counters in our renovation.

    Just an FYI, my mom has granite and the seller/installers told her always to use hot plates. While technically you can put a hot pot on the counter it is better not to on a regular basis.

  • imagekris356:

    I like the wood/granite combo. But I chose wood for our counters in our renovation.

    Just an FYI, my mom has granite and the seller/installers told her always to use hot plates. While technically you can put a hot pot on the counter it is better not to on a regular basis.

    Yeah, I don't see me putting anything directly on the surface anyway! I worry too much!

    Where'd you get your wood counters?

  • I much prefer the wood. It's warmer and adds texture. 
    "Never go with a hippie to a second location." ~ Jack Donaghy, 30 Rock
  • And since you will have granite everywhere else, I think it will be completely doable to baby the island surface a little.
    "Never go with a hippie to a second location." ~ Jack Donaghy, 30 Rock
  • imageMandyMilller:
    imagekris356:

    I like the wood/granite combo. But I chose wood for our counters in our renovation.

    Just an FYI, my mom has granite and the seller/installers told her always to use hot plates. While technically you can put a hot pot on the counter it is better not to on a regular basis.

    Yeah, I don't see me putting anything directly on the surface anyway! I worry too much!

    Where'd you get your wood counters?

    Ikea

  • imagekris356:
    imageMandyMilller:
    imagekris356:

    I like the wood/granite combo. But I chose wood for our counters in our renovation.

    Just an FYI, my mom has granite and the seller/installers told her always to use hot plates. While technically you can put a hot pot on the counter it is better not to on a regular basis.

    Yeah, I don't see me putting anything directly on the surface anyway! I worry too much!

    Where'd you get your wood counters?

    Ikea

    That's right. And they installed them for you? Were you responsible for staining or treating them with anything?

  • We are installing but they are treated and they recommend every few months use a wood conditioner on them. Basically you treat them like wooden cutting boards. But they have a 25 year warranty that extends to anyone who has the receipt. If you don't have a sink in the countertop, there isn't a whole lot to worry about. Since we are mountin a sink in it, we will probably seal it with Waterlox.

    They do offer installation services but we didn't do it.

  • I'd probably do the granite myself, just because I wouldn't want to have to worry about the upkeep on wood.
     
  • I like the look of the wood, but I would probably stick with granite.  I do ALL of my countertop work in the kitchen at my island, so I would want a surface there that is as durable and easy to clean/care for as possible. 
  • I would go with wood. I think the huge piece of granite looks cold. And agree, that those care items are no different than caring for any other countertop material. they all have limitations
  • We did a marble look quartz on our island (dark cabs) and wood on the perimeter (white cabs).  I love it.

    Jen & T.J. 6.17.06 BabyBlog * my chart *
    Joseph Henry was born at home on March 9, 2009
    Nora Mae was born at home on October 30, 2011
    image
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards