Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Newlyweds... roommates??

My husband and I are newlyweds and he wants us to consider having roommates. This couple are boyfriend/girlfriend and they've been dating for about 3ish years and they've broken up once, which I personally think made their relationship stronger, we habe known them for about 2 1/2 years, the boyfriend was one of our roommates (before we were married) best buds and he eventually moved in with us also, so we've already lived with the boyfriend. I like thr fact that rent would be cheaper considerig were struggling right now so could use a break, I also like that we'd all be together and can do things together. But we also already all go to the same gym and work-out together everyday. We all get along really well and haven't had any problems. We all also range from ages 21-23 

The other part of me that makes me not want to live with them is I love our privacy and I don't want this situation to ruin our friendship because this is really the only couple that we hang out with.

Please give me your thoughts and opinions, I'm so torn.  

Anniversary

Re: Newlyweds... roommates??

  • Well my own experience is I loved having a roommate while married to my husband. But I wouldn't choose to do it again. If that makes any sense. If I were you I wouldn't do it.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagemckinnonliz:

    I also like that we'd all be together and can do things together. But we also already all go to the same gym and work-out together everyday. We all get along really well and haven't had any problems.

    I'd be careful about these expectations.  Seeing someone every day for a couple hours then going your seperate ways is different than seeing them every day and then also going home with them.

    And it sounds like you kind of expect to be each others social lives. 

    Just be careful.  I think you'll all need your space/ couple time.

    I really feel like moving in w/ people you don't know well vs moving in w/ friends is better.  I've seen MANY friendships ruined once the people lived together. Living w/ someone is entirely different than being good friends.

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • It sounds like a really bad idea to me. 
    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
    TTC since September 2012
  • Living with another couple is not the same thing as living with the boyfriend. You'd have 2 couples with their relationship dynamics trapped under one roof. It sounds like a very bad idea and a perfect way to ruin a friendship. Why does your DH want roommates? Is it just finances? Could you consider a cheaper apartment instead?
    image Nicholas loved for 28 weeks, 4/11/10
    Baby Boy loved for 15 weeks, 5/31/11
    Baby Girl loved for 16.5 weeks. 3/1/12
  • I'd have to agree. The DH wants roommates because he sees it as cheaper rent, were actually in a pretty cheap place now, its just other finance problems have come along, I was temporarily laid off twice this last year and were still suffering. I think the DH also likes being able to have them around more, I also think he's kinda stuck being a kid and hasn't realized that we are married now. 
    Anniversary
  • I think it all depends how small the place is. If it's a small 2 bedroom apartment I would say nope, not enough space for 2 couples. If you're renting a house or duplex then you have a little bit more space and I would say go for it. We live in different times right now, where gas costs as much as rent and grocery prices are ridiculous. Being a young couple too I understand where you guys stand with trying to make it work with rent, gas, bills, food and honestly If I could find a roommate that we could both agree with I would do it. You gotta do what you gotta do sometimes to get by. 
  • We would for sure get a house or duplex the DH "has" to have a garage for his car, (boys and their toys) that's his only request whenever we moved. Anything else was left up to me. I'm just so torn because I don't want to ruin our friendship and I also don't want them in the middle of our marriage as I don't want to be in the middle of their relationship. I guess I should just sit down and right some pros & cons.
    Anniversary
  • What is this, an extension of college?
  • imagemckinnonliz:
    I think the DH also likes being able to have them around more, I also think he's kinda stuck being a kid and hasn't realized that we are married now. 
    And having them around more is NOT going to help your DH realize he's not a kid....

    So, from that perspective, I would not do this.  

    Yes, the $$ would be nice.  But I just feel like you're both approaching this from a "weee!!!  It would be so fun to have our best buddies around all the time!" and not really looking at the REALITY of what being w/ these people all the time will actually mean.

    And I agree- having A roommate (one person) is very different than living w/ another couple.  

    "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
    ~Benjamin Franklin

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  • NO, just no. The money is not worth the trouble. 
  • How long would you all be living together? A year lease?

    It would probably work fine for a few months! 

    I couldn't imagine living with another couple under the same roof. It would be hard to have privacy. Have you talked to your H about how you both think it would work out? Does H have any concerns?

  • This is a bad idea. Full stop. You are going to want private couple time, and even in a big house, they are still going to be there and you are not going to be truly alone.
  • You don't seem too concerned about your husband's immaturity.  Why is that?
  • imagemckinnonliz:
    I'd have to agree. The DH wants roommates because he sees it as cheaper rent, were actually in a pretty cheap place now, its just other finance problems have come along, I was temporarily laid off twice this last year and were still suffering. I think the DH also likes being able to have them around more, I also think he's kinda stuck being a kid and hasn't realized that we are married now. 

     

    I think that living with friends is NOT going to help him grow up...  It is only going to make him feel more like a bachelor living with his buddies. I have friends who got married and have his friends as room mates because they are trying to save up for a house, and they constantly have people over, never any real privacy. In order to get privacy at all they have to hide out in their room.  They haven't had a chance to enjoy eachother as newlyweds and are still kind of stuck in the college party scene.  I personally would not suggest living with anyone else, but that's jus tme... Good luck! :)

  • imagerenegade gaucho:
    You don't seem too concerned about your husband's immaturity.  Why is that?

    A very good question.  

  • imagerenegade gaucho:
    You don't seem too concerned about your husband's immaturity.  Why is that?

    Oh trust me I am concerned, were taking baby steps. Hes gotten better over thr last 4 years, I'm not trying to make an excuse for him, but I think his problem is/was that he had to grow up fast and had a lot of family problems and I was one of his only serious relationships. So I'm not sure,  he is only 23 and my dad always tells me it will take a while for him to "grow up". I love him for the way he is as for he loves me the way I am, so we just take it day by day.

     

    I have been thinking more about this and I've been leaning way more to saying NO to roommates because I agree with all of you, I guess I just wanted some more opinions to make sure that my decision wasn't a selfish act. 

    Anniversary
  • I'm glad you're leaning toward no.

    I am more antisocial than most people, so obviously I would never do this!

    It sounds like you and your H are more sociable than I am, but still I think you would regret this. If you do not move in together, I think you'll be able to fully enjoy and appreciate your friends, whereas if you become roommates I think it is inevitable that you guys will get on each others nerves at times and it could even end the friendship, at worst.

    I feel like you will be able to enjoy more aspects of your H if you and he do not live with others, and have more fun with your friends if you do not live with them.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Please don't do this. My husband and I had a one roommate that lived with us for 4 months. He is my husbands best friend. He moved in at a bad time. My husband lost his job and his best friend barely had a job himself. Instead of my husband focusing on getting another job, he felt like it was party time! Then, his friend was doing things that I wasn't agreeing with. Anyway, after arguing so much with my husband, finally the roommate moved out. Now, we are back on track with him looking for a job and him enrolling in a local university for a 2nd degree. It's not a good idea having extra people living with you when you are newly weds. Please, I beg you. Don't do this. Find a cheaper place or something. Because it will bite you in the behind later. 
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards