Relationships
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

brother has become a dead beat dad

Hi everyone, i am seeking some serious advice to give to my sister in law, and i know that everyone's answer for her will be "leave him" and she is already starting to consider it, so here we go...

 My niece, Adrianne was born May of last year, and from my knowledge of both sides, my brother does not help or take care of his daughter, his fiance, does everything and when he is asked to help he makes up an excuse, or says "why cant you do it?" and it has caused several fights between them, in which my sister in law says she wants to leave him and all he says is that he doesn't wanna breakup and become another statistic, and he is more concerned with what people will say and think, more then anything else, he spends maybe a few minutes with her, never takes charge for changing her, if she cries while they are sleeping he will get up and give her a bottle and go back to bed, He also raises his voice to her when she doesnt stop crying... this is a short glimpse of what my sister in law deals with, and has dealt with for the last year.. and she does not want to leave him only due to the fact of she keeps holding onto a hope he will change....which i really dont think will happen...i mean if it has not happened in the past year shes been around, why would it change?

I spoke to my sister in law last night and i felt like a beyond terrible sister for telling her to leave him..i love my big brother, hes my only sibling.. but he was not raised to act like this, i am very disappointed in him, but i care very much about my little niece and if he isn't going to be 100% Father figure, i think they should cut their losses and leave..

 Any opinions or advice? 

  

Re: brother has become a dead beat dad

  • Wellll.....to be honest, I think you've already crossed the line of 'minding your own business' and not getting involved, but really, I think this is something you should not be involved with at all. I realize it might be hard to avoid and I'm sur

  • Its a really tough situation, and yes you are right i SHOULD mind my business, but what am i supposed to say when i know my niece is being neglected by her own father who yes is my brother, is very hard not to want to step in and say "smarten the hell up"
  • Yea, I realize that it's a tough spot to be in, but still, it should not be your place to get involved because again, if you know what hits the fan, you are going to be blamed. It's kind of a lose lose situation, but if his FI is already feel

  • Yeah its super tough not to get involved and yes if *** does hit the fan the end result will suck... but i just dont think my brother cares anymore. if it doesnt benefit him, he doesnt care...  My sister in law is hanging onto a hope that he chang

  • Ohhhh...I'm really sorry about your parents. I'm sure if they were around, they would maybe kick some sense into your brother, or in the very least, say something because it is really not right how he is acting.

    Here's the thing though - your br

  • Thankyou, yeah i wish they were around, maybe its better that they arent, they would be ashamed of him if they seen the man he has became...or lack there of, it just angers me that he knew full well how much his life would change with a child, </p

  • Is he at least contributing financially to the household? Not that it makes his behavior any better, but if he wasn't even contributing financially, then that's even worse. Like I said, he might come around, but I highly doubt it. My ex was just like your
  • as far as i know he contributes to bills, but my sister in law constantly has to nag him for it, and sometimes hes short and she has to cover it, this isnt unusual behaviour, My brother used to ask my parents to help him pay his half of rent cause he blew
  • What kind d of man was your brother before the baby? Had they discussed having children? Did your brother want a child?

    I can't believe he was this wonderful responsable person and all of the sudden wasn't.

    I think your sister in law ma

  • imageburybuck0489:
    as far as i know he contributes to bills, but my sister in law constantly has to nag him for it, and sometimes hes s
  • Anyone who tells you "not to get involved" doesn't understand that you love your family and want to help!

     

    I would try to get your brother to attend parenting classes.  Another way to approach the situation is to STOP trying to g

  • imageprettywittyandi:

    Anyone who tells you "not to get involved" doesn't understand that you love your family and want to help!

    I

  •  and ps - this is not about 'not loving your family'. I love my family to pieces. But there's just some things I will not involve myself in for my own sanity. I am there to listen, but beyond that....

    OP even said herself that she's talked t

  • She's engaged to your brother and she's getting this kind of nonsense and static? Or are they legally married? In one instance you refer to her as his fiancee and in another, your in-law.

    She needs to get rid of him, stat...and stick with raising O
  • she is his fiance, so technically she is not my sister in law, but i feel strongly about her as part of the family so yes i do refer to her as a sister in law. 

    Its just a shitty situation, that i will keep my nose out of...but it hurts badl

  • imageburybuck0489:

    she is his fiance, so technically she is not my sister in law, but i feel strongly about her as part of the family s

  • ...Point her to these boards and maybe find 3-5 posts about 'husbands who never grew up and drain the life out of their spouses for years until eventually she leaves with years and energy wasted'. I'm sure you can find plenty! Maybe she would respond t

  • thats how i feel too, i hate to "meddle" in their business but that poor little girl deserves a father who will man up and take care of her... i spoke to my brother lastnight on the phone and did not mention anything but simply asked how he has felt since
  • imageprettywittyandi:

    I would try to get your brother to attend parenting classes.  Another way to approach the situation is to ST

  • imageburybuck0489:
    thats how i feel too, i hate to "meddle" in their business but that poor little girl deserves a father who will man
  • Believe me, i wanted "if you don't smarten up, and soon you are going to be left all by yourself" but something was just telling me not to say anything. And these "friends" which i wouldnt even call them that, friends dont down talk another persons sig

  • You know what then, maybe she really is better off. Not just her, but for the sake of their child too. If this is his attitude at this age, chances are, he's not going to change. There are some people who do, but that is very very rare.

    Anyway, j

  • Thanks for listening and giving such support and advice, i am very thankful that i am not in this situation, i mean my husband plays XBOX once in a blue moon.. but thats usually when the guys are over. so im pretty thankful that my hubby isnt like this, i
  • Don't feel bad for suggesting that bc he's your brother. I am so, so glad that my only brother has no kids (that we are aware of anyway). His life is a mess and I don't understand how he gets anyone to put up with his crap. He dated someone with a kid and
    IAmPregnant Ticker
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards