Sex & Romance
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Is my husband bisexual or gay? Found stuff he has posted on online forums

Help everyone! I recently found some posts that my husband has been posting online:

Here is what he posted:

For the last 10 years or so, I have gone back and forth on whether or not I could be "bisexual" or curious about sexual acts with guys. I have often fantasized about going down on a guy, and look at porn that includes those types of sex acts as well. I have never had an actual experience with a man, but am extremely curious about the act of giving oral sex. However, I am married to an amazing woman, who grew up conservatively and isnt as open minded as I would like. Shes not homophobic, but doesnt have much exposure to these types of things. Recently, my urges to experiment have gotten intense, and frequent. I find myself talking to quite a few female friends, and even family members about my situation in regard to my sexual orientation. I really want to tell my wife, but I am scared beyond belief that she will not understand, and freak out on me. To be quite honest, the fact that I have never had an actual experience sexually may not mean I am bisexual, but I do know that the urge to give oral sex is intense. It seems as though I can talk to everyone but her abotu this, and it has recently came back to bite me, as a couple of her siblings had people tell them I was questioning them in regard to how i came off sexual orientation wise. How do I tell my wife i have fantasies about men? Is there a way to somehow "gauge" her reaction, to see how she might react..or if she currently suspects anything? it should also be noted that I get teased all the time, and have been teased all my life because people think i am gay, or have those tendencies. The following incident happened over a year ago. so i look at the craigslist casual encounters section..alot. never respond to any ads or anything..but i like looking at the couples looking for men section.i search bi couples alot. anyways, about 8 months ago..i left it up on the browser. she saw it. asked me about it that night, and was like why were you on that site? i freaked out immediately and told her it was a pop up, and that i didnt go there on purpose. shes like bull, i clicked back..and saw the pages you looked at. she then asked if i was curious about what type of people posted on there, thats what i told her i mean. she then flat out asks..you arent gay are you? i say no immediately and shes like, then its not a huge deal, just dont lie to me about it. Ultimately, what I would like out of this entire situation is acceptance. My end goal is her accepting this part of me. I have really hated myself for the last how many years because of these urges. I look at a man, and immediately think of how nice his penis might look , or taste..or feel inside of me. Up until lately, the urges were just for the penis..but now..they are towards a certain guy. They have grown in a sense. I get very nervous and anxious around him, not to mention very aroused. Problem is, he is the husband of my wifes best friend. The other reason I want to know what she thinks is because every now and then, she will make little jokes, or comments that indicate to me she suspects something at the very least. She will randomly ask me if I am gay, and play it off as a joke..then when I ask her if she thinks I am, she says Cant you take a joke, I am just giving you a hard time. I honestly wish i knew exactly what my wife suspected/thought already..that way I think I could approach it better with her. If she does suspect something, then she is really good at hiding it because the times shes made jokes, i will ask her if she thinks i like men or something and immediately she says no. Another issue i am facing is i have talked to quite a few people. Her couple good friends know, which got to her sisters. The sisters said they wouldnt say anything and didnt want to get involved..but part of me wonders if someone will before i get a chance to talk to her. Does anyone have any suggestions on how to get more of an accurate read on her suspicions before I fully tell her? We have kind of talked about it, my wife and i. But it was over electronic means of communication. I am finding out who my true friends are with all of this, as a few of my guy friends wont even talk to me anymore. Was I wrong by talking to so many female friends? The wife and I have discussed it somewhat, over IM and such while I was at work. She basically told me that unless I would ever leave her for a guy, why make a big deal about it, or discuss it? Advice pleasE! My wife and I have an OK sex life. It doesnt happen very often, and is often quite boring when it does. I should add that the last 4 times my wife and i have had sex, i cant reach orgasm at all. Thats not good, especially when we are trying to have a baby. I guess I am just afraid to add more stress to her plate. She has a stressful job, there are alot of outside sources of stress and I guess I dont want to be another one of them. I mean, I honestly think she knows somewhat. She makes little jokes all the time..and when we were facebooking about it while i was at work, she told me that unless i want to leave her for a man, then she didnt want to discuss it, or make a big deal of it. I am also afraid that the amount of female friends and family members ive spoken with about it is going to haunt me, as it already has somewhat. Pleaseee help!

I am still seeking advice from female friends, and have actually been to a therapist in regard to the issue. Anyone have any advice? Thanks!

Re: Is my husband bisexual or gay? Found stuff he has posted on online forums

  • I can't say whether he is gay or bisexual, only he can.  It does sound like he obviously has feelings, fantasies, and thoughts about other men and has developed a sort of crush on someone.  I highly recommend couples counselling.  You two need to talk to each other about this.
    image
  • I think you need to sit down with him and have a talk with him.

    Is there a more or less public place where you can do it --- just to ensure he doesn't possibly cause a scene --- maybe a park or somewhere else similar?

    Or if you are sure he won't blow up or start a fight, do it at home when you and he have nothing to do and you can talk at length.

    Show him what you showed us. Maybe he will be relieved that you"found out" on your own.

    I suggest in the meanwhile, you see a sex therapist and a regular marriage counselor, on your own -- bounce this topic off them.

    You could decide to stay with your H and let him pursue sexual encounters with males and more or less let it be an open marriage.

    There is the risk of HIV, AIDS and other STDs, as you know. I don't know how open you are to an open marriage.

    Or you could decide to cut your losses and go.

    Couples counseling is what I also second.  Wishing you luck. (you can't live under a sword of Damocles and you can't be walking on eggs; talk to him)
  • edited October 2013
    PS: that he claims your sex life is "boring" pisses me off --- uh, did he ever sit down with you and discuss spicing things up? Did he ever try anything in the bedroom that YOU would perhaps like -- maybe maneuver you into a different position, try toys, try talking dirty, buy a sex manual, even bring home one of those silly sex games you buy in a lingerie store or sex shop....what did he do to make things more exciting????

     He is culpable for the "boredom." it takes 2 to tango -- and this also leads me to believe that you both have a snag in communication. You need help in that department.

    It is dicey for him to discuss this issue with female friends. He needs to talk TO YOU or to a professional about what he's experiencing!

    He also needs sex ed.

    Men can orgasm without ejaculating. They are not the same entity -- and is he so certain he is not attaining orgasm/ejaculating? If he is concerned about that problem, he'd see a urologist and a sex therapist.

    PSS: DO NOT TTC with him until you are clear about what path your marriage is going to take. Do not bring an infant into this picture while you and he are having a problem.

    And this is from APril of last year -- a year and a half ago....why have you let this go on so long???

    Hello all,

    I recently found out from one of my closest friends that my husband has been having lengthy conversations online with her, and quite a few other women. Apparently he has been asking them if they have ever wondered if he is gay or bisexual. I also recently found out he has asked one of my sisters. Should I be worried? It seems like he has done this alot with mutual female friends..

    From what he tells me, he gets alot of gay teasing, especially at work. From his family members, and i have teased him before, but in a very joking way. I discovered he had been looking at the casual encounters ads on craigslist, searching for "bisexual couples". I also found out he has talked to A LOT of females, asking them what they think. The most recent one was my sister, who told him that girls he has talked to came to her, wondering about him..thoughts?

  • To add to what the other posters have said: If you two decide to stay together while he explores this side of his sexuality and tries to figure out his orientation, he needs to do so safely. This means not meeting men on Craigslist, Grindr, etc. If you two decide to stay together, he'll need to make a commitment to you that he will practice safe sex, and this includes regular STI testing.
    imageimage
  • edited October 2013
    Also take into consideration what you will do if he is homosexual and not *just* bi.

    Have a Plan B ready.

    Either you will stay with him and accept that side of him (while he explores his sexuality and he's with partners of another sex) and let him have an open marriage or you will decide where to go from there.

    Suppose you do get pregnant and a child comes into the picture? Maybe you are not crazy about the idea of a gay father, or a mate that you might eventually divorce, where you child might have 2 dads.

    Put yourself first and stay safe. 

    He can't put your sexual health and overall health at risk. Bear that in mind.

    THis news is not great at all and considering how he was feeling "For years" perhaps he never should have married:

    I have really hated myself for the last how many years because of these urges. I look at a man, and immediately think of how nice his penis might look , or taste..or feel inside of me.

    Bear in mind a lot of gay men marry (and perhaps have kids) as they are making their way out of the closet.
  • I think you should also have a game plan going in to this conversation about what you will do in the potential scenarios that he is bi or gay.

    If he is bi, are you comfortable with him experimenting, or is that a dealbreaker? It's okay if it is; he has made vows to you. If he can no longer keep those, he needs to divorce you or at least ask for an open relationship before he start, because otherwise it is cheating. I realized after getting married that I am bi, and our marriage is not ending, but our solution may not work for you.

    If he is gay, of course, there is no real course of action here other than divorce. It's not fair to either of you to stay married to someone who is sexually incompatible, especially if you both want children eventually. (By the way, to echo Tarpon, STOP TTC IMMEDIATELY until this is resolved)
  • edited October 2013
    You could get a civil annulment if he is gay.

    If you are religious or spiritual and you are not embarrassed to speak to your minister, your priest, your rabbi or whatever applies, do speak to that person.  I recommend a secular counselor and, like I said, a sex therapist.

    You might also want to call PFLAG and see if you can get some resources. Perhaps there is somebody PFLAG can refer you to in the way of a support group for those who are married to spouses who are bi or gay.

    Take your time. You need not decide anything at all right now. Wishing you luck.
  • My favorite part is the line "... isn't as open minded as I would like". I cannot believe a man would actually think that his wife should be just fine with him having oral sex with other men. The moral decline in our society is just appalling. There is absolutely no understanding of what is right and wrong anymore. You poor woman. Go to counseling, but let me tell you- by the tone of that e-mail he wrote- he seems beyond repair in my opinion. 

    One thing that really bothers me is how people refuse to acknowledge the damage that pornography can unleash on a marriage. It is extremely destructive. 

    I am sorry you are going through this situation, I wish you luck and please don't have children with this man. 
  • ErikaB123 said:
    My favorite part is the line "... isn't as open minded as I would like". I cannot believe a man would actually think that his wife should be just fine with him having oral sex with other men. The moral decline in our society is just appalling. There is absolutely no understanding of what is right and wrong anymore. You poor woman. Go to counseling, but let me tell you- by the tone of that e-mail he wrote- he seems beyond repair in my opinion. 

    One thing that really bothers me is how people refuse to acknowledge the damage that pornography can unleash on a marriage. It is extremely destructive. 

    I am sorry you are going through this situation, I wish you luck and please don't have children with this man. 
    What?  If this guy is gay, porn did not make him that way.  The problem in their marriage is lying and lack of communication, not porn.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • The more i research on this, the more i find out. When he said "not as open minded as id like", i am pretty sure he means that i grew up fairly conservative and dont have much exposure to people who are gay or bisexual. To be honest, part of me has always kind of wondered if he was into men somewhat. 

    He has had trouble performing sexually in the past, and he does have feminine mannerisms. Not to mention my siblings have wondered as well.
  • edited October 2013
    This kills me. He complains about the wife not being "as open minded as I like" but at no time did he ever sit down and say, "Hon, let's get wild and sow our sexual wild oats together. I would like X Y or Z; what do you say?"

    "Beyond repair" inasmuch as he's already discussing with other women what he needs to discuss with his wife. This is beyond reproach --- he's disclosing a confidence, more or less. Yoo should have been pretty pissed he did this and you need to tell him to stop.

    This falls into the category of inappropriate communication. He had no business discussing this with anybody but you and a therapist.

    And no, porn had nothing at all to do with the fact a person is gay or bi. it's said that you already know what sexual orientation you are at about age 8. Kids know when they are different than other kids.

    Born that way, not made that way, by any external factor.  Song from a musical or not, "I am what I am" is where it's at.

    He is what he is and he's known what he was very early on in life but didn't come to terms with it until years later.

    There are lots of straight guys who have some effeminism.  And if he's had more than a just every once in awhile problem with performing, he needed to see a doctor and a urologist -- and if they both came up with nothing, then it's a psychological factor -- a sex therapist would have been next to see.

    There are a slew of issues here: this guy needs to learn how to be a team with his wife --- he can't go and disclose confidential information to other people (he did that by virtue of the fact he didn't discuss the issue with his wife) and he's reluctant to be open with her, period.

    As I said, you need to sit down and talk to him about what you found.  See a therapist and a sex therapist on your own before you do; go as many times as you think is necessary -- and then talk to him.

    Put yourself first. And hold up on TTC; stop doing it, as I said. You have a crisis in your marriage and you have to attend to it.

    If he married you while he was struggling with a sexual orientation issue, that's dishonest and wrong of him. He should have gone nowhere into the marriage zone until his orientation issue was resolved and he could more or less be a full time husband to you.
  • doeydo said:
    I can't say whether he is gay or bisexual, only he can.  It does sound like he obviously has feelings, fantasies, and thoughts about other men and has developed a sort of crush on someone.  I highly recommend couples counselling.  You two need to talk to each other about this.

    I ABOSLUTELY AGREE!!  My estranged husband is going through the same thing as your husband, the only thing is mine actually acted out those fantasies twice.. And I personally am having a hard time dealing with it because he never put my feelings first, like yours seems to be doing.  Kudos to him for actually taking YOU into consideration. My H actually knows hes BI atleast, and is having difficulties figuring out if he is completely gay or not.. He wont openly discuss it with me, nor will he attempt to ask my position on it.

    Take heed, and go see a marriage counselor. They will be able to help THE BOTH OF YOU walk this path together. It doesnt sound like your H is the type to act on his fantasies, but I would do this before he gets that sudden urge to. 

  • edited February 2014
    Jole5653 said:
    doeydo said:
    I can't say whether he is gay or bisexual, only he can.  It does sound like he obviously has feelings, fantasies, and thoughts about other men and has developed a sort of crush on someone.  I highly recommend couples counselling.  You two need to talk to each other about this.

    I ABOSLUTELY AGREE!!  My estranged husband is going through the same thing as your husband, the only thing is mine actually acted out those fantasies twice.. And I personally am having a hard time dealing with it because he never put my feelings first, like yours seems to be doing.  Kudos to him for actually taking YOU into consideration. My H actually knows hes BI atleast, and is having difficulties figuring out if he is completely gay or not.. He wont openly discuss it with me, nor will he attempt to ask my position on it.

    Take heed, and go see a marriage counselor. They will be able to help THE BOTH OF YOU walk this path together. It doesnt sound like your H is the type to act on his fantasies, but I would do this before he gets that sudden urge to. 

    Does not put you first and won't discuss anything with you.

    AND he is putting you at risk for STDs. You have no reassurance he has not been intimate with men and if he has, you have no promise he used protection...and what's more, he's committed adultery, if he was intimate with a guy he met!

    AND he was intimate with somebody else he had an affair with!

    What do you need him for?

    Ask yourself that.
  • ErikaB123 said:
    My favorite part is the line "... isn't as open minded as I would like". I cannot believe a man would actually think that his wife should be just fine with him having oral sex with other men. The moral decline in our society is just appalling. There is absolutely no understanding of what is right and wrong anymore. You poor woman. Go to counseling, but let me tell you- by the tone of that e-mail he wrote- he seems beyond repair in my opinion. 

    One thing that really bothers me is how people refuse to acknowledge the damage that pornography can unleash on a marriage. It is extremely destructive. 

    I am sorry you are going through this situation, I wish you luck and please don't have children with this man. 
    Oh yeah porn made this man gay. Give me a freaking break.    
  • edited March 2014
    ErikaB123 said:
    My favorite part is the line "... isn't as open minded as I would like". I cannot believe a man would actually think that his wife should be just fine with him having oral sex with other men. The moral decline in our society is just appalling. There is absolutely no understanding of what is right and wrong anymore. You poor woman. Go to counseling, but let me tell you- by the tone of that e-mail he wrote- he seems beyond repair in my opinion. 

    One thing that really bothers me is how people refuse to acknowledge the damage that pornography can unleash on a marriage. It is extremely destructive. 

    I am sorry you are going through this situation, I wish you luck and please don't have children with this man. 
    Oh yeah porn made this man gay. Give me a freaking break.    
    Yeah, I'll bet it was that one copy of Playboy or Penthouse or that one video he had lying around for eons that did it. Or maybe the porn he downloaded on line is what did it?

    I vote that she take what she found, print it out (screenshot it also) and show it to him --- and also show him the door -- if she is that uncomfortable about what she read.  This is going to hang over her head like a Sword of Damocles otherwise. What's the sense in staying silent about it at this point?

    I do not know her H's age. If he is young 20s it very well could be he might be in the experimental stage. It is hard to tell.
  • Sillygirl, I know this may be a total shock to you--but not everyone thinks like you do. We obviously have different views and to any open minded person that shouldn't be a problem. Did I ever once say that porn made him gay? NO, I didn't. Learn to read and make educated responses next time. 
  • If he wants to have a relationship or encounters with another man, try counseling for your marriage first. If he doesn't change his mind, it sounds like you will be getting a divorce. This is the same as if he cheated on you with a woman.

    Open marriages don't work. You are going to need to have a serious talk with him AND a counselor. This is not something that can be dealt with alone. And he does need to see a doctor if he is unable to ejaculate. He could have a health condition. That coupled with his curiosities may make him think he's gay even though he's just confusing one as causing the other. There could also be issues in the marriage you aren't addressing. There's more to this story. We don't need all the information, but the therapist you pick will need to know and so will your husband. You both deserve to have the whole truth.

    Good luck.
  • ErikaB123 said:
    My favorite part is the line "... isn't as open minded as I would like". I cannot believe a man would actually think that his wife should be just fine with him having oral sex with other men. The moral decline in our society is just appalling. There is absolutely no understanding of what is right and wrong anymore. You poor woman. Go to counseling, but let me tell you- by the tone of that e-mail he wrote- he seems beyond repair in my opinion. 

    One thing that really bothers me is how people refuse to acknowledge the damage that pornography can unleash on a marriage. It is extremely destructive. 

    I am sorry you are going through this situation, I wish you luck and please don't have children with this man. 
    Oh yeah porn made this man gay. Give me a freaking break.    

    ErikaB123 said:
    Sillygirl, I know this may be a total shock to you--but not everyone thinks like you do. We obviously have different views and to any open minded person that shouldn't be a problem. Did I ever once say that porn made him gay? NO, I didn't. Learn to read and make educated responses next time. 
    The damage to this relationship isn't pornography...not sure what else I was supposed to construe from your post.

    The damage is from a gay or bisexual man marrying a straight woman who isn't interested in an open relationship. 

    So, what was it that I did not understand from your post?
  • Oh, I went back and read some of your previous posts. Didn't realize you had an issue with masturbation and porn.

    Apparently you are letting your own personal issues cloud your advice for others. My H and I don't have these problems. Good luck to you.
  • @EricaB123...I went back and read OP's post as well as her one follow up. None of it mentions pornography or even masturbation, so what is your point?
  • If he is not experimenting, then it very well could be he is in the process of finding his way out of the closet.

    I personally wouldn't count on a marital future with a guy who *suspects* he is homosexual or bi.;
  • Sillygirl    " I have often fantasized about going down on a guy, and look at porn that includes those types of sex acts as well."   

  • Sillygirl, don't we all allow our "personal issues" effect the way we advise others? We learn from our experiences don't we? You seem to think that only your point of view is okay and the minute someone else thinks differently, you have to call them out (remember, you responded to my comment, I didn't seek you out). You apparently missed the sentence which states CLEARLY about pornography I have often fantasized about going down on a guy, and look at porn that includes those types of sex acts as well." 
  • artbyallieartbyallie member
    500 Comments Fourth Anniversary 100 Love Its First Answer
    edited March 2014
    Yeah, but Erika, the porn wasn't the cause of him fantasizing. His attraction to men was the cause of him fantasizing. The damage here is coming from his lack of ability to communicate openly and honestly. And it's perfectly acceptable for any or all of that (his same-sex attraction, bad communication, seeking out M4M personal ads) to be a dealbreaker for her. It's not fair for him to withhold that information knowing it might cause her to leave. It's not fair for him to stay with someone he's not comfortable sharing his whole self with.

    And in any case, the OP has not posted on this since October, so why are you trying to advise her now?
  • I missed that sentence. I still say porn is the least of OP's problems.
  • Wow. This is such a personal and complex situation unfortunately there is no definitive answer. But I would definitely confront him and seek counseling immediately. And not throw a baby into the mix. Good luck.
  • ErikaB123 said:
    Sillygirl, don't we all allow our "personal issues" effect the way we advise others? We learn from our experiences don't we? You seem to think that only your point of view is okay and the minute someone else thinks differently, you have to call them out (remember, you responded to my comment, I didn't seek you out). You apparently missed the sentence which states CLEARLY about pornography I have often fantasized about going down on a guy, and look at porn that includes those types of sex acts as well." 
    @EricaB123- I usually let personal attacks lie and don't respond. Sometimes I do (like now) but...I admit I am human and occasionally get annoyed by assumptions about me and I really try to 1) stick on topic unless OP or other posters take it elsewhere...in that post...and 2) be mostly respectful. 

    That doesn't mean not raising questions about what an OP or other poster respond...it just means I hope we can all see another's point of view. I understand some posters get upset or heated about what they may see as a personal attack. I see it as a constructive debate...but I also think if people can't take others not agreeing with them to the point of it really, really upsetting them...a public forum isn't for them. 

    If you notice, I've never marked another posters comment as abuse. You may tell me to go fuck myself and I don't see that as abuse. I see someone who is upset and is responding where they are at that time. That's ok with me. I'm only using that as an example. That was actually not even close to the nastiest thing I've been called or assumptions made about me. 

    I have said many things on here I rethought and either apologized for or just wished I hadn't said. However, I leave it as I wrote it because that is what I felt at the time and it may help someone else.

    No, I don't think porn is this OP's problem since her H was having issues that caused him to seek out gay porn. I don't feel that if he suddenly saw gay porn that would make him gay/bi. As you said, our personal experiences color our responses. My H doesn't care for much porn. He also feels hating gays is ridiculous since he doesn't remember when he chose to like vaginas. It was just always there. I can respect that and I love that he doesn't have issues with my gay friends. I feel the same way. 

    Apparently you have read my responses elsewhere and been offended by them. That's fine. We don't have to agree. That's the beauty of the internet. We may agree on one thing, and heatedly disagree on another. It's not like real life where people who like you may slightly bend their views to keep you as a friend and not upset you.

    Here, we can give our first knee jerk reactions...recant if we change our minds...and fight an issue to our detriment if we feel that strongly about it. Good luck to you!
  • aguyouthereaguyouthere member
    10 Comments Name Dropper
    edited May 2014
    ErikaB123 said:
    One thing that really bothers me is how people refuse to acknowledge the damage that pornography can unleash on a marriage. It is extremely destructive.
    We could look at this from another perspective and that is...people (that's both genders), don't stray, for no good reason. Albeit a sex addiction would do it too. Point is, burying one's head in the sand about the catalyst and blaming the outcome, seems to me to be a very misguided thought process.

    Hypotherically, if my partner woke up one day and decided she liked watching women have sex but didn't want to participate, I'd rather she achieved that gratification from "porn", than for me to make a song and dance about it, turning it into something she felt she had to hide and watch as it manifested itself into an obsessive taboo. Which could well lead to her wanting to try it with another women.

    What seems to destroy marriages is lack of honest and since communications between both partners. And, ground rules that no matter what is said, it will not be used against the other. Doing so forces people to hide their true feelings etc etc and the outcome of that, is never positive ;)

    Added: Ya know the people who are truly happy, content with their marriage or life partner, seem to have the knack for respecting each other and also the understanding an security that while they have committed to each other, they still remain two unique souls.
  • edited May 2014
    The OP is going to have to ask her H with no hesitation "Are you gay?"

    They say gay fantasies for males are common. They are also common for women, from what I have heard.

    And maybe he is still in the experimental stage.

    She needs to ask.

    She needs to tell him what she has found, and ask him why he's interested in pursuing that topic on line.

    And if he does not give an immediate "no" as a reply, she needs to decide whether to show him the door or stay married to him.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards