Married Life
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

I've never felt accepted by his family

While my husband and I have only been married for 2.5 weeks at this point, we dated for 5 years and were engaged for 2 years before the wedding happened, so we clearly have been together a long time. My family completely accepts him and LOVES him. My family calls him son, grandson, nephew, etc and always makes sure that he is included in everything. Birthdays and Christmas are big occasions in my family, and are always celebrated. Since the first birthday of his while we were dating, my family has held a party for him and gotten him gifts, same in price and value as what I receive on my birthday. Even before we were married, my parents introduced him as "son." His family is completely different with me and I'm not sure how to take it.

I'm still introduced as their son's gf/fiance/wife, not our daughter in law or daughter. I've never heard anyone in his family refer to me as granddaughter, niece, cousin, etc, in fact, it's like they don't consider me family because it's by marriage. When it comes to birthday and holidays, my husband and his sister always get more gifts and it's clear that more money was spent on them (and by "clear" I mean that I may have 1 gift that is about $20 in value, while they get 10+ gifts with at least $150+ value). Please understand that I'm not superficial and fake and all about money, but it feels like a slap in my face because it feels like they still think that I'm not a permanent part of the family and that eventually I won't be around anymore. Most of the time, my birthday is not even acknowledged by his family, including his parents! When it comes to holidays, I never really know if I'm invited by his parents/family, because I'm never included in the discussions. 

Am I being petty and superficial or do I have legitimate reasoning to feel hurt and slighted? At the least, I would just like to be accepted into his family, even if I'm never referred to as their daughter or granddaughter/niece/cousin, etc. 

Re: I've never felt accepted by his family

  • I would talk to your husband about this after some more time goes by. Every family is a little different. My hope is that they do care for you, they just have a different way of showing it, he might be able to shed more light on that. I would also assume they would have said something to him by now if they didn't like you.

    My MIL will refer to herself as "mom" to both of us, yet my SIL won't acknowledge me as the aunt of her children and we've been married 4 years, dated 4.5 years before that (there are other issues there.) My Mom had a problem with the term MIL and SIL saying that you only get one mother in life and she wasn't his mother. She at least had a conversation with my husband early on and explained she meant no offense when she said call me by my first name, not mom. Maybe even talk to your MIL and FIL and see where they stand? Perhaps they're in this same boat?

    Some families are just so close or have different traditions it's hard to break in. When DH and I  got married my SIL threw herself a baby shower on the same day as our wedding shower. Since her invitations "got out first" (mind you we didn't get invited) DH's entire family went to her shower. DH told me in his family you throw your own shower (even though I've always been told that's rude.) They never sent a card or gift afterward, didn't acknowledge our shower they were invited too. Since that's their tradition he didn't see it as them going against our marriage, that's just how they are. They wish me a happy birthday on Facebook but that's about it (no cards, calls etc.) Some families are just one sided, we go to everything they invite us too pending it works with the work schedule, yet they don't reciprocate and come to our stuff/how the same love. Doesn't mean they hate me that's just unfortunately how they are.

    Some older people feel the tradition is that you must be married to be part of the family. DH's Uncle and Aunt called me their niece after our wedding even though we were together 4.5 years before that. My MIL was the same way.

    As far as the gifts, what if you suggest not doing adult gifts, how would that go over? We started that after one year of giving everyone adult gifts at Christmas. DH and I gave nice, thoughtful, decently priced gifts (6 adults plus parents to shop for $20-$30 a person was a lot) and in return got a lot of cheap bubble bath. I'm not trying to be rude either, I just felt if that's what you're going to spend the money on save it and we'll do a night out after the holidays. Perhaps they don't know enough about you to know what to buy you either? I strongly feel that was half the point of the bubble bath was I don't know what you like so here's a standard "female" gift.

    Sorry for the long post, I'm glad to hear someone else is in the same boat as me, I really think DH's family is so different than the average family. Again talking it out with him will help.
  • My In-laws introduce me as their sons wife and it never seemed to bother me, because that's what I am. To me, I would not expect them to call the their "daughter" because they didn't raise me. I think the main difference here it what titles your family is comfortable using and what titles his family is comfortable with using, and it may not mean that they are trying to be offensive. Even so, by them saying "my son's wife" alone doesn't mean that they do not like having you around. For example, I love my sister-in-law (my brother's wife) and when I introduce her as so, I don't ever mean "she's not blood, so I love her less".

    If they call you their son's "girlfriend" or "fiancee" when they introduce you though, I would correct them with "wife". It may be just a honest mistake when they say it (assuming best intentions), but if you correct them each time, they will get the point pretty quick. If it keeps happening, I would calmly bring it up with them (or have your husband bring it up with them) and ask why they feel like they aren't comfortable with transitioning into calling you their daughter-in-law or their son's wife. This may be the cure for all feelings involved so they can voice how they feel on many of these topics an may clear up any misunderstandings on their end or yours. Good luck!
  • I think that you need to chill out on this for two reasons:

    1. Your family and his family are different when it comes to how they behave during holidays. Neither is wrong, just different. Easier to accept it than to fight it, I would think.

    2. You have only been married for 2.5 WEEKS. WEEKS. Have you even had a birthday since your wedding? It is common for many families to maintain a bit more distance while someone is a girlfriend or fiancee, regardless of how much time they've known them. Until the actual wedding that distance seems quite appropriate. 

    So you are speculating. You don't actually know if this will remain the case now that you are married - so I'd suggest that you relax on this issue and deal with it once it becomes an actual issue, not before.

    If they are still referring to you as a fiancee now chances are it is more out of habit than malice. Seriously. 2.5 WEEKS. You need to give this stage time.
    image

    Chronically hilarious - you'll split your stitches!
    I wrote a book! Bucket list CHECK!
  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    TBH, yes, you are being petty.  His family is different than yours.  Yes, yours sounds very warm and welcoming, and that's wonderful.  But clearly that's not how his family is.  This doesn't make them wrong - it just makes them different.  You HAVE to accept this.

    And in these 2.5 weeks, has there really been much opportunity for them to call you their daughter-in-law?  It might take them time to get used to the new term.  OR they might just always call you their son's wife. 

    And the gifts.  Oy.  I'll try to roll with that it's not about the money, but really... I don't understnad why spouses go into a marriage expecting to be treated like one of the kids.  Your family does this- that's VERY nice.  But it shouldn't be expected.  I never fault parents for giving their child more when it comes to gifts than their child's spouse.  It's their money - they can spend it however they want.  you marrying into the family doesn't give you any "rights" to their money. 

    Are they nice to you?  Do this acknowledge your presence?  Do they talk to you?  Do they include you in all their events?  If so- then they ACCEPT YOU.  Buying you presents or calling you "daughter" aren't the only ways that people show acceptance.
  • I understand some of your points and wanting to feel more like a family.  I get that.  However, I think your comments about gifts and how they get more than you from their own parents is actually quite childish and makes you sound spoiled.  
  • GilliCGilliC member
    Ancient Membership 5000 Comments 500 Love Its First Answer
    edited October 2014
    JennK1005 said:
    While my husband and I have only been married for 2.5 weeks at this point, we dated for 5 years and were engaged for 2 years before the wedding happened, so we clearly have been together a long time. My family completely accepts him and LOVES him. My family calls him son, grandson, nephew, etc and always makes sure that he is included in everything. Birthdays and Christmas are big occasions in my family, and are always celebrated. Since the first birthday of his while we were dating, my family has held a party for him and gotten him gifts, same in price and value as what I receive on my birthday. Even before we were married, my parents introduced him as "son." His family is completely different with me and I'm not sure how to take it.

    I'm still introduced as their son's gf/fiance/wife, not our daughter in law or daughter. I've never heard anyone in his family refer to me as granddaughter, niece, cousin, etc, in fact, it's like they don't consider me family because it's by marriage. When it comes to birthday and holidays, my husband and his sister always get more gifts and it's clear that more money was spent on them (and by "clear" I mean that I may have 1 gift that is about $20 in value, while they get 10+ gifts with at least $150+ value). Please understand that I'm not superficial and fake and all about money, but it feels like a slap in my face because it feels like they still think that I'm not a permanent part of the family and that eventually I won't be around anymore. Most of the time, my birthday is not even acknowledged by his family, including his parents! When it comes to holidays, I never really know if I'm invited by his parents/family, because I'm never included in the discussions. 

    Am I being petty and superficial or do I have legitimate reasoning to feel hurt and slighted? At the least, I would just like to be accepted into his family, even if I'm never referred to as their daughter or granddaughter/niece/cousin, etc. 
    My parents completely adored my H, but they never spent as much on gifts as they did on me. They also didn't call him on his birthday. But that's not surprising, because they don't always call me on my birthday, and I was ripped screaming out of my mother's stomach! ...come to think of it, that must have been traumatic. Maybe my birthday is not her favorite memory! ;)

    However, my H's parents call every year without fail. Because that's what they do! We're divorced, and they still call me on my birthday, because we're still friends and birthday wishes are a big deal in their culture.

    image
    image
  • Thank you everyone for your feedback, I appreciate it. Now that people think I'm superficial and all about the money, guess it's a good time to elaborate on something I just skimmed over before-I'm NOT included in a lot of things with his family. Holidays and family functions are normally planned for my husband, his sister, and their parents. It's not until my husband mentions something about me that I'm even thought of. When we go visit, his family seems surprised, and unprepared for, me to be there as well. If tickets or reservations are needed for something, they are made for 4 people, not 5. Oh, and did I mention they didn't want to come to our weddin because it "cost too much for them to get there?" As for being acknowledged by them? Yeah, sure, if by being acknowledged you mean a quick hello and then not being spoken to again.

    I promise you it's not about the money, it's about wanting to be accepted by his family. About them wanting me to be around instead of being upset that I'm there. Everyone's family is different and I'm willing to accept that, but if I'm not included in family functions, will our future kids be? I was unwanted by my Dad's parents and I always felt and knew that. I dreaded family functions because I knew it would be another day of sitting and having dirty looks given to me, just for being born. I NEVER want my children to have that experience that I had.

    For now I will chill out and hope that it's how you said, and they have just kept their distance because we weren't married, but I'm still leery.
  • VORVOR member
    Eighth Anniversary 500 Love Its 500 Comments Name Dropper
    JennK1005 said:
    good time to elaborate on something I just skimmed over before-I'm NOT included in a lot of things with his family. Holidays and family functions are normally planned for my husband, his sister, and their parents. It's not until my husband mentions something about me that I'm even thought of. When we go visit, his family seems surprised, and unprepared for, me to be there as well. If tickets or reservations are needed for something, they are made for 4 people, not 5. Oh, and did I mention they didn't want to come to our weddin because it "cost too much for them to get there?" As for being acknowledged by them? Yeah, sure, if by being acknowledged you mean a quick hello and then not being spoken to again.
    Well, JFC.  How are we supposed to know this if you don't TELL us?  This is an entirely different situation and on this note... A:  they sound like assholes.   And B: your DH needs to do more to stand up for you and fight for you.  He needs to stop going to these gatherings if they continue to "be surprised" when you come, or when they only buy 4 tickets, etc.

    This is VERY much about your DH and how he handles them.  Simply "reminding" them that you'll be coming too isn't enough.  He needs to tell them in no uncertain terms that if they don't start to consider you part of the family and include you without him having to "remind" them, then they won't be seeing HIM anymore either.
  • You are leaving out some important info. Together for 5 years and they seem surprised you're there? They didn't come to the wedding? They ignore you the whole time you're around? Something tells me that you're leaving out a lot of drama. Like maybe you broke up a lot or he was dating other people during the 5 years. Or you're not very outgoing and wait for everyone to talk to you throughout every visit. Something is missing here.
    ********************************************* ================================================== *********************************************
  • 1. I feel weird if my in laws called me their daughter.  I'm not... I don't call them mom and dad because I have a mom and dad and it feels weird to me to call someone else that.

    2. They definetely seem to be leaving you out.  They're surprised you're there???  Wowzers.  This is all up to your DH to fix.  He should not accept this behavior and needs to put his foot down.  You shouldn't feel like an outsider.
  • Samboni said:
    You are leaving out some important info. Together for 5 years and they seem surprised you're there? They didn't come to the wedding? They ignore you the whole time you're around? Something tells me that you're leaving out a lot of drama. Like maybe you broke up a lot or he was dating other people during the 5 years. Or you're not very outgoing and wait for everyone to talk to you throughout every visit. Something is missing here.
    Not necessarily true. Sometimes people act like jerks without provocation. My MIL has ignored me and treated me differently than her other DIL since day one, even when I told her I'd love to have a relationship with her. She smiled to my face and then continued behaving in the same underhanded ways.
  • We got married this summer and my inlaws completely forgot about my birthday. No phone call, no text, not even a Facebook message. They know when my birthday is, they got me gifts for the 4 years before we were married but I guess this year it was just too hard to even pick up the phone. I have never felt accepted by them either. They were super negative during our entire engagement and said a lot of shit behind my back that I haven't forgiven them for.

    The worst part is the H has confronted his mother about it on 2 different occasions, as she is the one doing all this shit, and she completely turned it around on him and tried to blame him. After these confrontations, she acts like nothing happened and we have no reason to be distant with them.

    The biggest thing is to just talk it out with your H and make sure you're on the same page. Maybe he'll know a way to get in with them, or maybe you're "blessed" with inlaws like mine who are barely believable as human beings and act worse than children. In that case, keep your distance. It's not worth all the drama and it put a lot of unneccesary stress on our relationship before we limited them from our lives. Good luck!

     

  • I kind of feel the same way but at the same time my h has virtually nothing to do with his family :-S
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Several of you need to stop sweating the small stuff. The drama that's being created over small things...mindblowing. "I'm still introduced as son's wife, and not daughter or DIL." Well, that's fine. They may never call you daughter. Whoopie! LOL. You whole post is full of petty stuff as are most of the bandwagon posts. It might help some of you to reach out to your inlaws on your own. Go shopping with your MIL or do something without your H around. You know, crap a daughter does. Just enjoy your life and stop looking for and adding up faults in people. We all have our own way of doing things.
    ********************************************* ================================================== *********************************************
  • Yeah this sounds like a difference in family culture.  My parents do "son-in-law" if I'm not around at the introduction and "our daughter's husband" if I am.  They were not the warmest ILs to him at first, but we are also just a little more introverted as a family unit so it was understandable.  We've been married a little over a year and it is improving so I am not going to try and force it to go any faster than it is right now.

    In my family, if you were not engaged, you were not assumed to be invited to things.  Nothing rude, and if I said "Can he come along?" they usually said yes or gave a reason why not.  I never assumed he was invited unless explicitly told so.  I went to my cousin's wedding without him (4 years into dating) because he was not on the invitation (and no "and guest" either) and my aunt thought it meant he and I were broken up until I told her that my name was the only one on the invite so I was the one who showed up.  She apologized for it, I was not offended, but clearly we assumed two different things.  That may explain why they never had a ticket for you, weren't planning for your arrival, etc.  

    As far as the gift thing, my MIL gives both of her DILs a nice gift.  Her sons get more.  It has never once bothered me.  Those are her sons, and I see it as her giving them extra instead of giving us less.  That makes sense to me. 

    I would give them some time to warm up, since it was a whopping 2.5 weeks of marriage when you posted this.  Your ILs don't suddenly have a bond with you because you married their son, that takes time.  They also may never be as warm and fuzzy as your family is.  Stop looking for evidence they dislike you until it slaps you in the face.  You will have plenty of other things to argue about as newlyweds.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards