Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

Oh The Holidays

So even though there is no interest in mine and my husband's life together my MIL keeps mentioning that we should take over her holidays because she doesn't want to host anymore and is pretty forceful about it.  I keep saying we will do holidays at our home when we decide to and my husband just encourages her (I know we need to get on the same page it's something we are working on).  I have a few issues with this but my main issue is that we travel during all of the holidays to spend some time with my parents who do not live by also I know all of the responsibilities will fall on me which I am not ready to take on at this point.  Eventually my parents will sell their home that I grew up in and move closer but until then we are enjoying what holidays we see each other in my childhood home.  Bottom line is that I am tired of MIL pushing all of her distant relatives and her holidays on me, she has gone as far as to plan out how I will host this event.  I know it would be better coming from my husband but I am wondering if I should just let her know what we will not be having the holidays this year and we will let her know when we are ready. 

Re: Oh The Holidays

  • If your DH won't do it, then yes, do it.  Don't get into over explanation, though.  Leave it simple.  "I appreciate that you don't want to host the holiday's again. However, as we're traveling again this year, we'll be unable to do it.".  Period.

    She starts to throw out "how" you can still do it (different day, traveling at a different time, etc) - smile and stand firm and say "As I said, we won't be hosting this year."  PERIOD. 

    The less you say, the less she can argue.

  • You say your husband encourages her, what does he do? Maybe he wants to start hosting?
    If that's the case then you have a DH issue.
    As to your MIL, a simple "We will not be hosting this year." Is all you need to say.
  • So even though there is no interest in mine and my husband's life together my MIL keeps mentioning that we should take over her holidays because she doesn't want to host anymore and is pretty forceful about it.  I keep saying we will do holidays at our home when we decide to and my husband just encourages her (I know we need to get on the same page it's something we are working on).  I have a few issues with this but my main issue is that we travel during all of the holidays to spend some time with my parents who do not live by also I know all of the responsibilities will fall on me which I am not ready to take on at this point.  Eventually my parents will sell their home that I grew up in and move closer but until then we are enjoying what holidays we see each other in my childhood home.  Bottom line is that I am tired of MIL pushing all of her distant relatives and her holidays on me, she has gone as far as to plan out how I will host this event.  I know it would be better coming from my husband but I am wondering if I should just let her know what we will not be having the holidays this year and we will let her know when we are ready. 
    She pushes her relatives on you?

    If you don't know them or you are not crazy about them, you are not obligated to entertain them.

    Tell her what you told us. "We will not be hosting the holidays this year; we've made other plans quite some time ago. We will let you know when we will host a holiday" and as an option, you can add "and we will invite you" but that's up to you.:)
  • I see two issues stemming from the fact that your MIL no longer wants to host the family holidays anymore. 

    1) Her continual desire to hand over the mantle onto YOU.  
    2) The fact that you all are not recognizing HER desire to stop being the very thing YOU do not want to be...i.e. You still go to her house for the holidays even though she has hinted that she doesn't want to do it anymore. 

    I mean lets be honest here...she is more than likely being pushed and guilted the same way you are.  Only for her, if she doesn't do it, then no one will.  

    Now that doesn't mean that you should, but it does mean that there are other options for YOU and YOUR DH to do 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • VOR said:

    If your DH won't do it, then yes, do it.  Don't get into over explanation, though.  Leave it simple.  "I appreciate that you don't want to host the holiday's again. However, as we're traveling again this year, we'll be unable to do it.".  Period.

    She starts to throw out "how" you can still do it (different day, traveling at a different time, etc) - smile and stand firm and say "As I said, we won't be hosting this year."  PERIOD. 

    The less you say, the less she can argue.


    I agree with this, you do not need to justify your decision, but make sure that you are on the same page as your husband.  It would make things far worse if he played it off like it is all your decision.  You need to have a united front on this.

    Be the change you want to see in the world!

  • Where are these distant relatives when it is time to host?

    I am curious.....are you NOT going to her house for the holidays, instead visiting your parents? Or are you going to her holidays some holidays / some years?  Or eating at her house, but don't want to host because the next day you will leave for your parents' home and you don't want a mess to clean up right before you leave? 

    I do think it is wrong to keep expecting MIL to host if she is not interested in hosting anymore.  It is just as wrong for you/H to assume you will eat at her home as it is for her to expect to eat at yours. 

    You do not have to host, but maybe you could come up with some ideas to make her life easier - such as sending hubby over early to help her cook / clean up (after all, he apparently loves this tradition sooooo much!), volunteering to bring over some dishes, or even suggesting you eat at a restaurant and everybody pays their own way.  One restaurant in my area will bring a full turkey to the table if you have more than 4 people ($25 pp!  much less than what I spend to host each year!).  Many grocery stores will provide a catered meal for a reasonable cost.  Maybe chip in with the cost and have ShopRite make the meal?  Of course, your MIL can refuse your offers, but it doesn't mean that holidays have to be done HER way ONLY.  You can walk away knowing you offered ways to help her out.

    I also think that if you make the choice to host, you are not required to replicate her feasts and guest list.  If you don't want to invite her distant relatives - you don't need to.  They can always find another place to celebrate.  You can keep the guest list as small as MIL and you and DH.  In fact, you can say outright to MIL "when I start hosting, I will not be hosting dinner for 14.  It will just be you, me, and DH."  You do not HAVE to include HER relatives.  Maybe her parents (DH's grandparents) or someone DH is especially close to.

    I speak as someone who does not mind hosting Thanksgiving, and I invite everyone - because I want to!!!  I refuse to host Christmas because I want to enjoy the time with my kids and not worry about cleaning or cooking.  It is not fun for me and I put my foot down on that one.  But I know it used to bother my mom when she hosted EVERY d*mn holiday (Christmas & Thanksgiving) EVERY year and her SIL would waltz into our home, fork ready to eat, and NEVER EVER hosted. 


    image "Before you diagnose yourself with depression or low self esteem, first make sure you are not, in fact, just surrounded by assholes.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards