Family Matters
Dear Community,

Our tech team has launched updates to The Nest today. As a result of these updates, members of the Nest Community will need to change their password in order to continue participating in the community. In addition, The Nest community member's avatars will be replaced with generic default avatars. If you wish to revert to your original avatar, you will need to re-upload it via The Nest.

If you have questions about this, please email help@theknot.com.

Thank you.

Note: This only affects The Nest's community members and will not affect members on The Bump or The Knot.

DH's best friend dating his younger sister and it's AWKWARD

My H and I have been together for 7 years and just recently got married at the beginning of October. We were high school sweethearts at a small high where there are only about 700 students, teachers, AND staff for the 7-12th grade. My H is 24, I'm 23, and his sister is 21. Since my H didn't move to our area until the 7th grade, I was actually friends with some of my H's current friends before he was (i.e. I knew his best friend back in kindergarten and while we have never been close, we have always been friendly). Anyway, at our wedding, we noticed H's best friend was spending a lot of time with his younger sister. He kept asking her to dance and buying her drinks, etc. We didn't think too much of it, figured he was just being nice since they were both in the wedding party. Well the day after our wedding, he texted my H and said he was interested in H's sister and wanted to know if H minded if he dated her. My H and I both thought it would be a little weird (especially since H and I are long distance right now while trying to obtain our degrees and I live with his sister so I would be around everytime his best friend came to visit) to see his best friend with his younger sister, but in order to keep them from going behind his back and having a secret relationship, he went for a neutral answer of "do whatever you want, I'm not getting in the middle between you two if anything happens." His best friend is a really great guy and like I said, I've known him since kindergarten, so we know he will treat H's sister right. The issue is that H's sister is a user. She doesn't really date guys, she uses them until they stop spending money on her and then she dumps them. H comes to visit me every weekend and since I live with his sister, we spend a lot of time with her as well. Now that she is "dating" (they won't tell us if they are actually dating and we are pretty sure we are the only ones who know they are spending time together) his best friend, things have gotten a little awkward/strange when the four of us get together. We want to tell his best friend about his sister, but don't think his best friend would believe us, and don't want to deal with his sister after she finds out we told him. H and I were trying to act like adults and spend time with his sister and best friend when they were at the house, but like I said, it's awkward for H and I because we know his sister is probably just using his best friend. We tried talking to the two of them and letting them know how we feel about their relationship and that we thought things were a little awkward. We also told them that for a while, we were just going to pretend like we didn't know his best friend and let them start/form their "own" relationship without our interfering. They just brushed our feelings off and told us if/when things ended, we would all act like adults and go back to the way things were (easy for them to say since they aren't the commonality here). Also, the conversation almost seemed to start a challenge to them; when they know we are around, they are as touchy-feely and "couple-y" as they can be (again because they know it makes us uncomfortable), but when they don't think we are around, they just act normal and like friends in a new relationship. In order to try and deal with this in our own way, H and I have decided to spend more time alone and less time with them. His sister is now saying her brother "hates her and is grumpy whenever she comes around on the weekends." His best friend is also acting weird and goes back and forth between trying really hard to include us in their conversations, to completely ignoring us, even when H's sister is not around. So the whole "acting like adults" thing has already gone wayward. We just aren't sure how to handle this: should we tell his best friend his sister is a user and deal with her later? Should we just let things work themselves out? Are we being ridiculous by not spending time with them, even if we aren't sure they really want us around anyway? My H was hurt to find out his sister said those things about him as the 3 of us had formed a pretty close relationship before his best friend came into the picture. We want his sister and best friend to be happy and if that's with them being together, we will eventually be ok with it. But right now, we are uncomfortable because we don't think they are together for the right reasons. 

Re: DH's best friend dating his younger sister and it's AWKWARD

  • My father's sister married his best friend.  His sister in law also married his brother.  My FIL's sister married my MIL's brother.  This is not weird or awkward. 

    My father's sister and his best friend have had a very tumultuous marriage.  My father has never said a word, nor would he.  It's none of his business.  This is none of your business.  I think it's ridiculous not to spend time with your friend and sister, who you both individually like, just because you don't approve of their relationship, but if you can't keep your mouths shut, then stay away from them.  
  • I am not sure why you are surprised by your SIL's comments.  

    1) You have assumed and disparaged her personality about her past relationships and the current one.  I mean has she actually told you, "I stopped dating him because he stopped buying me things?  Because normally, when an relationship is ending, the couple start pulling back on all things, sex, outings and yes, spending cash.  

    And you KNOW that your disapproval, while not spoken has been made loud and clear through your attitudes. 

    2) And even IF she was like that in the past, who are you to say that her feelings for your DH's BFF are not true?  Who are you to say that she has not grown up a bit...just like you. 

    3) And finally YOU WERE THE ONES THAT PULLED BACK FROM THEM, WITHOUT ANY CONVERSATION, FIRST. 

    And yet, somehow your confused SIL is wrong for expressing the concern that her brother has issues with her because he and his wife have stopped hanging around with her?  

    I mean, lets be honest, YOU were talking behind HER back first.  So why are YOU justified, but SHE is not?
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I'm with Ilumine on this.  It's awkward because YOU and your DH made it awkward.  If you hadn't talked to them and made a point to say it would be weird- it might not haven been weird.

    Maybe she is a user, who knows.  But your over concern and angst about this whole thing seems really weird.

    You seem annoyed that they 'brushed off' your feelings, but aren't you brushing off theirs too?  They're happy for now.  they're enjoying this.  But because you don't think it's right, you feel they should just blindly listen to you?? 

    As they ARE adults, of COURSE they're going to want to figure this out for themselves and make their own choices! 

    Again- this is all just quite weird.
  • It is not a situation that neither YOU or your DH should try to control or even get involved.  Your DH's friend and his sister are both adults and can handle things on their own.

    I don't understand why you both feel the need to get involved, or maybe it's just you pushing your husband to see things the way you do. Maybe you have an interest in his best friend and it bothers you that he might find happiness with someone else.

    Whatever the reason is, IT IS NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS!!!   

  • I have not assumed anything about his sister, I know for a fact that she is a user because she is like this in ALL aspects/relationships in her life, including with her brother and myself. She doesn't have many friends because they all realize the same thing, THEY end up paying for everything they do with her and she only talks to them when she wants something. As for knowing she is like this with guys, I do know for a fact that is why her most recent relationship (before DH's best friend) was ended. Her last boyfriend really loved her and wanted to make things work, but he just didn't have the money anymore, and when things started really going south, he contacted me. Him and I had become friends throughout their relationship and he was really upset with how things were ending and he needed someone to talk to about it. 

    We aren't saying that her current feelings aren't real right now, we are just WORRIED that they aren't. We have seen her use many guys before, but could do nothing about it because we didn't know them enough to personally talk to them. This time it's a close friend to both of us, and we don't want to see him, or DH's sister get hurt. I can FULLY reassure you that I do NOT have feelings/an interest in my DH's best friend! I could have had my chance with the guy in the past, but I LOVE my DH and chose to be with him. The only interest I have in him, is our FRIENDSHIP, which I don't want ruined by his being used by my sister-in-law.

    We DID have a conversation with them before we started pulling back. I mentioned that above. We told them how we felt and that for a while we were just going to pretend like we didn't know DH's best friend and let them form their own relationship. Like I said, that's when things became a challenge and they started becoming more physical in public whenever we were around, but not when we weren't. Other than that, we are not getting involved; I was asking if we should, but based on everyone's advice, we definitely should not. And can you please tell me how I was talking behind her back first? I appreciate everyone's advice (that's why I posted on here), but I'm just confused as to how I am talking behind her back?
  • Still all weird. You acted like you didn't know him? Huh? Of course that changed your dynamic with them. And if she's such a user, why are you lving with her? Maybe that's a part of the problem.
  • puppylove2014puppylove2014 member
    100 Comments 25 Love Its Name Dropper
    edited November 2014
    This is none of your buisness.

    You think she was in the wrong with her ex because "he really loved her and wanted to make it work"? You have no idea what their relationship really was. Really wanting it to work quite often is not enough. She doesn't have to settle for the first "nice guy" that comes along. 

    IF she is a gold digger and a guy too dumb to realize they are being used, too bad for them. It can be a good life lesson.

    They are young and having fun dating whomever they choose. Stop judging and be happy they are happy. Be there for them if they need someone to lean on. That is what friends are for. Not judging and blowing things out of proportion.

    Not everyone marries their high school sweetheart...nor should they. Honestly, your whole post sounds very small town and gossipy. I'm sure there is plenty people could judge and comment on about your relationship too and I'm sure you wouldn't like it. So don't do it to people you're supposed to care about.

    The only one making this awkward is you.
  • When does your lease end? I would consider moving out and not living with SIL any longer than you have to. You obviously do not have a high opinion of SIL, and the potential for drama bothers you. There are plenty of other roommates you could choose without the family baggage.
    image "Before you diagnose yourself with depression or low self esteem, first make sure you are not, in fact, just surrounded by assholes.
  • JennK1005 said:
    I have not assumed anything about his sister, I know for a fact that she is a user because she is like this in ALL aspects/relationships in her life, including with her brother and myself. She doesn't have many friends because they all realize the same thing, THEY end up paying for everything they do with her and she only talks to them when she wants something. As for knowing she is like this with guys, I do know for a fact that is why her most recent relationship (before DH's best friend) was ended. Her last boyfriend really loved her and wanted to make things work, but he just didn't have the money anymore, and when things started really going south, he contacted me. Him and I had become friends throughout their relationship and he was really upset with how things were ending and he needed someone to talk to about it. 

    We aren't saying that her current feelings aren't real right now, we are just WORRIED that they aren't. We have seen her use many guys before, but could do nothing about it because we didn't know them enough to personally talk to them. This time it's a close friend to both of us, and we don't want to see him, or DH's sister get hurt. I can FULLY reassure you that I do NOT have feelings/an interest in my DH's best friend! I could have had my chance with the guy in the past, but I LOVE my DH and chose to be with him. The only interest I have in him, is our FRIENDSHIP, which I don't want ruined by his being used by my sister-in-law.

    We DID have a conversation with them before we started pulling back. I mentioned that above. We told them how we felt and that for a while we were just going to pretend like we didn't know DH's best friend and let them form their own relationship. Like I said, that's when things became a challenge and they started becoming more physical in public whenever we were around, but not when we weren't. Other than that, we are not getting involved; I was asking if we should, but based on everyone's advice, we definitely should not. And can you please tell me how I was talking behind her back first? I appreciate everyone's advice (that's why I posted on here), but I'm just confused as to how I am talking behind her back?
    My opinion still hasn't changed.  This is NONE of your business.  You seem to hate your SIL yet you said you were close to her before this relationship began.  Don't be friends with someone you have such a low opinion of.  Keep your mouth shut.
  • If you are so concerned that she may be using him, then husband needs to do some guy time with BF and tell him that while he doesn't mind BF dating his sister, he does have some concerns that he has based on her past behavior. Husband needs to make sure BF knows he isn't saying don't date my sister, but just keep your eyes open to some of these behaviors & then let BF make decision from there. For all you know, maybe all her prior relationships were with jerks and so she took advantage of things but if the BF is a good match for her, her behavior could change with him.

    And it also sounds like you need to find some alternative locations, as do they, to hang out to have some alone time. Maybe walks in the park, or the mall, but just try to anything. Maybe even explan to her that while you are happy for them, it's weird for husband to think about his BF and his little sister hooking up. That maybe on the weekends if they could hang out at his place and then just make

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards